According to the theory of nuclear deterrence, a state acquires nuclear weapons in self-defense if its territorial integrity and sovereignty come under attack. Nuclear weapons serve as a shield for a state having conventional asymmetries...
moreAccording to the theory of nuclear deterrence, a state acquires nuclear weapons in self-defense if its territorial integrity and sovereignty come under attack. Nuclear weapons serve as a shield for a state having conventional asymmetries against its adversary.However, emerging technologies are questioning the efficacy of nuclear deterrence. The
unregulated military use of cyber technology, Artificial Intelligence (AI),deep-fakes, quantum computing, hypersonic missiles, and advanced ballistic-missiles defense systems are questioning the credibility of nuclear deterrence, reluctantly increasing the risks of
inadvertent or intentional use of nuclear weapons2. Rebecca Hersman has attributed this situation as “Wormhole Escalation”. According to her, “emerging technologies have created openings (Wormholes) in the fabric of nuclear deterrence that may compel competing nations into anintentional or inadvertent sub-conventional or strategic level of conflict”. Emerging technologieshave also changed the concept of the “stability-instability” paradox and Kahn’s 44 rungsescalation ladder by making the patterns of escalation non-linear and unpredictable. Now
states are using emerging technologies in place of surrogates and proxies to target their adversaries below the nuclear threshold. Moreover, the precision and lethality of digital weapons are blurring the lines between the conflicts at sub-conventional, conventional, and strategic levels and creating a challenging situation for nuclear risks reduction3. Emerging technologies are also threatening the strategic stability of South Asia. In all such scenarios, the presence of three nuclear-armed neighbors i.e., India, China, and Pakistan, intensifying conventional and nuclear arms race, are the factors posing serious challenges for the strategic stability of the region. The nuclear history of the region reveals that Pakistan’s nuclear program is purely defensive and it was forced to adopt a nuclear path. Since the nuclearization of South Asia in 1974, nuclear weapons-free South Asia has remained the cornerstone of Pakistan’s nuclear diplomacy. Since 1947, the dispute of Jammu & Kashmir which caused wars continues to be the mother of all disputes between both countries4. However, the recent developments like growing violence in Afghanistan, border tensions between India and China, and the growing militarization of the Indian Ocean are not a good omen for regional stability. These developments should be analyzed in the context of Indian military modernization and its growing belligerence which has further accentuated after declaring it a Net-Security provider in the Indian Ocean Region.
This paper has been divided into five portions. The first portion discusses the concept of nuclear risk reduction (NRR), its history, and different agreements concluded by the NWS. The second portion outlines the types of new and emerging technologies which are threatening strategic stability. The third part traces the nuclear history of South Asia, broad contours Pakistan’s nuclear diplomacy and the CBMs taken by both countries over time. The fourth part has been dedicated to the study of threats of the military use of emerging technologies specific to South Asia and the fifth part explores the measures which could help mitigate the risks posed by the emerging technologies.