Academia.eduAcademia.edu

judicial control

description35 papers
group1 follower
lightbulbAbout this topic
Judicial control refers to the authority of courts to review and potentially invalidate actions or decisions made by legislative or executive branches of government, ensuring compliance with constitutional principles and the rule of law. It serves as a mechanism for upholding individual rights and maintaining checks and balances within a legal system.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Judicial control refers to the authority of courts to review and potentially invalidate actions or decisions made by legislative or executive branches of government, ensuring compliance with constitutional principles and the rule of law. It serves as a mechanism for upholding individual rights and maintaining checks and balances within a legal system.

Key research themes

1. How does judicial control balance the exercise of administrative discretion with ensuring accountability and legality in administrative actions?

This research area investigates the role of judicial oversight in supervising administrative authorities to prevent arbitrariness, abuse of discretionary power, and ensure compliance with constitutional and statutory mandates. It is crucial because administrative discretion, while necessary for governance flexibility, poses risks of unchecked power that can harm individual rights and public interest without effective judicial review.

Key finding: This paper documents the constitutional and statutory mechanisms employed by Indian courts to check administrative action, such as writs, injunctions, and damages suits. It highlights judicial review's centrality in holding... Read more
Key finding: Through a focused examination of discretionary power, this article argues that judicial control is the most effective means of regulating discretionary authority to prevent abuse and arbitrariness. It delineates conditions... Read more
Key finding: This chapter highlights the use of judicial review and judicial activism as primary tools for institutional oversight of bureaucracy, emphasizing their role in protecting individual rights and promoting bureaucratic... Read more
Key finding: Examining administrative law and judicialization in East and Southeast Asia, this article finds an evolving role of courts from passive entities to active controllers of administrative discretion, especially through judicial... Read more

2. In what ways does judicial governance function as an institutional mechanism to regulate courts themselves and balance independence with accountability?

This research theme explores the internal governance of the judiciary, examining how courts and judges exercise authority over judicial administration, uphold standards, and maintain accountability without undermining judicial independence. It investigates governance structures, inter-judge relations, and mechanisms to enhance court efficiency and legitimacy, reflecting a crucial institutional dimension of judicial control relevant for constitutional systems.

Key finding: Using extensive internal documentation and interviews, this study of the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reveals an innovated model of judicial self-governance characterized by decentralized, participatory decision-making... Read more
Key finding: This article critiques traditional legal approaches to judicial governance, arguing that legal standards alone are insufficient for effective judicial accountability and administration. It advocates an interdisciplinary... Read more
Key finding: The paper disentangles four key concepts—judicial independence, accountability, control, and constraints—and explicates their interrelations within Western constitutional systems. It argues that understanding these notions... Read more

3. How do courts function as regulatory bodies in the constitutional and rights protection domain beyond traditional dispute adjudication?

This theme conceptualizes courts not only as adjudicators but also as active regulators shaping constitutional rights, legal norms, and public policies. It revisits judicial power through a regulatory lens, articulating the courts’ role in managing aggregate social rights and constitutional norms, thereby offering a theoretical framework that integrates judicial decision-making with broader social regulation.

Key finding: This article proposes a novel regulatory theory in which common law courts function as regulators of fundamental and constitutional rights beyond individual disputes. It demonstrates that courts’ adjudication creates social... Read more
Key finding: Extending the regulatory theory of courts, this exposition argues that courts exercise interstitial legislative roles through their decisions by regulating constitutional rights and maintaining the balance of power within the... Read more

