Academia.eduAcademia.edu

New Testament Textual Criticism

description2,390 papers
group29,245 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
New Testament Textual Criticism is the scholarly study of the manuscripts and textual variants of the New Testament writings. It aims to reconstruct the original text by analyzing differences among various copies, understanding the historical context of these variations, and evaluating the reliability of sources to determine the most authentic readings.
lightbulbAbout this topic
New Testament Textual Criticism is the scholarly study of the manuscripts and textual variants of the New Testament writings. It aims to reconstruct the original text by analyzing differences among various copies, understanding the historical context of these variations, and evaluating the reliability of sources to determine the most authentic readings.

Key research themes

1. How do modern assumptions about ancient textual finalization affect New Testament textual criticism?

This research area interrogates the modern conceptual framework applied to the New Testament texts, especially the notions of 'final text,' 'authorship,' and 'publication,' which have been shaped by print culture but may be anachronistic when retrojected onto the ancient context. Understanding the fluid and 'unfinished' nature of these texts challenges foundational assumptions in traditional textual criticism and demands reevaluating its methodologies and aims. This theme is critical because it reshapes the goals of textual criticism from pursuing a stable 'original text' toward appreciating textual fluidity and the dynamics of early Christian textual transmission.

Key finding: This paper demonstrates that modern critical editions inherently embody contradictory assumptions: while they visually scaffold a fixed, authorial text (via print conventions and apparatus), the underlying textual tradition... Read more
Key finding: This essay surveys the long-standing trajectory of New Testament textual criticism centered on the desire for an idealized, transcendent ‘original’ text, tracing how cultural expectations of textual purity and stability have... Read more

2. What role do Synoptic minor agreements and textual variants play in understanding the Synoptic Problem and Gospel interrelations?

This theme focuses on the investigation of textual phenomena known as ‘minor agreements’ (MAs) among the Synoptic Gospels—especially between Mark and its receptions in Matthew and Luke—to elucidate the mechanics of compositional history, editorial intervention, and textual transmission. Characterizing and classifying these subtle agreements and variants refines understanding of Gospel interdependency and challenges assumptions about independent or direct literary relationships. These studies contribute methodologically by introducing refined classifications and by emphasizing the importance of rigorous manuscript-level textual analysis for reconstructing early Gospel reception.

Key finding: This study introduces a new classification system for minor agreements (MAs) into additions, omissions, relocations, and reformulations, using Mark 13:5-37 as an empirically grounded case. It shows that a detailed evaluation... Read more
Key finding: This volume provides extensive textual commentary on variants of the Gospel of Mark, elucidating detailed manuscript evidence along with translation choices. It showcases how variant readings among different text-types and... Read more
Key finding: This historical and critical reflection challenges common assumptions about the Q source hypothesis as a solution to the Synoptic Problem. It reviews adaptive literary and source-critical theories over centuries, including... Read more

3. How do manuscript discoveries, paratextual features, and textual variants affect the reconstruction and interpretation of the New Testament text?

This research area explores the role of manuscript evidence—including rare readings, palimpsests, and paratextual elements like marginalia, titles, and apparatuses—in shaping the textual critical enterprise. Attention to the manuscript tradition’s complexity, including the reception history and editorial layers, critically informs the understanding of text fluidity, scribal interventions, and interpretative frameworks. This theme emphasizes the multifaceted nature of textual transmission and cautions against simplistic conceptions of a fixed, singular text.

Key finding: Through multispectral imaging and codicological study of Christian Palestinian Aramaic palimpsests, this paper recovers and reconstructs undertexts of Pauline and Apostolic manuscripts, illuminating Byzantine and regional... Read more
Key finding: This study identifies four notable rare and ancient variant readings preserved uniquely in the Syriac Harklean version, a relatively late but complex translation of the New Testament. The paper argues that these variants,... Read more
Key finding: This book review foregrounds the significance of paratextual elements—such as titles, marginal notations, cross-references, and prefaces—in shaping the reception, interpretation, and authority of New Testament manuscripts. It... Read more
Key finding: This article argues that the interpretive categorization of Luke 16:19–31 as a parable emerged following the rediscovery of Codex Bezae with its variant reading supporting the parabolic label, marking a significant shift in... Read more
Key finding: Reevaluation of manuscript GA 0206 reveals textual peculiarities in First Peter 5 aligning partially with Byzantine and Alexandrian readings. The analysis exposes editorial inconsistencies in critical editions (NA27)... Read more

