Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Matching Methods

description15 papers
group0 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Matching methods are statistical techniques used in observational studies to create comparable groups by pairing units with similar characteristics, thereby reducing selection bias and confounding variables. These methods aim to estimate causal effects by ensuring that the treatment and control groups are statistically similar on observed covariates.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Matching methods are statistical techniques used in observational studies to create comparable groups by pairing units with similar characteristics, thereby reducing selection bias and confounding variables. These methods aim to estimate causal effects by ensuring that the treatment and control groups are statistically similar on observed covariates.

Key research themes

1. What conditions ensure the uniqueness of stable matchings in preference-based two-sided markets?

This research area focuses on identifying necessary and sufficient conditions under which a preference-driven stable matching problem admits a unique stable matching solution. Determining uniqueness is critical for predicting outcomes, ensuring strategy-proofness, and enhancing market transparency. Recent advances refine traditional sufficient conditions by considering the problem's normal form and acyclicity of preferences within it, devoting attention to how irrelevant preference information can be pruned to yield more precise characterizations of uniqueness.

Key finding: Shows that a stable matching problem has a unique stable matching if and only if the preferences are acyclic on the problem’s normal form—an essential subproblem obtained by iterated deletion of unattractive alternatives... Read more
Key finding: Investigates stable matching problems incorporating ties and incomplete preference lists, focusing on finding maximum-size stable matchings (MAX-SMTI), an NP-hard problem. Employs advanced local search techniques with... Read more
Key finding: Studies the parameterized complexity of NP-hard stable matching variants with ties and incomplete lists, focusing on maximizing or minimizing stable matching size. Establishes fixed-parameter tractability results and... Read more

2. How can feature matching in computer vision be enhanced to improve robustness and distribution uniformity?

This research theme addresses improving the quantity and spatial homogeneity of matched feature points in image pairs, a critical factor for robust computer vision tasks such as stereo vision, mosaicking, and 3D reconstruction. Given feature detection and descriptor extraction methods, the focus lies on post-processing matched features to rectify clustering and improve distribution across images using geometric transformations and elimination of ambiguous matches, thereby enhancing accuracy of downstream applications.

Key finding: Proposes an enhancement algorithm added after standard feature matching pipelines that reduces spatial clustering of matched features by eliminating ambiguous close-by matches and warping feature points using coarse geometric... Read more
Key finding: Develops a two-step motion-analysis framework to first distinguish rigid from non-rigid objects by matching dense optic flow fields without prior motion knowledge using mutual information-based motion estimation, and then... Read more
Key finding: Introduces a 2D object characterization and matching scheme integrating uniform-scale chromatic color spaces with morphological image processing and deformable contour models. Employs hierarchical unsupervised segmentation... Read more

3. What advanced algorithmic frameworks and theoretical characterizations improve graph and string matching under structural and parameterized constraints?

This theme explores the development of novel theoretical frameworks and algorithmic methodologies for addressing complex matching problems, including graph matching modeled as quadratic assignment problems and string matching variations such as parameterized and order-preserving matching. The research emphasizes continuous relaxation methods, parameterized complexity, and approximation algorithms to overcome computational hardness, improve scalability, and extend classical matching notions to incorporate structural constraints or approximate similarities relevant for practical applications in computer science and bioinformatics.

Key finding: Defines a broad family of Separable Functions that asymptotically approximate the discrete graph matching problem traditionally formulated as a quadratic assignment problem (QAP). Introduces novel continuous relaxation... Read more
Key finding: Surveys and extends parameterized matching—a string matching variant where two strings match if a bijective parameter mapping aligns their symbols—developing theoretical foundations and algorithmic solutions including... Read more
Key finding: Proposes an algorithmic framework for approximate order-preserving matching by relaxing strict order constraints with δγ-distances that bound individual position errors and global cumulative distortion between pattern and... Read more

4. How can matching methods be formalized and optimized to incorporate demands, capacities, and multiple applications in economic and network problems?

Research here focuses on extending classical one-to-one matching to many-to-many scenarios while considering constraints such as individual demands and capacities, as well as multiple applications by agents. These extensions are important in resource allocation, job markets, and network design. The works develop polynomial-time algorithms leveraging classic tools like the Hungarian algorithm and adapt the urn-ball matching function to handle multiple applications, offering corrected formulas and limiting results vital for practical large-scale matching applications.

Key finding: Presents a polynomial-time algorithm to find a minimum-cost many-to-many matching with demands and capacities (MMDC) by extending the Hungarian algorithm. The approach enforces lower and upper bounds on the number of matches... Read more
Key finding: Corrects earlier expressions for the expected number of matches in a model where unemployed workers can submit multiple applications to vacancies, clarifying the dependence structure between applications and competitors.... Read more
Key finding: Derives explicit expressions for the expected number of worker-vacancy matches under a model where each worker submits multiple applications, correcting previous finite case miscalculations. Demonstrates that in the limit of... Read more

5. How can matching and reweighting methods be applied to estimate counterfactual distributions and causal effects in observational settings without relying extensively on balance checking?