All papers in judicial control

GODOY, Miguel Gualano de.; ALMEIDA, Larissa de Moura Guerra. Caso Francischini e a desinformação face à integridade do processo eleitoral: a democracia militante nos percalços da erosão constitucional. In: Álvaro Ricardo de Sousa Cruz;... more
PINHO, Angela. STF engata decisões controversas para liberdade de expressão em sintonia com TSE. Entrevista com Miguel Godoy. 2023. Disponível em:... more
remediada por la LO 2/2002. En dicha ley se fija un sistema de control judicial previo que, tras ser comparado con el fijado en la Ley de Enjuiciamiento Criminal, pone de manifiesto que el control al que se somete al CNI en esta materia... more
O presente trabalho propõe-se a explorar a aplicação do princípio constitucional da moralidade administrativa no controle do ato administrativo. Parte-se da conceituação e elucidação do ato administrativo, seus requisitos e possíveis... more
O artigo busca esclarecer a nocao de ato administrativo e discutir sobre as peculiaridades do ato discricionario e o seu merito. Trata-se, a partir do estudo legislativo, constitucional, jurisprudencial e doutrinario, da possibilidade de... more
El control fiscal es, en Colombia, una función pública que consiste en verificar la manera en que se manejan o administran los dineros públicos.
During the last three decades, Italian criminal procedure has been steadily going through substantial changes. The most notable transformation has been brought forth with the introduction of a new Code of Criminal Procedure (1988) that... more
Vinculação e discricionariedade ocorre em qualquer do direito. É necessário um critério técnico de diferenciação uma e outra.
The Constitutionalising of Administrative Law, as well as the evolution on the principle of legality, radiated effects on the Public Administration. It amplifies the principles and rules on the constitutional body, while applied to... more
contemporaneous political context, as well as understand the importance of court orders for guardianship of this right, and contribute to analysis of the relativity of separation of powers referring to court orders that interfere in... more
O presente artigo tem como objetivo demonstrar as inovações abordadas pelo Tribunal Superior Eleitoral nas normas deste ano, a partir da regulação de novas tecnologias, destacando o papel e a função do Ministério Público enquanto... more
This paper considers judgments based on agreement of the parties in Croatian law, more precisely particular aspects of this consensual form which previous studies have assessed to be potentially problematic. These aspects include the... more
A escolha do administrador e os limites e possibilidades do controle judicial: uma leitura sob o enfoque da Nova Juridicidade / por João Marcelo Lang.-2008. 215 f. ; 30cm. Dissertação (mestrado)-Universidade do Vale do Rio dos Sinos,... more
o direito atualmente se encontra 'hamletianamente' martirizado pelo dilema de ser arte ou ciência. Ou seja, entre ser 'tecnologia de controle', organização e direção social, o que implica uma formação unidisciplinar. meramente... more
O artigo tem por objetivo analisar os ataques ao sistema eleitoral brasileiro nas eleições de 2022 no Twitter. Por meio de uma abordagem interdisciplinar e o emprego de ferramentas e técnicas computacionais de rotulação automatizada de... more
The distinctive character of the European Union (EU) is indisputable. May it be denoted as a supranational or as a sui generis organization (which is a preferred designation of the European Court of Justice), it is considered to be the... more
After the Lisbon Treaty has entered into force, the process of concluding treaties between the EU and third countries or international organizations has sustained significant changes. The most important procedural novelty is the... more
O resultado desta dissertação carrega um pouco de todos que me instigaram ao direito público, à vida acadêmica e à consultoria jurídica. Em primeiro lugar, à Delegações de Prefeituras Municipais, que me abrindo as portas, me mostrou uma... more
Las acciones populares son el mecanismo de litigio colectivo que la Constitución Política Colombiana prevé para proteger derechos e intereses, entre ellos la moralidad administrativa. Para  este evento, los ciudadanos cuentan con la... more
Objectives: The constitutional powers of the National Council of Justice challenge a constitutionally appropriate interpretation of its functions and constitutional consequences. This article analyzes the incidental control of... more
O trabalho demonstra que o Inquérito das Fake News (Inquérito 4.781/DF), aberto pela Presidência do Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF) e distribuído à relatoria do Ministro Alexandre de Moraes, foi instaurado para investigar notícias... more
Autonomia universitária é o princípio que garante às universidades e instituições de ensino superior a liberdade de gerir suas próprias atividades acadêmicas, administrativas e financeiras, sem interferência externa indevida. Nos últimos... more
En este articulo se presenta un analisis sobre la naturaleza del injusto penal y el ilicito disciplinario, conceptualizaciones, caracteristicas y diferencias; partiendo de la premisa de que el Derecho disciplinario es un area del Derecho... more
