Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Epistemology (Anthropology)

description482 papers
group18,906 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Epistemology in anthropology examines the nature, sources, and limits of knowledge within the discipline. It explores how cultural contexts influence the understanding and interpretation of human behavior, social practices, and beliefs, emphasizing the relationship between knowledge production and the anthropological study of diverse societies.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Epistemology in anthropology examines the nature, sources, and limits of knowledge within the discipline. It explores how cultural contexts influence the understanding and interpretation of human behavior, social practices, and beliefs, emphasizing the relationship between knowledge production and the anthropological study of diverse societies.

Key research themes

1. How do epistemological frameworks shape anthropological knowledge production and reflexivity?

This theme explores how anthropology as a discipline conceptualizes knowledge, who is recognized as a knower, and how reflexive practices and citation politics influence epistemic authority and the boundaries of expert knowledge production. It is crucial for understanding anthropology's internal self-critique, its methods, and the politics of representation amid ongoing social and disciplinary transformations.

Key finding: The paper identifies a complex evolution of epistemological approaches within Medical Anthropology Quarterly over almost five decades, revealing tensions between biomedical epistemic dominance and vernacular or alternative... Read more
Key finding: Through a reflexive examination of citation and acknowledgment practices, this paper demonstrates how disciplinary conventions produce an epistemic hierarchy distinguishing interlocutors from scholars, often erasing... Read more
Key finding: This article innovatively applies a 'not-knowing' epistemological stance through collaborative reflexive writing, using esoteric communication devices like tarot and astrology to reveal how ethnography can embrace uncertainty... Read more

2. What roles do alternative epistemologies and ontologies play in understanding cultural and religious practices within anthropology?

This research area investigates how anthropological approaches engage with non-Western, spiritual, and non-material epistemologies and ontologies, including the challenge of moving beyond semiotic reductions and positivist paradigms. It focuses on the epistemological pluralism needed to grasp phenomena such as live stones, religious rituals, and uncertainties in human-environment relations, emphasizing the importance of integrating diverse forms of knowledge systems and experiential realities.

Key finding: The paper critiques the limits of semiotics in anthropology by introducing the concept of the 'onton'—an indivisible, nonrepresentational entity—arguing that live stones in West African shrine contexts are better understood... Read more
Key finding: The work proposes a dual perspective distinguishing the religious and the paranormal under an 'extended naturalism' framework to reconfigure the boundaries of reality, addressing marginalization under positivist and... Read more
Key finding: This article applies agnotology—the study of ignorance—to religion, revealing how the deliberate construction and maintenance of ignorance ('agnomancy') operate within religious domains to sustain belief systems. It... Read more

3. How does epistemic pluralism challenge unified accounts of knowledge and impact anthropological methodologies?

This research question addresses philosophical debates within anthropology and epistemology regarding whether knowledge can be reduced to a unified epistemic framework or whether diverse, context-dependent linkages between beliefs and facts support pluralism. It considers how epistemic pluralism calls for methodological openness to different forms of knowledge-making and acknowledges uncertainty, thus influencing ethnographic methods and interdisciplinary dialogues.

Key finding: The paper argues convincingly that the quest for a unified, singular account of the belief-fact linkage constituting knowledge is misguided and that epistemic pluralism—accepting multiple, context-sensitive forms of... Read more
Key finding: This work conceptualizes uncertainty not as a mere absence of knowledge but as a constitutive element of late industrial environments and the knowledge practices situated therein. It advocates treating uncertainty... Read more
Key finding: The essay critically revisits three major criticisms of the concept of belief in anthropology, demonstrating through historical textual analysis that these critiques do not hold when traced to original disciplinary uses. It... Read more

All papers in Epistemology (Anthropology)

