Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Outline

Title
Abstract
Discussion of the Basic Assumptions
Finding Distances
References

Out of Nowhere: Spacetime from causality: causal set theory

Profile image of Christian WuthrichChristian Wuthrich

2020

Abstract

This is a chapter of the planned monograph "Out of Nowhere: The Emergence of Spacetime in Quantum Theories of Gravity", co-authored by Nick Huggett and Christian Wuthrich and under contract with Oxford University Press. (More information at www.beyondspacetime.net.) This chapter introduces causal set theory and identifies and articulates a 'problem of space' in this theory.

Related papers

The Structure of Causal Sets
Christian Wuthrich

Journal for General Philosophy of Science, 2012

More often than not, recently popular structuralist interpretations of physical theories leave the central concept of a structure insufficiently precisified. The incipient causal sets approach to quantum gravity offers a paradigmatic case of a physical theory predestined to be interpreted in structuralist terms. It is shown how employing structuralism lends itself to a natural interpretation of the physical meaning of causal sets theory. Conversely, the conceptually exceptionally clear case of causal sets is used as a foil to illustrate how a mathematically informed rigorous conceptualization of structure serves to identify structures in physical theories. Furthermore, a number of technical issues infesting structuralist interpretations of physical theories such as difficulties with grounding the identity of the places of highly symmetrical physical structures in their relational profile and what may resolve these difficulties can be vividly illustrated with causal sets.

View PDFchevron_right
Directions in Causal Set Quantum Gravity
S Surya

Arxiv preprint arXiv:1103.6272, 2011

Abstract: In the causal set approach to quantum gravity the spacetime continuum arises as an approximation to a fundamentally discrete substructure, the causal set, which is a locally finite partially ordered set. The causal set paradigm was elucidated in a classic paper by ...

View PDFchevron_right
Curved Spacetime in the Causal Set approach to Quantum Gravity
Ayush Dhital

2021

Causal Set theory is an approach to quantum gravity. In this approach, the spacetime continuum is assumed to be discrete rather than continuous. The discrete points in a causal set can be seen as a continuum spacetime if they can be embedded in a manifold such that the causal structure is preserved. In this regard, a manifold can be constructed by embedding a causal set preserving causal information between the neighboring points. In this thesis, some of the fundamental properties of causal sets are discussed and the curvature and dimension information of Minkowski, de Sitter, and Anti-de Sitter spaces is approximated using chain length distributions. The accuracy of the results is compared with the continuum manifold and the feasibility of such an approach is discussed. In the first chapter, the need for quantizing gravity is addressed and the concept of spacetime and Lorentz boosts is delineated at length. The second chapter begins with a formal definition of a causal set and delv...

View PDFchevron_right
On the Foundation of Space and Time by Quantum-Events
Andreas Schlatter

Foundations of Physics, 2021

The true nature of space and time has been a topic of natural philosophy, passed down since the presocratic era. In modern times reflection has particularly been inspired by the physical theories of Newton and Einstein and, more recently, by the quest for a theory of quantum gravity. In this paper we want to specify the idea that material systems and their spatio-temporal distances emerge from quantum-events. We will show a mechanism, by which quantum-events induce a metric field between material systems, which is governed by Einstein's equation including a cosmological constant.

View PDFchevron_right
Gravity and matter in causal set theory
Luca Bombelli, Roman Sverdlov

Classical and Quantum Gravity, 2009

View PDFchevron_right
The emergence of spacetime in quantum theories of gravity - eScholarship
Christian Wuthrich

2013

View PDFchevron_right
Causality and relativity in quantum physics
Johan Prins

arXiv (Cornell University), 2006

It is argued here that the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics violates the tenets on which both Galileo's and Einstein's theories of relativity are based. It is postulated that the "building blocks" of the universe are not "particles" but are holistic wave-entitities which act and interact with other wave-entities as one would expect from waves. A new approach to model the free electron is presented. It is argued from Coulomb's law that the electromagnetic quantum-field energy is not part of an electric field surrounding the electron, but is localised, so that it is wholly equal to the mass of the electron. It is found that an energy component must also exist along a fourth spatial dimension which could be the origin of the "dark energy" in the universe and which, in turn, should be responsible for "vacuum-fluctuations" as governed by Heisenberg's uncertainty relationship for energy and time. The possible consequences of this approach are analysed and discussed.

