explain (i) the physical processes involved in fragipan genesis, such as self-weight collapse followed by physical The evolution of fragipans in the Great Lakes region is poorly ripening (Bryant, 1989), or (ii) the physical and chemical...
moreexplain (i) the physical processes involved in fragipan genesis, such as self-weight collapse followed by physical The evolution of fragipans in the Great Lakes region is poorly ripening (Bryant, 1989), or (ii) the physical and chemical understood despite the common occurrence of fragipans in the region. To help resolve this problem, three soils with fragipans in northern processes involved in fragipan bonding by agents, such Michigan were studied to evaluate the pedogenic pathways for fragi-as translocated silica or Si-rich pan evolution, and the results extended to soils forming under similar aluminosilicates (Karathanasis, 1989) or precipitation conditions. Soil characterizations were made via field, physical, chemiof acid-weathering products (Smeck et al., 1989), or (iii) cal, and micromorphological observations and analyses and were evalboth . Formation and development uated in terms of the major models of fragipan genesis. Because it of these binding agents have been proposed to occur in appears that a combination of pedogenic models best explains many association with lithologic, hydrologic, or weathering of the fragipan properties of our soils, while also allowing for their discontinuities in the solum Kara-variable expression, we developed a new model-one that integrates thanasis, 1989; Smeck et al., 1989). The purpose of this study was to (i) identify and evolution for many soils in Michigan and the Great Lakes region. The Michigan Model of Fragipan Evolution (MMFE) is therefore a describe pedogenic processes important to fragipan evosynthesizing model that involves the self-weight collapse of a wet soil lution based on some Michigan soils, formed in till, that or parent material, followed by physical ripening of the collapsed have variable fragipan expression, (ii) infer fragipan zone. Ripening helps to retain the closely packed fabric and intergrain genesis based on data from these soils, linked to existing bridging in the collapsed zone, creating a protofragipan. Later, amorpedogenic models, and (iii) evaluate our findings in phous bonding agents precipitate in the protofragipan due to its positerms of these models so as to develop a new, synthesiztion near a weathering-front discontinuity. The resulting fragipan deing, and integrating model of fragipan evolution. Alvelops progressively and becomes better expressed with further though developed from and for Michigan soils, our pedogenesis. Fragipan degradation is eventually initiated by an inmodel may have, theoretically, wide applicability. creasingly prominent, perched zone of saturation that forms seasonally above the fragipan. With time, processes associated with fragipan degradation and translocation of materials to lower parts of the profile MATERIALS AND METHODS exceed processes associated with progressive development, and the Soil series from across northern Michigan that exhibit varifragipan is destroyed. able degrees of fragipan expression were studied. The Feldhauser (coarse-loamy, mixed, active, frigid Oxyaquic Glossudalfs), Munising (coarse-loamy, mixed, active, frigid Alfic M ost papers on fragipan genesis have focused on Oxyaquic Fragiorthods), and Glennie (coarse-loamy, mixed, superactive, frigid Oxyaquic Fraglossudalfs) soil series repre-loess parent materials of the southcentral and sent weakly, moderately, and strongly expressed fragipans, midwestern USA. Fragipan research, particularly gerespectively, relative to other soils with fragipans in the region. netic studies, has been less active elsewhere. During the A study location for each series was selected based on site past two decades, only a few have discussed fragipan similarities, and the soils were sampled from a backhoe pit. genesis for the Great Lakes region (e.g., Habecker et Details on field and laboratory analyses are provided else- al., 1990; Miller et al., 1993; Bockheim, 2003). Fragipans where . Sodium citrate-dithiin Michigan, more specifically, have been studied very onite was used to extract Fe, Al, and SiO 2 on the Ͻ2 mm little since Yassoglou and Whiteside (1960), despite fraction of all genetic horizons (Ross and Wang, 1993; Loeptheir common occurrence across northern Michigan. pert and Inskeep, 1996); results are written with a sub-Moreover, they have not been evaluated in terms of the scripted d. Undisturbed, bulk samples were collected from all proto-major genetic models developed for glaciated regions fragipan and fragipan horizons for micromorphological deduring the past four decades (e.g., Olson and Hole, 1967; scription using scanning electron microscopy (scanning elec-