The object of study of this article was the Judicialization of Politics, a topic on which we sought to explore different positions, given that there are different and controversial analyzes with regard to Constitutionality Control. The... more
Public policies have received more attention from scholars and researchers in the humanities and applied social sciences with each passing year. The theme is relevant as a plausible way of promoting social transformation through... more
El objetivo del presente trabajo es la elaboración de una propuesta de un mecanismo rural de garantía para Castilla y León. Para ello, la metodología utilizada ha sido analizar las principales experiencias en esta materia a nivel mundial... more
This text discussion among economists and lawyers on judicial control in economics in order to show the democratic character of this occurs. The analysis contains three parts: (i) contextualization of the debate from the beginning of... more
The present article focuses on national restrictive regulations affecting market structure and functioning. It is argued that EU primary law permits, to a certain extent, a control of legality of such national measures in the light of... more
This text discussion among economists and lawyers on judicial control in economics in order to show the democratic character of this occurs. The analysis contains three parts: (i) contextualization of the debate from the beginning of... more
Alcance del precedente jurisprudencial artículo 10 de la ley 1437 de 2011 y sus implicaciones en la practica judicial.
SUMARIO: I. OBJETO Y PRETENSIONES DEL ESTUDIO. II. LA JURISPRUDENCIA SOBRE LA INVALIDEZ DE LOS PLANES. III. LOS NEFASTOS EFECTOS DE ESTA JURISPRUDENCIA Y LOS INTENTOS LEGISLATIVOS DE CORREGIRLA. 1. El reconocimiento de las consecuencias... more
Alcance del precedente jurisprudencial artículo 10 de la ley 1437 de 2011 y sus implicaciones en la practica judicial.
The article is devoted to the topical issue of judicial control over non-interference in the private (personal and family) life of participants in criminal proceedings. The study was conducted in the context of the analysis of the... more
This work is an article of reflection whose purpose is the analysis of the concept of substantial illegality from the antiformalist precepts preached by the Political Constitution of 1991, which advocate for the autonomy and independence... more
The real present scene of diffuse and changing cities shows the actual crisis of the traditional urban planning as a suitable instrument for the definition and control of development. The disregulating positions in which the market policy... more
Este artículo es producto del proyecto de investigación denominado; "Control de legalidad y constitucionalidad de los decretos reglamentarios de leyes marco", realizado entre los años 2014 a 2016, financiado por la
RIASSUNTO Obbiettivo: Questo articolo presenta un’osservazione dei Sistemi del Diritto e della Scienza a partire dalla relazione fra quanto è comunicato scientificamente sul Diritto e quanto è giudicato dal Tribunale di Giustizia di Santa... more
Sao diversos os obstaculos por que se tem engendrado a critica a atividade judicial de controle sobre os atos emanados do Estado e, tambem, sobre as suas omissoes. Embora algumas delas contenham inequivoca pertinencia e os limites de... more
El presente artículo se deriva de una investigación que estableció como objeto central analizar   los avances en materia de control disciplinario pasando por un análisis de la percepción de la sociedad civil frente a dicho control y... more
El presente artículo comienza poniendo de manifiesto la importancia que el conocimiento y el aprendizaje tienen en el contexto actual para hacer frente a los enormes retos a los que nos enfrentamos como sociedad. Se hace un especial... more
This text discussion among economists and lawyers on judicial control in economics in order to show the democratic character of this occurs. The analysis contains three parts: (i) contextualization of the debate from the beginning of... more
El objeto de este escrito es establecer las causas por las cuales se ha instituido el poder disciplinario preferente de la Procuraduría General de la Nación sobre las actuaciones disciplinarias, en qué casos aplica y en cuales no;... more
El presente artículo comienza poniendo de manifiesto la importancia que el conocimiento y el aprendizaje tienen en el contexto actual para hacer frente a los enormes retos a los que nos enfrentamos como sociedad. Se hace... more
After the Lisbon Treaty has entered into force, the process of concluding treaties between the EU and third countries or international organizations has sustained significant changes. The most important procedural novelty is the... more
The distinctive character of the European Union (EU) is indisputable. May it be denoted as a supranational or as a sui generis organization (which is a preferred designation of the European Court of Justice), it is considered to be the... more
The present investigation evidences a theoretical approach to the concept of "administrative acts and acts", taking into account the doctrinal and jurisprudential dimensions that have been developed in the Colombian legal... more
Alcance del precedente jurisprudencial artículo 10 de la ley 1437 de 2011 y sus implicaciones en la practica judicial.
Download research papers for free!