Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Conventional Deterrence

description40 papers
group32 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Conventional deterrence refers to the strategy of preventing aggression by maintaining a credible threat of military retaliation using conventional forces, rather than nuclear weapons. It relies on the ability to project power and demonstrate readiness to respond to potential threats, thereby discouraging adversaries from initiating conflict.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Conventional deterrence refers to the strategy of preventing aggression by maintaining a credible threat of military retaliation using conventional forces, rather than nuclear weapons. It relies on the ability to project power and demonstrate readiness to respond to potential threats, thereby discouraging adversaries from initiating conflict.

Key research themes

1. How do contemporary security dynamics reshape conventional deterrence theories and practices in the post-Cold War and post-9/11 contexts?

This theme investigates how evolving geopolitical realities—such as proliferation to 'rogue' states, nuclear multipolarity, non-state actors, and technological innovations—challenge and transform classical deterrence theories into more nuanced approaches including conventional, extended, and cross-domain deterrence. It addresses the limitations of Cold War-era deterrence models and explores administrative shifts, especially in US policy post-9/11, that recalibrate deterrence to cope with asymmetric threats and emerging security domains.

Key finding: The paper identifies the Bush administration’s fourfold deterrence goals that appear prima facie contradictory: reaffirming deterrence with resolve, extending deterrence scope to new policy ends, reducing overall reliance on... Read more
Key finding: The study highlights the Philippine security discourse’s reactive conception of deterrence—focused on facing aggression post-attack rather than preventing hostile acts—and argues for a paradigm shift towards proactive... Read more
Key finding: Analyzing Polish-Russian military relations, the paper contends that conventional deterrence against Russia remains constrained by Russia’s quantitative military advantage and ongoing modernization. It incorporates the... Read more
Key finding: The work explicates Israel's evolving security doctrine, emphasizing deterrence as a central pillar from the early statehood period to the present, where threats have transitioned from interstate military invasions to... Read more

2. What are the strategic and operational challenges in establishing credible conventional deterrence capabilities amid shifting geopolitical and technological landscapes?

This area explores practical issues in implementing conventional deterrence amidst power transitions, technological proliferation, and evolving military doctrines. It studies how cost, military power diffusion, technological innovation, and the interplay between deterrence and compellence shape state strategies, especially for small and medium powers facing superior or aggressive neighbors. The focus is on how military capabilities translate into credible deterrence signals, the political-strategic considerations that structure force deployments, and adaptations to multi-domain threat environments.

Key finding: The paper develops a political-strategic analysis of deterrence versus compellence, emphasizing cost and probability of success rather than technological replication. It argues that states achieve deterrence more... Read more
Key finding: This operational study assesses India's naval conventional deterrence and evolving posture towards compellence, especially in maritime blockade and surveillance operations against Pakistan. It documents how Indian naval... Read more
Key finding: The article critiques NATO’s erosion of credible deterrence on its Eastern Flank post-Cold War due to organizational fragmentation, lowered spending, and a shift to expeditionary focus. It advocates restoring a compounded... Read more
Key finding: The paper evaluates the Baltic States’ efforts to enhance conventional deterrence post-Russian aggression in Ukraine, highlighting increased defense spending and procurement focused on mobility and firepower. It notes... Read more

3. How do legal, ethical, and strategic considerations influence the conceptualization and applicability of preventive war, preemption, and deterrence doctrines in US policy?

This theme addresses the normative and practical constraints shaping US security doctrines post-9/11, focusing on policy debates about preventive war and preemption vis-à-vis classical deterrence. It critically examines US doctrinal documents and their interpretations, the tension between legal frameworks and strategic necessities, and the domestic and international political context influencing the adoption of interventionist postures. The implications for deterrence credibility, international law, and strategic stability form the core of inquiry here.

Key finding: This article elucidates the Bush administration’s reframing of deterrence, preventive war, and preemption post-9/11, arguing while rhetoric suggests a preventive war doctrine, actual policy implementation is constrained by... Read more

All papers in Conventional Deterrence

Israeli security policy began to formulate in the early 1950s by its first leader, David Ben-Gurion. The three pillars of the defence doctrine were deterrence of possible threats; detection of impending attacks, and decisive military... more
This article explores the way issues of pre-emption, preventive war and deterrence are presented in the policy documents of the George W. Bush Administration.
The current situation around the Karabakh conflict leads to pessimism concerning the prospects for a speedy resolution based on mutual compromise. Given the improbability of reaching a compromise solution even in the mid-term, the most... more
Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan have different hopes for the Atlantic Alliance.
Over the last two decades, conventional (non-nuclear) deterrence in Russia's military strategy has changed from being a sub-tactical, sub-strategic warfighting tool to being a separate military-political factor—a self-contained component... more
The military parade dedicated to the twenty-fifth anniversary of Armenia’s independence has put an end to three years of speculation about whether Armenia is in possession of the Russian-made advanced 9K720 Iskander Short-Range Ballistic... more
Download research papers for free!