Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Outline

Digital Material

Abstract

This article for Estonian magazine MAJA advances the argument that what we consider “digital” in architecture, may in fact be analog. Architects have consistently misunderstood the nature of the digital, and have mainly based their argument on “the affordance” of computer controlled machines to create differentiated forms. This analog approach to digital manufacturing has led to a situation where architecture is reduced to a surface and disconnected from the actual economic and political implications of digital manufacturing tools. The article develops a series of arguments and discussions about the relationship between “the digital” and architecture. It advances the criticism that “we have never been digital” - not as a negative, counter-argument, but as something propositional, continuing the project of the digital in architecture in the long run - post 2008. The text advances the Digital and Discrete, as a propositional argument for another way to think about the digital and architecture, driven by the notion of a digital building block. It is an invitation to leave the surface behind, to recolonise the depth of architecture, fundamentally questioning how it is produced, distributed, and given form. Apart of the more architectural questions related to syntax and part-to-whole relations, a focus on digital production beyond mere formal differentiation sets up a discussion about the potential social agency of these tools. It enables the possibility for architects to engage the digital in a larger social discussion. At the same time, the focus on parts, composition and syntax keep this discussion firmly grounded in design. In the digital-discrete, the political engagement is integrated : digital fabrication tools are understood as a way to engage with modes of production and therefore also social and political ideas. Rather than an isolated conversation about material behaviour and structural performance, architects can use their understanding of digital workflows to contribute ideas to a vivid cultural and political debate about the future of capitalism, automation, the status of the city, housing etc.

FAQs

sparkles

AI

What explains the transition from continuous to discrete design paradigms in architecture?add

The paper argues that architects misunderstood the digital realm, mistaking discrete computational design for production efficiency since the 1990s. Carpo highlights how this misunderstanding persists into the Second Digital Age, limiting true digital architecture.

How does digital production challenge traditional manufacturing processes?add

Digital production allows for localized, efficient manufacturing, reducing reliance on extensive supply chains. Jeremy Rifkin suggests products can be rapidly customized without additional costs, transforming traditional production models.

What role do tools like CNC machines play in the architectural design process?add

CNC machines have been pivotal since the 1990s, enabling mass-customization but often still following traditional fabrication techniques. Projects like the Diamond House showcase the potential of CNC for distributed manufacturing.

When did the concept of digital architecture evolve to include social implications?add

The discussion intensified post-2010, reflecting on design's societal impacts alongside technological advancements. Recent examples like Wikihouse emphasize democratizing construction through open-source platforms.

What are the implications of a fully digital syntax in architecture?add

A fully digital syntax, as proposed in the paper, shifts focus from geometry to relations among parts. This change fosters an architecture adaptable to various social and political contexts.

References (2)

  1. " We have never been digital" and the link with Latour and Negroponte was first used by Thomas Haigh in the context of digital humanities. The statement here does not refer to Thomas Haigh's article which is rather skeptical of the impact of digital technologies.
  2. Carpo refers to the work of EZCT, Biothing, Kokkugia and Michael Hansmeyer.