View PDFchevron_right
CAUSALITY AND SPACETIME STRUCTURE
MANOELITO DE SOUZA

Pre-print UFES-DF-MMS.1993/4, 1993

We discuss the level of implementation of causality in field theory, highlight features of a proposed [1] new model of spacetime structure with a stricter causality implementation which produces an infinityfree formalism with a linear and conformally invariant dynamics. This is relevant since it extends to 4-dimensions results known, up to now, only in bi-dimensional theories. It is particularly interesting that even in a still purely classical formulation it brings, naturally, the idea of quantum of a field, its particle likeness. The standard formalism with all its infinities and divergencies is retrieved in terms of average fields. The singularity of a field is shown to be just a consequence of this averaging in its definiton.

View PDFchevron_right
Spacetime is as spacetime does
Christian Wuthrich

2018

Theories of quantum gravity generically presuppose or predict that the reality underlying relativistic spacetimes they are describing is significantly non-spatiotemporal. On pain of empirical incoherence, approaches to quantum gravity must establish how relativistic spacetime emerges from their non-spatiotemporal structures. We argue that in order to secure this emergence, it is sufficient to establish that only those features of relativistic spacetimes functionally relevant in producing empirical evidence must be recovered. In order to complete this task, an account must be given of how the more fundamental structures instantiate these functional roles. We illustrate the general idea in the context of causal set theory and loop quantum gravity, two prominent approaches to quantum gravity.

View PDFchevron_right
A Specimen of Theory Construction from Quantum Gravity
Rafael Sorkin

The Creation of Ideas in Physics, 1995

I describe the history of my attempts to arrive at a discrete substratum underlying the spacetime manifold, culminating in the hypothesis that the basic structure has the form of a partial-order (i.e. that it is a causal set). Like the other speakers in this session, I too am here much more as a working scientist than as a philosopher. Of course it is good to remember Peter Bergmann's description of the physicist as "in many respects a philosopher in workingman's* clothes", but today I'm not going to change into a white shirt and attempt to draw philosophical lessons from the course of past work on quantum gravity. Instead I will merely try to recount a certain part of my own experience with this problem, explaining how I arrived at the idea of what I will call a causal set. This and similar structures have been proposed more than once as discrete replacements for spacetime. My excuse for not telling you also how others arrived at essentially the same idea [1] is naturally that my case is the only one I can hope to reconstruct with even minimal accuracy.

View PDFchevron_right

References (57)

