Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Outline

IBN KHALDUN'S ILM UL UMRĀN AND HISTORY OF JUDAISM

2021, Pakistan Journal of Historical Reseaech

Abstract

Main focus of the paper is the socio-historical studies of Judaism by Ibn Khaldun. Ibn Khaldun's scholarship and his contribution to the various domains of social sciences like history, sociology and politics has been acknowledged globally. While his both works al Ibar and Muqadimmah have remained the focus of many researches dealing with his social scientific theories and historical studies but Ibn Khaldun's approach to the study of other religions has been touched by only few scholars. It is the purpose of this study to examine and analyze Ibn Khaldun's Ilm ul-Umran (science of society) and its correlation with the history of Judaism. In an attempt to highlight and discuss his approach to the study of Judaism the research will firstly discuss his contribution to the study of Judaism in Muqaddimah and then in al Ibar decisively showing his two distinct methods for dealing with the Jewish history and religion. For him, Jews are the best example to explain his Umran science and his socio-historical theories that he has discussed at length in his Muqaddimah. Thus, he takes Jewish history as a prototype for explaining the theoretical framework of his science al Umran. According to him Jewish history is the best example for study of human history and society as they have experienced many rises and falls throughout their history. Likewise, their history is replete with examples of various models of social life; they experienced the dessert and sedentary life, they lost their social and political status many times and regained it by their group solidarity. This study is based on qualitative research design and applies the content analysis to trace and collect the data related to the theoretical and historical study of Judaism scattered in his al Ibar and Muqaddimah and textual analysis to describe, interpret and analyze these themes to frame together a comprehensive approach of Ibn Khadun to study of Judaism.

Key takeaways
sparkles

AI

  1. Ibn Khaldun uses Jewish history as a prototype for his socio-historical theories in Ilm ul-Umran.
  2. He identifies four aspects of Umran: historical, anthropological, sociological, and political.
  3. Jewish history illustrates cycles of rise and fall, framed by Khaldun's 'asābīyāh theory.
  4. Khaldun critiques Jewish concepts, linking them to socio-political dynamics and group solidarity.
  5. The study employs qualitative analysis to synthesize Khaldun's views on Judaism across his major works.

References (22)

  1. Ibn Khaldun's book of history and Al-Muqadimmah are not separate from each other. Although many researchers do not consider his book of history, but it has an important link to his sociological discussions in Muqadimmah. In other words, for Ibn Khaldun history and sociology are related to each other. Ibn Khaldun discusses this history of Jews in the first volume of kitab al-ibar. In his first volume he starts the history of world from Prophet Adam A.S and Prophet Nuh A.S and he starts history of Jews from Prophet Ibrahim A.S. Ibn Khaldun takes references not only from the Muslim sources but also from Jewish and non-Jewish sources. He uses the sources of Tabari, Masudi and Ibn Ishaq. He prefers the Jewish historical sources of Yusuf bin Kuryun. He also quotes Christian historians named Horosius and Ibn Amid many times. Ibn Khaldun is a historian who focuses on formulating of dynasties, achieving social and political authority. Throughout his work on Judaism the focus is on political and social history of Judaism and he specifically highlights the role of their religious leaders in their political and social matters. Ibn Khaldun takes references from Torah to explain his main theories of umrān science. The history of Judaism plays a significant role in Khaldunian studies. Indeed, Jews were the best example for Ibn Khaldun to explain his social theories because the nation of Jews had many ups and downs throughout the history. They were also a best example for Ibn Khaldun because they experienced desert and sedentary life many times. His socio-historical approach gives a unique perception of Jewish history. Ibn Khaldun's scientific attempt to study of history paved the way for scientific study of Judaism.
  2. Abd Al-Rahman Ibn Khaldun. (2000). Tarikh Ibn Khaldun (Khalil Shihadah, Ed.). Dar al-Fikr.
  3. Abd Al-Rahman Ibn Khaldun. (2001). Muqadimmah Ibn Khaldun (Suhayl Zikaar, Ed.; Vol. 1). Dar al-Fikr.
  4. Abd Al-Rahman Ibn Khaldun. (2003). Tarikh Ibn Khaldun (Hakeem Ahmed Hussein Ala-Abadi, Trans.; Vol. 1). Nafees Academy Press.
  5. Al-Quran. (n.d.).
  6. Avi Beker. (2008). The Chosen: The History of an Idea, the Anatomy of an Obsession. Palgrave Macmillan.
  7. Bland, K. (1983). An Islamic Theory of Jewish History: The Case of Ibn Khaldun. Journal of Asian and African Studies, 18(3), 189.
  8. Bukhari, M. bin I. (1998). Sahih Bukhari. International Ideas Home for Publishing and Distribution.
  9. Cooley, C. H. (1920). Reflections Upon the Sociology of Herbert Spencer. American Journal of Sociology, 26(2), 129-145.
  10. Hebrew English Tanakh: The Jewish Bible. (2009). Varda Books.
  11. Ibn Khaldun. (2000). Tarikh Ibn Khaldun (K. Shihadah, Ed.). Dar ul Fikr.
  12. Ibn Khaldun, & W. udeen A. R. (2004). Muqadimmah Ibn Khaldun (D. Abdullah Muhammad, Ed.; Vol. 1). Dar e Yu'rab.
  13. Khaldûn, I. I., & Lawrence, B. B. (2015). The Muqaddimah: An Introduction to History -Abridged Edition (N. J. Dawood, Ed.; F. Rosenthal, Trans.; Abridged edition). Princeton University Press.
  14. Montefiore, S. S. (2011). Jerusalem: The Biography. Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group. Pines, S. (1970). Ibn Khaldun and Maimonides, a compararison between two texts. https://doi.org/10.2307/1595224
  15. Pro. Hillel Frisch. (2018, August 21). Ibn Khaldun and the Nation State Law. The Begin-Sadat Center For Strategic Studies.
  16. Reuven Firestone. (n.d.). Children of Abraham: An Introduction to Judaism for Muslims. KTAV Publishing House.
  17. Roy Jackson. (2006). Fifty Key Figures In Islam. Routledge.
  18. Salime Leyla GÜRKAN. (n.d.). Some Implications of Ibn Khaldun's Approach to the History of The People of Israel: The Relation Between Asabiya and Chosenness.
  19. The Muqaddimah. (2015). https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691166285/the- muqaddimah
  20. Walter J. Fischel. (2009). Ibn Khaldun's Use of Historical Sources. Maisonneuve & Larose. Wan Mohd Farzul Azadi Wan Razali. (2017). An Analysis of Ibn Khaldun's Study of other Religions in the Muqadimmah. University Kebangsaan Malaysia.
  21. What Would Ibn Khaldun Say? -Israel National News. (n.d.). Retrieved 3 December 2021, from https://www.israelnationalnews.com/Articles/Article.aspx/4024
  22. Yücekaya, M. (n.d.). A Thesis Submitted To The Graduate School Of Social Sciences Of Middle East Technical University. 133.