Instituttets skriftserie nr. 25, 2010. ©Institutt for filosofi og førstesemesterstudier ... Universitetet i Bergen Elektronisk utgave. Pagineringen kan variere noe fra papirutgaven. ... Eivind Kolflaath: Tolkningsbegreper i... more
Este ensaio explora as propostas teóricas dos antropólogos Clifford Geertz e Tim Ingold sobre a relação entre cultura e natureza. Ingold destaca a inserção humana no mundo através da habitação, onde humanos e outras criaturas coexistem em... more
The essay Consciousness and the Energy Vision (Brigitte Heid:2025) presents a conceptual framework in which consciousness is treated as a resonant, organizing field capable of shaping individual, biological, and social systems. It... more
This paper offers a critical engagement with Ola Samuel Pelumi's "What is Time? Phenomenology, Physics, and Indigenous Temporalities." Pelumi's essay rightly challenges the hegemony of Western temporal models and makes a compelling case... more
Plamen N. Nikolov's article Reflection on the Essence of Time (2024) seeks to revisit one of philosophy's perennial problems-the definition and nature of time-through interdisciplinary reflection. The article argues that time, although an... more
The Crisis of Human Knowledge by Yang Burzhome is a bold and thought-provoking critique of how modern societies construct and control knowledge. Here are its central themes: Main Themes of the Book Epistemic Corruption The book argues... more
espanolSumario: La antropologia metafisica de Karl Rahner ha servido de fundamento para la formulacion del "teorema de la opcion fundamental" por parte de los teologos de la denominada Moral Autonoma. Dicha antropologia se... more
Buchrezension von Jörg Noller von Dimensionen der Zeit. Die Zeitphilosophie Kants und Husserls, Passagen Wien 2018 Das Phänomen der Zeit darf als eines der schwierigsten Probleme der Philosophie gelten. Problematisch ist die Zeit... more
The Hidden Code of Reality For most of human history, reality was thought to be made of STUFF. The earliest natural philosophers of Greece sought a single substance underlying all things. Thales of Miletus proposed that everything was, in... more
This paper explores the Logos-centred epistemology articulated in S. C. Sayles' Reorientation: The Architecture of Knowledge. The study argues that reality is not fundamentally material but informational, embedded within a divinely... more
Tolomeo, attivo ad Alessandria nel II secolo d.C., ereditò e sistematizzò un patrimonio di conoscenze geografiche e astronomiche accumulato...
This paper presents a comprehensive refutation of Rogério Fonteles Castro's Kosmos Theory and Topological Physics: Between God's Volume and the Devil's Surface. The theory proposes that life and consciousness can be understood as... more
Veritas Confirmata: The Logos-Centred Ontology is an inquiry into the nature of reality that begins where all sound philosophy and theology must: with God as Being Itself. From this fixed point, the work unfolds as a structured series of... more
Rodney Bartlett's article "A Cross-Disciplinary, Quantum-Gravity Approach to Everything" advances a speculative framework-Vector-Tensor-Scalar Geometry (VTSG)-that seeks to unify fundamental physics, mathematics, and consciousness. His... more
This article explores colonialism not merely as a political-economic project of European expansion, but as a cognitive, gendered, and cultural fossil embedded in the early stages of human evolution. By tracing colonial tendencies to... more
Beyond Perception is a loving and creative analysis of the main themes so caringly and revealing explored throughout Ingold's oeuvre -a wayfaring of sorts by the chapter authors, woven of Ingoldian lines and threads: embodiment, movement,... more
In the first part of this paper I present some basic presuppositions that in my view define metaphysical realism, whose negation leads to idealism. Aquinas' explicit realism is based on his epistemological thesis on the intentionality of... more
Die Natur ist uns immer nur so weit präsent, Als sie uns in unserem Geiste erscheint. Erst also als Idee ist die Natur uns präsent. Als Idee aber ist alle Natur real. Nur erscheint uns das Reale dann in unserem Geiste. Der Idealismus also... more
Este trabajo presenta la concepción de Ockham sobre los universales como signos mentales sin existencia extramental, en contraste con el realismo platónico y aristotélico. Se expone cómo los universales se generan de manera natural en... more
Este artículo propone una reconceptualización radical del ecosistema al aplicar dos axiomas filosóficos fundamentales: (1) "No hay absolutamente nada que pueda ser objetivo", y (2) "No importa cuánto busquemos porque nunca encontraremos... more
Oder: Über die Ideen. I. Arten von Ideen: 1. Es gibt Ideen von Wirklichem und es gibt Ideen von Geistigem. • Ideen von Wirklichem ist z.B. die Idee des Tisches, des Wassers, des Universums, des Metalls. • Ideen von Geistigem sind die... more
The Logos-Centred Epistemology by S C Sayles This paper examines VERITAS CONFIRMATA: The Logos-Centred Epistemology by S.C. Sayles as a comprehensive theological-philosophical system integrating Reformed theology, Van Tilian... more