  1. Victor Ambarzumian and Dmitri Iwanenko. Zur Frage nach Vermeidung der unendlichen Selbst- rückwirkung des Elektrons. Zeitschrift für Physik, 64(7-8):563-567, 1930.
  2. Luca Bombelli. Space-time as causal set. PhD thesis, Syracuse University, 1987.
  3. Luca Bombelli, Joohan Lee, David Meyer, and Rafael Sorkin. Spacetime as a causal set. Physical Review Letters, 59:521-524, 1987.
  4. Graham Brightwell. Partial orders. In Lowell W Beineke and Robin J Wilson, editors, Graph Connections: Relationships between Graph Theory and other Areas of Mathematics, pages 52-69. Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1997.
  5. Graham Brightwell and Ruth Gregory. Structure of random discrete spacetime. Physics Review Letters, 66:260-263, 1991.
  6. Graham Brightwell and Douglas B West. Partially ordered sets. In Kenneth H Rosen, edi- tor, Handbook of Discrete and Combinatorial Mathematics, pages 717-752. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 2000.
  7. Fay Dowker. Being and becoming on the road to quantum gravity: or, the birth of a baby is not a baby. In Nick Huggett, Keizo Matsubara, and Christian Wüthrich, editors, Beyond Spacetime: The Foundations of Quantum Gravity, pages 133-142. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2020.
  8. Benjamin F Dribus. On the axioms of causal set theory. Manuscript, 2013. URL http://arxiv. org/abs/1311.2148.
  9. Benjamin F Dribus. Discrete Causal Set Theory: Emergent Spacetime and the Causal Metric Hypothesis. Springer, Cham, 2017.
  10. Ben Dushnik and E W Miller. Partially ordered sets. American Journal of Mathematics, 63: 600-610, 1941.
  11. John Earman. Notes on the causal theory of time. Synthese, 24:74-86, 1972.
  12. Philipp Ehrlich. Are points (necessarily) unextended? Manuscript, 2015.
  13. Stefan Felsner, Peter C Fishburn, and William T Trotter. Finite three dimensional partial orders which are not sphere orders. Discrete Mathematics, 201:101-132, 1999.
  14. Stefan Felsner, Irina Mustatȃ, and Martin Pergel. The complexity of the partial order dimension problem-closing the gap. Manuscript, 2014.
  15. David Finkelstein. The space-time code. Physical Review, 184:1261-1271, 1969.
  16. Adolf Grünbaum. Philosophical Problems of Space and Time. Alfred A. Knopf, New York, 1963.
  17. Adolf Grünbaum. Modern Science and Zeno's Paradoxes. George Allen and Unwin, London, 1967.
  18. Stephen W Hawking and George F R Ellis. The Large Scale Structure of Space-time. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1979.
  19. Stephen W Hawking, A R King, and P J McCarthy. A new topology for curved space-time which incorporates the causal, differential, and conformal Journal of Mathematical Physics, 17:174-181, 1976.
  20. Joe Henson. The causal set approach to quantum gravity. In Daniele Oriti, editor, Approaches to Quantum Gravity: Toward a New Understanding of Space, Time and Matter, pages 393-413. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2009.
  21. David Hilbert and Nick Huggett. Groups in mind. Philosophy of Science, 73:765-777, 2006.
  22. Toshio Hiraguchi. On the dimension of partially ordered sets. Science Reports of Kanazawa University, 1:77-94, 1951.
  23. Nick Huggett, Tiziana Vistarini, and Christian Wüthrich. Time in quantum gravity. In Adrian Bardon and Heather Dyke, editors, The Blackwell Companion to the Philosophy of Time, pages 242-261. Blackwell, Chichester, 2013.
  24. Raluca Ilie, Gregory B Thompson, and David D Reid. A numerical study of the correspondence between paths in a causal set and geodesics in the continuum. Classical and Quantum Gravity, 23:3275-3285, 2006.
  25. E. H. Kronheimer and Roger Penrose. On the structure of causal spaces. Mathematical Proceed- ings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, 63:481-501, 1967.
  26. Koen Lefever. A century of axiomatic systems for ordinal approaches to special relativity theory. Manuscript, 2013.
  27. Seth Major, David Rideout, and Sumati Surya. Spatial hypersurfaces in causal set cosmology. Classical and Quantum Gravity, 23:4743-4752, 2006.
  28. Seth Major, David Rideout, and Sumati Surya. On recovering continuum topology from a causal set. Journal of Mathematical Physics, 48:032501, 2007.
  29. David B Malament. The class of continuous timelike curves determines the topology of spacetime. Journal of Mathematical Physics, 18:1399-1404, 1977.
  30. Henryk Mehlberg. Essai sur la théorie causale du temps. Studia Philosophica, 1:119-258, 1935.
  31. Henryk Mehlberg. Essai sur la théorie causale du temps. Studia Philosophica, 2:111-231, 1937.
  32. David A Meyer. The Dimension of Causal Sets. PhD thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Tech- nology, 1988.
  33. David A Meyer. Spherical containment and the minkowski dimension of partial orders. Order, 10:227-237, 1993.
  34. Jan Myrheim. Statistical geometry. Technical Report TH-2538, CERN preprint, 1978.
  35. L A Paul and Ned Hall. Causation: A User's Guide. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2013.
  36. Henri Poincaré. Science and Hypothesis. Walter Scott Publishing Company, London and Newcastle-on-Tyne, 1905.
  37. Hans Reichenbach. Axiomatik der relativistischen Raum-Zeit-Lehre. Friedrich Vieweg und Sohn, Braunschweig, 1924.
  38. Hans Reichenbach. Philosophie der Raum-Zeit-Lehre. Walter de Gruyter, Berlin and Leipzig, 1928.
  39. Hans Reichenbach. The Direction of Time. University of California Press, Berkeley, 1956.
  40. David D. Reid. Discrete quantum gravity and causal sets. Canadian Journal of Physics, 79: 1-16, 2001.
  41. David Rideout and Petros Wallden. Emergence of spatial structure from causal sets. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 174:012017, 2009.
  42. Bernhard Riemann. Über die Hypothesen, welche der Geometrie zugrunde liegen. Abhandlungen der königlichen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen, pages 133-152, 1868.
  43. Alfred A Robb. A Theory of Time and Space. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1914.
  44. Alfred A Robb. The Geometry of Time and Space. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1936.
  45. Lawrence Sklar. Prospects for a causal theory of space-time. In Richard Swinburne, editor, Space, Time and Causality, pages 45-62. D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht, 1983.
  46. Chris Smeenk and Christian Wüthrich. Time travel and time machines. In Craig Callender, editor, The Oxford Handbook of Philosophy of Time, pages 577-630. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2011.
  47. Hartland S. Snyder. Quantized space-time. Physical Review, 71:38-41, 1947.
  48. Rafael Sorkin. A specimen of theory construction from quantum gravity. In Jarrett Leplin, editor, The Creation of Ideas in Physics: Studies for a Methodology of Theory Construction, Univer- sity of Western Ontario Series in Philosophy of Science, pages 167-179. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 1995.
  49. Gerard 't Hooft. Quantum gravity: A fundamental problem and some radical ideas. In Maurice Lévy and Stanley Deser, editors, Recent Developments in Gravitation: Cargèse 1978, pages 323-345. Plenum Press, New York and London, 1979.
  50. Bas C van Fraassen. An Introduction to the Philosophy of Time and Space. Random House, New York, 1970.
  51. Robert M Wald. General Relativity. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London, 1984.
  52. John A Winnie. The causal theory of space-time. In John Earman, Clark Glymour, and John Stachel, editors, Foundations of Space-Tome Theories, volume 8 of Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science, pages 134-205. University of Minnesota Press, 1977.
  53. Christian Wüthrich. Challenging the spacetime structuralist. Philosophy of Science, 65:1039- 1051, 2009.
  54. Christian Wüthrich. The structure of causal sets. Journal for General Philosophy of Science, 43:223-241, 2012.
  55. Christian Wüthrich. Time travelling in emergent spacetime. In Judit Madarász and Gergely Székely, editors, Hajnal Andréka and István Németi on the Unity of Science: From Computing to Relativity Theory Through Algebraic Logic. Springer, forthcoming.
  56. Christian Wüthrich and Craig Callender. What becomes of a causal set. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 68:907-925, 2017.
  57. E Christopher Zeeman. Causality implies the Lorentz group. Journal of Mathematical Physics, 5:490-493, 1964.