This theme encompasses methodologies for estimating treatment effects and counterfactual outcome distributions through matching and reweighting, emphasizing approaches that do not require extensive balance diagnostics. It includes advances in coarsened exact matching (CEM) that guarantee imbalance bounds ex ante, and practical applications in economics and social sciences where randomized trials are unavailable. The focus is on improving causal inference reliability by bounding imbalance monotonicity and employing generalized weighting schemes, combining statistical rigor with computational feasibility.

Key finding: Develops Coarsened Exact Matching (CEM), a monotonic imbalance bounding matching method that guarantees predetermined bounds on matching imbalance before analysis, eliminating the need for iterative balance checking.... Read more
Key finding: Investigates reweighting approaches, both parametric (probit model based) and nonparametric, for estimating counterfactual outcome distributions, conducting sensitivity analyses via Monte Carlo simulations and applying... Read more
Key finding: Applies matching methods (specifically probit estimation with matching) to survey data from Uruguay to estimate the effect of self-assessed health status on self-reported happiness. Finds that individuals reporting good... Read more

All papers in Matching Methods

Mazeinda provides functions for detecting and testing the significance of pairwise Monotonic Association for Zero-Inflated non-negative Data with the measure proposed by Pimentel(2009)[1]. This package can handle any degree of zero... more
This study examines the impact of New Integrated Management Package (IMP) adoption on income and poverty among fodder farming household in Sahl El-Tina. The IMP such as Rate, time, and methods of nitrogen fertilization and other... more
This research demonstrates that soybean adoption has a positive effect on the crop production value of households. Employing a genetic matching approach, the estimated impact amounts to 11,000 Mozambican Meticals (MT). On average,... more
From Temporary Help Jobs to Permanent Employment: What Can We Learn from Matching Estimators and their Sensitivity? * The diffusion of Temporary Work Agency (TWA) jobs originated a harsh policy debate and ambiguous empirical evidence.... more
Propensity score methods are an increasingly popular technique for causal inference. To estimate propensity scores, we must model the distribution of the treatment indicator given a vector of covariates. Much work has been done in the... more
Insecure land tenure plagues many developing and tropical regions, often where conservation concerns are highest. Conservation organizations have long focused on protected areas as tenure interventions, but are now thinking more... more
by Wei Li
The lack of longitudinal studies of the relationship between the built environment and travel behavior has been widely discussed in the literature. This paper discusses how standard propensity score matching estimators can be extended to... more
This article presents a study of the relationship between self-reported happiness and selfassessed health status at the individual level, using the Religion, Health, and Young Emancipation ISSP survey for Uruguay in 2008. Probit estimates... more
This paper sought to evaluate the economic impact of the Cotton YIELD Programme on crop income of smallholder cotton farmers in Zambia. Specifically, the study sought to (a) identify factors that influence smallholder cotton farmer’... more
The study examines school data and their association with participation in the Wabash County Promise Scholarships program, which combines Children's Savings Accounts (CSAs) with scholarships. CSAs are interventions designed to build... more
A broad and growing body of research suggests that intergroup contact can reduce bias (e.g., Pettigrew, Tropp, Wagner, & Chris, 2011). At the same time, polling suggests that many White adults do not experience intergroup contact in their... more
Group Processes & Intergroup Relations "The single most promising arena of racial integration-at least for adults-is the workplace." Cynthia Estlund (2003, p. 9) A broad and growing body of research suggests that intergroup contact can... more
We discuss a method for improving causal inferences called ''Coarsened Exact Matching'' (CEM), and the new ''Monotonic Imbalance Bounding'' (MIB) class of matching methods from which CEM is derived. We summarize what is known about CEM... more
Matched sampling is a methodology used to estimate treatment effects. A caliper mechanism is used to achieve better similarity among matched pairs. We investigate finite sample properties of matching with caliper and propose a slight... more
Matched sampling is a methodology used to estimate treatment effects. A caliper mechanism is used to achieve better similarity among matched pairs. We investigate finite sample properties of matching with caliper and propose a slight... more
A caliper mechanism is a common tool used to prevent from inexact matches. The existing literature discusses asymptotic properties of matching with caliper. In this simulation study we investigate properties in small and medium sized... more
Matched sampling is a methodology used to estimate treatment effects. A caliper mechanism is used to achieve better similarity among matched pairs. We investigate finite sample properties of matching with caliper and propose a slight... more
Matched sampling is a methodology used to estimate treatment effects. A caliper mechanism is used to achieve better similarity among matched pairs. We investigate finite sample properties of matching with caliper and propose a slight... more
The funding environment of European Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) has evolved towards a "new funding climate" characterized by austerity and competition for resources. The outcome is a differentiated setting in terms of... more
Watershed development facilitates in reducing the vulnerability of farm income to weather-induced shocks in rain-fed lands in India. The present paper estimates homogeneous as well as non-homogeneous effects of watershed development on... more