All papers in New Testament Textual Criticism

The discovery of the Bar Kokhba letters in the Judean Desert has provided invaluable insights into the structural, organizational, and administrative aspects of the shortlived state under the leadership of Shimʿon Bar Kosiba (132-135/6... more
Dumbarton Oaks Papers
Hebrews uses the exact form Paul identifies in 2 Thessalonians.-3. Addressing Style Objections Critics argue Hebrews' style is more polished than Paul's other letters and lacks a personal introduction. Possible explanations: Paul may have... more
This paper presents a critical analysis of a 2016 debate featuring Muslim apologist Dr. Zakir Naik, focusing on his arguments against the divinity of Jesus Christ. The study examines Dr. Naik's specific claims, including the alleged... more
ივანე ჯავახიშვილის სახელობის თბილისის სახელმწიფო უნივერსიტეტი ჰუმანიტარულ მეცნიერებათა ფაკულტეტი ილია ცეცხლაძე ათანასე ალექსანდრიელის ჰომილიის -"აღწერისათჳს ღმრთისმშობელისა და იოსებისა" -ძველი ქართული თარგმანი (ტექსტი, გამოკვლევა და... more
The Roman general Vespasian is regarded as a military genius of low origins who put down the revolt in Judea to bring a measure of peace to the Roman Empire. But evidence has been provided by the late Guy Edward Farquhar Chilver,... more
3rd-4th c. 4th c.
2. Even this is changing, as online collections like the Internet Archive <archive.org> continually add digitized versions of these resources, which are available for users to rent or download freely. In this essay, rather than printing... more
Die Behandlung der griechischen Konjunk5on ὅτι in den ältesten lateinischen Übersetzungen des Markusevangeliums. Ein Beitrag zur Frage der altlateinischen Übersetzungstechnik" ["The Treatment of the Greek Conjunc9on ὅτι in the earliest... more
In recent years, discussions regarding the historical accuracy and textual integrity of scripture have transcended academic discussions and permeated the daily life of the church. This article aims to investigate significant passages in... more
Este estudio informa y analiza la evidencia que apoya la interpolación de la Perícopa de la Adúltera en los Evangelios, especialmente en Juan 7:53-8:11, por parte de escribas anónimos, basándose en la Ciencia de la Crítica Textual. Por lo... more
What then shall we say to these things? If God is for us, who can be against us?" The Apostle Paul, having finished the glorious words that make up the "golden chain of salvation" in Romans 8:29-30, reaches a final climax that is a... more
This paper examines the concept of spiritual resistance as exemplified in the biblical narrative of Jesus, with particular focus on his confrontation with Satan as recorded in the Gospels of Matthew. Through an eschatological lens, this... more
An ancient controversy between the Catholics and the orthodox that dates to the 10th century. The Catholics believe that Covenant Thursday was the feast of passover, in which only unleavened bread is consumed, so Christ must have used... more
This paper argues that the Gospel story of Barabbas preserves a suppressed memory of Jesus as a militant figure, later reworked into the peaceful Christ of Christian theology. Early manuscripts of Matthew record the crowd choosing between... more
The Lord's Prayer in the 1537 Munster, the 1551 Cinquarbres, the 1555 DuTillet/1879 Herbst, the new Garza-Trimm/MS Or150, Howard’s Shem Tov editions (printed and A-G), the Hebrew manuscript Vat.ebr.100, and the Hebrew manuscript MS... more
This work surveys the "Third Quest" (TQ) of the historical Jesus with a focus on the various portraits of Jesus within the first century using the historical-critical method. It argues that such studies and portraits of Jesus have... more
A quick note on Postmillennialism and the modern nation state of Israel.
In Hebrews 12:27, does ὡς πεποιημένων belong with the preceding or following context? I attempt to settle this 19th century debate with recourse to ancient translations, exegetes, and the manuscript evidence.
Not exclusive but ALL inclusive. Any Doctrine that divides is Satanic.
Theme: The Power of Truth in the Face of Self-Deception: The Witness of St. John the Baptist "In the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, One God. Amen. O Lord, open our hearts and minds to receive the word of truth, that we... more
