Chapter 12 of ‘Laudate Dominum’ discusses the foundation of primary churches in the Bailiwick of ‘s-Hertogenbosch between 700 and 1225. Primary churches were by definition founded in locations that did not yet belong to any parish....
moreChapter 12 of ‘Laudate Dominum’ discusses the foundation of primary churches in the Bailiwick of ‘s-Hertogenbosch between 700 and 1225. Primary churches were by definition founded in locations that did not yet belong to any parish.
First, for each church in the study area, it was determined whether it was a primary or secondary church. The conclusion is that there were 81 primary churches in the Bailiwick of 's-Hertogenbosch, including the parish church of Alphen, whose jurisdiction partially extended over this region, and including the two primary daughter churches in Diessen and Lommel. To put it more precisely: there are 81 churches for which there is no convincing evidence that they were founded within the jurisdiction of an existing parish church. A secondary church usually leaves traces that reveal its origins (designation as a daughter church or appendix in the sources - although not all daughter churches were secondary churches - , rights to tithes, the patronage, the right of collation, and certain obligations towards the mother church). After the distinction between primary and secondary churches was made, the periods in which the primary churches were founded were delineated using the methods described in chapter 8 and additional considerations. This never yielded a precise date, but rather periods rounded to the nearest fifty years. The length of these periods, or timelines, ranges from fifty years to 550 years. The results are presented in Appendix 1 at the end of this book.
For more than half of the parish churches dating from before approximately 1225, the founding date can be estimated within a period of no more than three centuries. This was sufficient to allow for some statistical analysis.
The analysis tentatively reveals the contours of an interesting development: a gradual increase in the number of founded primary churches until around 850, followed by a dip between approximately 850 and 950. After this, the number of newly founded primary churches increased again, peaking in the second half of the eleventh and the first half of the twelfth century. After that, it declined rapidly. The first primary churches may have been founded shortly before 700, but there is no hard evidence that any had been founded long before 721.
How does this development relate to the literature? In 1999, Bijsterveld proposed that churches were founded on several estates in Texandria as early as the eighth or ninth century, such as in Waalre, Ruimel, Bakel, and Reppel. Subsequently, a comprehensive parish organization was established in the diocese of Liège in the twelfth century, with the church of Ruimel being subordinated as a chapel to the parish church of Sint-Michielsgestel. My analysis suggests that the model proposed by Bijsterveld does not accurately reflect reality.
Verbesselt concludes that few churches were founded in the Kempen region in the eighth century. He bases this on socalled ‘Polyptica’ of the Benedictine Abbey of Lobbes. In these records only the church of Oudenburg is mentioned, and in the descriptions of the numerous 'villae' listed in Flanders and Brabant, no church is mentioned anywhere else. The 'Liber Traditionum' of St. Peter's Abbey in Ghent, which contains charters from the late seventh and early eighth centuries, also doesn't mention any churches. My analysis suggests this trend also to some extend applies to the Bailiwick region. Approximately only 13 primary churches in the Bailiwick were founded in the eigth century,
The dip in the number of newly built primary churches between approximately 850 and 950 aligns well with a hypothesis by Frans Theuws from 2011, based on archaeological research in Dommelen and Nederweert, among other places. Theuws states that the excavations, which allow us to form a picture of population development, show that the settlements still located on the site of the clustered settlements from around 650, shrank sharply to one or two farms. The scattered farms from the Carolingian period seem to have disappeared entirely. Few people seem to have lived in the Kempen region in the period 850-950. Possibly, habitation remained in large property complexes. From around 950, the population began to grow again. Building styles were different than before, which may indicate newcomers from elsewhere. Because of the assumptions and uncertainties in the data, further archaeological research is needed to confirm or not the dip in the number of new primary churches between 850 and 950.
As mentioned, the date of the founding of the primary churches could usually not be determined exactly. The dates were approximated using 50-year periods. The length of the periods in which the churches were founded ranges from fifty to 550 years. For the analysis in Laudate Dominum, the middle of these "timelines" was used. To further investigate the robustness of the result, the analysis was repeated after the publication of Laudate Dominum using a different method. This time, instead of using the middle of the timelines, each 50-year period was given an equal probability that the church was founded in that period.
According to this second analysis, 27 primary churches were founded in the period 700-950. According to the method described in Laudate Dominum, there were 25. These two results correspond well, and this appears to be a robust result. This provides a somewhat firmer basis for the reconstruction of the Woensel deanery, as described in Chapter 10.
The dip in church construction between 850 and 950 is not reflected in the second analytical method. This does not mean that this dip did not exist. The reality likely lay somewhere between method 1 (center of the timelines) and method 2 (equal probability for each 50-year period). Consider, for example, a normal distribution with a peak in the center of the timelines, with gradually decreasing probabilities further from the center. This still yields a dip between 850 and 950, but less pronounced than described in Laudate Dominum.
Demographic developments can explain the sharp increase in the construction of new primary churches in the period 1050-1150. Around 1050, strong population growth began, and with it, an increase in the amount of cultivated land. This development has been meticulously mapped for Veghel. There, the amount of private land increased sharply in the eleventh, twelfth, and thirteenth centuries. The estimates for this growth are: an average of 0.2 bunder per year between 725 and 1050; 5.3 bunder per year between 1050 and 1190; and 3.0 bunder per year between 1190 and 1314.
Before 1225, areas, which previously did not belong under any parish, were gradually filled in, until shortly after 1200, all houses and lands in the Bailiwick region fell under the jurisdiction of one or another parish church. On the sand ridge that stretched from Waalwijk and Drunen, and from Orthen to Oss, churches were not founded until the tenth or eleventh century. The fact that Chris de Bont does not indicate any ‘old forest floors' (‘moderpodzol bodems’) on this sand ridge is probably not a coincidence. Many areas with fertile 'old forest floors' were already inhabited from the seventh or eighth century onwards. Another area that provides insight into the process of ‘ecclesiastical colonization’ of a previously parish-less area is the region of the later parishes of Diessen, Hilvarenbeek, and Moergestel.
While the amount of cultivated land and the population in the Bailiwick region continued to increase steadily around 1200 or 1225, the establishment of new primary churches came to a rather abrupt end. There is only one good explanation for this: the parish network was completed. De last primary church build in this region was the church of Moergestel probably between 1200 and 1225. After around 1225 still new churches were founded, but these were secondary churches. This aligns well with Karel Leenders's finding that in western North Brabant and the adjacent part of Belgium, the parish network was completed between 1225 and 1275.