Related papers

Out of Nowhere: The emergence of spacetime from causal sets
Nick Huggett

arXiv: History and Philosophy of Physics, 2020

This is a chapter of the planned monograph "Out of Nowhere: The Emergence of Spacetime in Quantum Theories of Gravity", co-authored by Nick Huggett and Christian Wuthrich and under contract with Oxford University Press. (More information at www.beyondspacetime.net.) This chapter sketches how spacetime emerges in causal set theory and demonstrates how this question is deeply entangled with genuinely philosophical concerns.

View PDFchevron_right
Space-time as a causal set
Rafael Sorkin

Physical Review Letters, 1987

We propose that space-time at the smallest scales is in reality a causal set: a locally finite set of elements endowed with a partial order corresponding to the macroscopic relation that defines past and future. We explore how a Lorentzian manifold can approximate a causal set, noting in particular that the thereby defined effective dimensionality of a given causal set can vary with length scale. Finally, we speculate brieAy on the quantum dynamics of causal sets, indicating why an appropriate choice of action can reproduce general relativity in the classical limit.

View PDFchevron_right
Causal Theories of Spacetime
Baptiste Le Bihan

Noûs, 2023

We develop a new version of the causal theory of spacetime. Whereas traditional versions of the theory seek to identify spatiotemporal relations with causal relations, the version we develop takes causal relations to be the grounds for spatiotemporal relations. Causation is thus distinct from, and more basic than, spacetime. We argue that this non-identity theory, suitably developed, avoids the challenges facing the traditional identity theory.

View PDFchevron_right
Axiomatic causal theory of space-time
Alexander К O N S T A N T I N O V I C H Guts

Gravitation and Cosmology

Principles of construction of a causal space-time theory are discussed. A system of axioms for Special Relativity Theory, which postulates the macrocausality and continuity of time order, is considered. The posibilities of a topos-theoretic approach to the foundations of Relativity Theory are investigated. Construction of a causal theory of space-time is one of the most attractive tasks of science in the 20th century. From the viewpoint of mathematics, partially ordered structures should be considered. The latter is commonly understood as a set V with a specified reflexive and transitive binary relation. A primary notion is actually not that of causality but rather that of motion (interaction) of material objects. Causality is brought to the foreground since an observer detects changes of object motion or state. It is this detection that gives rise to the view of a particular significance of causes and effects for a phenomenon under study, along with the conviction that causal connections are non-symmetric. Causality is treated as such a relation in the material world that plays a key role in explaining the topological, metric and all other world structures.

View PDFchevron_right
Out of Nowhere: Introduction: The emergence of spacetime
Christian Wuthrich

2021

Quantum gravity and philosophy 2 2 Worlds without spacetime? 4 3 Challenges to spacetime emergence 7 4 Physical salience 9 * This is a chapter of the planned monograph Out of Nowhere: The Emergence of Spacetime in Quantum Theories of Gravity, co-authored by Nick Huggett and Christian Wüthrich and under contract with Oxford University Press. More information at www.beyondspacetime.net. This work was supported financially by the ACLS and the John Templeton Foundation (the views expressed are those of the authors not necessarily those of the sponsors.

View PDFchevron_right
580 California St., Suite 400
San Francisco, CA, 94104
© 2025 Academia. All rights reserved