Jesus’ statement to the criminal on the cross recorded in Luke 23:43 has often been cited as evidence that the criminal went to Paradise that day. However, the correct reading hinges on the placement of the comma, either before or after... more
Preaching has historically occupied a central place in the life and mission of the church, functioning as both a theological proclamation and a pastoral responsibility. Within the African evangelical context, however, questions have... more
Do not cling to me" (Μή μου ἅπτου). These are the mysterious words that the risen Jesus tells Mary Magdalene in the Gospel of John 20:17. "The force of the saying is not clearly visible to many, for a mystery is hidden in it," declares... more
Near the end of the Apostle Paul’s life, in his second letter to Timothy, he wrote, “I have fought the good fight, I have finished the race, I have kept the faith” (2 Timothy 4:7). These metaphors were likely familiar to Timothy. It was... more
Background-Contemporary pulpits and lecture halls often echo with swelling honorifics-Major Prophet, His Holiness, Doctor-Apostle-that polish the speaker's nameplate while the lamp of humble witness sputters. This paper interrogates... more
Acts 16 presents a Spirit-led expansion of the Gospel through strategic mission, personal sacrifice, divine redirection, and supernatural intervention. The chapter underscores the apostolic commitment to doctrinal clarity, cultural... more
This paper examines what I call The Damon Richardson Effect—a manifestation of hypocrisy and a lying tongue within modern church leadership, revealed through the contradictory actions and public statements of Damon Richardson. Drawing... more
Philippians 1:12-18 I want you to know, brothers, that what has happened to me has really served to advance the gospel, 13 so that it has become known throughout the whole imperial guard and to all the rest that my imprisonment is for... more
But as for you, teach what accords with sound doctrine. 2 Older men are to be sober-minded, dignified, self-controlled, sound in faith, in love, and in steadfastness. 3 Older women likewise are to be reverent in behavior, not slanderers... more
Byzantine monks had close relationships with time, and they were intimately aware of how it was measured. Using both textual and material sources, this article examines the different ways the designated "timekeepers" of monasteries used... more
The Hebrew root ‫דבר‬ (d-b-r) encompasses meanings ranging from "word" and "speech" to "commandment," "story," and "event." This article explores the philological breadth of ‫דבר‬ in the Hebrew Bible, situating it within its... more
In the Christian tradition, fourteen letters of the New Testament have been attributed to the Apostle Paul. However, for seven of these letters-1 and 2 Timothy, Titus, Ephesians, Colossians, 2 Thessalonians, and Hebrews-the attribution to... more
Have you ever thought about why Jesus chose to speak in parables on many occasions? Now, in the parables, Jesus leads us to authentic listening, not only hearing what has been said.
But grace was given to each one of us according to the measure of Christ's gift. 8 Therefore it says, "When he ascended on high he led a host of captives, and he gave gifts to men." 9 In saying, "He ascended," what does it mean but that... more
Lucrarea de față face o trecere în revistă a meritelor Mitropolitului Dosoftei ca mare cărturar și traducător al spațiului românesc. Cuvinte-cheie: Dosoftei, traducător, cărturar, "perioada slavă", Așa cum cărţile și scrierile duc, peste... more
This article explores the inscription placed above the crucified Jesus, traditionally abbreviated as “INRI” (Iesus Nazarenus Rex Iudaeorum). While the four canonical Gospels transmit the wording of the titulus crucis in slightly different... more
Within the Textus Receptus, no book has provoked more textual scrutiny than Revelation, in part because several of its readings appear scarcely, if at all, in surviving Greek manuscripts. One such passage is found in Revelation 21:24, a... more
Ausführliche Begründung, warum der Original-Text "in euren Herzen" nicht wie üblich nach links zu "Morgenstern", sondern nach rechts bezieht.
Download research papers for free!