This paper provides a simple microeconomic evaluation of the determinants of credit card holding in Italy. Using a Probit model, the analysis mostly concentrates on the demand side of the credit card market. Thus, the focus has been on... more
The Policy Research Working Paper Series disseminates the findings of work in progress to encourage the exchange of ideas about development issues. An objective of the series is to get the findings out quickly, even if the presentations... more
The Policy Research Working Paper Series disseminates the findings of work in progress to encourage the exchange of ideas about development issues. An objective of the series is to get the findings out quickly, even if the presentations... more
Appendix A Discussion of propensity score matching methodologies A.1 Propensity score and matching methods in a binary setting In the first step of our empirical analysis we aim at estimating the treatment effect τ i for the unit... more
This paper analyzes the relationship between households' wealth and heterogeneous treatment impacts for a market-based training program that has benefited more than 40,000 disadvantaged individuals in Peru since 1996. We proxy long-run... more
Rigidity and reflectivity are important properties of objects, identifying these properties is a fundamental problem for many computer vision applications like motion and tracking. In this paper, we extend our previous work to propose a... more
A Bayesian Spatial-Propensity Score Matching estimator is proposed to measure the regional impact of microfinance on poverty reduction and women's empowerment. The impact of microfinance in Bolivia was tested with this estimator,... more
A Bayesian Spatial-Propensity Score Matching estimator is proposed to measure the regional impact of microfinance on poverty reduction and women's empowerment. The impact of microfinance in Bolivia was tested with this estimator,... more
By Beatriz Corchuelo Martínez-Azúa and Ester Martínez-Ros; Abstract: This paper explores the effect of fiscal incentives for R&D on innovation. Spain is considered one of the most.
Road accessibility is an important development priority of the government of Bhutan. Since, wealth is assumed to grow with road connectivity, using Bhutan Living Standard Survey data of 2007 and 2012, a Difference in Difference regression... more
This paper provides a simple microeconomic evaluation of the determinants of credit card holding in Italy. Using a Probit model, the analysis mostly concentrates on the demand side of the credit card market. Thus, the focus has been on... more
During the 1990s Peru greatly expanded the access of formal judicial services in underserved districts through the construction and staffing of justice modules-physical structures which housed courts, prosecutors and public defenders. The... more
By Beatriz Corchuelo Martínez-Azúa and Ester Martínez-Ros; Abstract: This paper explores the effect of fiscal incentives for R&D on innovation. Spain is considered one of the most.
This paper tests the linkage between a binary treatment (rural road improvement project) and a continuous outcome (cotton productivity) in Zambia's agro-based Eastern Province as measured by repeated crosssections of farm-level data from... more
Our special thanks go to their Royal Highnesses or their representatives who attended the district validation meetings. We also thank the many charcoal and timber producers, traders, retailers and transporters who provided invaluable... more
Mazeinda provides functions for detecting and testing the significance of pairwise Monotonic Association for Zero-Inflated non-negative Data with the measure proposed by Pimentel(2009)[1]. This package can handle any degree of zero... more
Working Paper 2 October 2014 Mark T. Buntaine, Stuart E. Hamilton, Marco Millones* Land tenure and land titling programs for forests have become a mainstay of conservation and resource management policy worldwide. They are thought to... more
Newcastle disease (ND) is a highly infectious disease of poultry that seriously impacts on food security and livelihoods of livestock farmers and communities in tropical regions of the world. ND is a constant problem in the eastern... more
Rural poultry production is important for its nutrition and economic value in the tropics and subtropics of the world. Unfortunately, disease is among the greatest challenges to this sector. Lack of a sustainable poultry disease... more
Counterfactual distributions are generally estimated by matching techniques, less frequently by data reweighting. In this study, we investigate this second approach, first by a Monte Carlo study and then by an empirical application to... more
Using a 5,000 household panel from Zambia, we find that asset ownership, but not access to fertilizer, has an extremely important impact on output and that investment in oxen would yield returns above the market rate. Policies should thus... more
Impact evaluation was high on the agenda at the recent 3rd Global Review of Aid-for-Trade (AfT). Since the mid-2000s, interest in the analytically robust evaluation of the impact of projects, programmes and policies has increased amongst... more
Many cost-effectiveness analyses (CEAs) use data from observational studies. Statistical methods can only address selection bias if they make plausible assumptions. No quality assessment tool is available for appraising CEAs that use... more
The primary purpose of this paper is to seek empirical answers to the above question. Using a highly disaggregated bilateral trade flows at HS 6 digit level for African countries for a period 1995-2009 and a conditional logit technique, I... more
Today water supply issue in large cities seems to be a big problem. This becomes more important with population growth and urbanization extension. To cope with this problem lots of irrigation and drainage projects have been implemented... more
A case-control study was conducted to determine the relationship between household livestock keeping and malnutrition levels of under-5 children. A questionnaire was used to capture data on the hypothesized risk factors. Fisher’s Exact... more
Our special thanks go to their Royal Highnesses or their representatives who attended the district validation meetings. We also thank the many charcoal and timber producers, traders, retailers and transporters who provided invaluable... more
Download research papers for free!