A common criticism, which Duns Scotus's doctrine on divine ideas has received, is the supposed contradiction that it maintains when stating, on the one hand, that we find the origin of its intelligibility in the divine essence and, on the... more
Zusammenfassung: Dieser Artikel untersucht die Entwicklung der drei Grundbegriffe Vernunft, Materie und Ethik im Kontext der säkularen Moderne anhand eines strukturkritischen Analyseansatzes. Dabei werden die genannten Konzepte nicht nur... more
For the past ten years, South Africa has been progressively coming out of the apartheid system. Although all ties with the former regime have been severed completely, managing the heavy structural legacy has made the transition a diffi... more
In this work we reconstruct through a short correspondence between the author and Massimo Quaini, the idea of creating a dictionary of imaginary cartographers. This hypothesis was born as a by -product of a research project of national... more
This paper challenges the conventional notion of “genius” as a measure of exceptional intelligence, proposing instead that historical figures such as Newton, Einstein, and Darwin succeeded not due to rare cognitive gifts, but because they... more
This article is a meta-reflection on dissemination strategy under existential constraint. It addresses a peculiar and urgent dilemma: the theoretical framework of the Nine Laws-which outline the structural dynamics of systemic collapse... more
Slides do Seminário do GFEG: Epistemologia Genética e Filosofia - Gêneses, Liberdade Filosófica e Conhecimento (https://www.youtube.com/live/lIXPKwbgCh0), ministrado online em 07/08/21.
La homeopatía, surgida a finales del siglo XVIII de la mano del médico alemán Samuel Hahnemann, ha sido objeto de intensos debates científicos, filosóficos y clínicos. Fundamentada en la ley de similitud (“lo similar cura lo similar”), en... more
Este capítulo apresenta as principais contribuições de Thomas Csordas à antropologia da religião, com ênfase em sua formulação de um paradigma da corporeidade. Ao deslocar o corpo de objeto passivo para sujeito da cultura, Csordas propõe... more
Este artigo propõe uma leitura da trajetória histórica e simbólica cabo-verdiana a partir da metáfora ampliada "mar-cidade-campo-cidade-mar", entendida como estrutura didático-simbólica para uma pedagogia linguístico-identitária. A... more
This paper argues that the methodological naturalism employed in origin-of-life (OoL) research functions as a de facto metaphysical commitment rather than a neutral heuristic. While methodological naturalism claims to restrict itself to... more
Il testo della Geografia di Tolomeo è tràdito da oltre cinquanta manoscritti, completi o frammentari, risalenti...
Die Wahrheit ist eine Idee. Aber als Idee ist die Wahrheit niemals ein Fakt: faktisch ist keine Wahrheit und das Faktische ist auch niemals Wahrheit. Sondern Wahrheit ist die innere Logik des Seins: aber darin liegt dann die Idee. Die... more
La colaboración entre filosofía y neurociencia. Una propuesta interdisciplinar para entender la unidad de la persona humana José Ángel loMbo facoltà di filosofía. Pontificia univeRsità della santa cRoce. RoMa. José Manuel giMénez aMaya... more
The so-called «mind-brain relationships» are shown to be a privileged place for understanding the human being in a unitary way in its biological and psychic aspects. This reveals the need for an interdisciplinary approach to understand... more
Faust war ein großer Deutscher: ein großer Physiker, ein großer Philosoph und ein großer Forscher: Er stellte sich und die ganze Welt in Frage und fragte nach ihr. Das: "was diese Welt in ihrem Grunde zusammenhält"-des "Pudels Kern"-ist... more
el internet es fuente de información - la mayoría es pseudociencia.
Esta pesquisa pretende compreender em que moldes a pós-verdade é desafiadora na construção discursiva da realidade compartilhada. Propõe uma abordagem qualitativa, que emprega o procedimento bibliográfico e a análise do discurso. A... more
minhas memórias e memórias outras Fabiana Vencezlau DE, A PARTIR, SOBRE O ENSINO ARTÍSTICO EM CABO VERDE 29 O ensino artístico profissionalizante na escola técnica pública em cabo verde: história, percursos e perspetivas de... more
Este artigo tem como proposito fazer uma reflexão sobre o paradigma da corporalidade, a partir da articulação de algumas teorias que já foram produzidas sobre o assunto, dentro do âmbito das ciências sociais. Importa refletir sobre as... more
Épistémologie « des Suds », partenariat scientifique, méthodologie collaborative, religion, transnationalisation. Ce texte propose une révision critique de la distinction Nord / Suds, c'est-à-dire des postures institutionnelles et... more
benennt den Menschen, das "Wesen des Menschen" als den "Hirten des Seins." Der "Hirte des Seins" wird aufgefaßt als der Mensch, der im "festen Sein", im "Festen Seinszusammenhang" lebt, denkt und arbeitet. Dieser "feste Seinszusammenhang"... more
Download research papers for free!