Inside the Black Box
2017, International Journal of Information Systems and Social Change
https://doi.org/10.4018/IJISSC.2017100101Abstract
Thisarticleusesanoriginalthree-phaseapproachforempiricalassessmentandcomparativeevaluation oftheefficiencyofuniversitytechnologytransfer.Itisbasedonanalysisofinputsandoutputsofa disclosurephasefollowedbyavalue-addphaseandafinallicensephase,usingamultidimensional framework.TheobjectiveistofinduniversityTechnologyTransferOffice(TTO)efficiencyand effectivenesspatternsforeachphaseaswellasoverallTTprocesses.AnetworkDataEnvelopment Analysis(DEA)modelwasusedtoanalyzeanddescribethecomplicatedTToperationalprocesses usingAssociationofUniversityTechnologyManagersdatacollectedfrom90USuniversityTTOs fortheperiod2007-2013.ItwasconcludedthatthesampledTTOsweremostinefficientintheir value-add(2nd)phaseandthattheaverageoverallefficiencyaswellastheefficiencyofdisclosure (1st)andlicense(3rd)phasesdecreasedduringthelastfiveyearsofdataanalyzed.Inaddition,in linewithotherstudies,analysissupportsthecontentionthatthepresenceofmedicalschooldoesnot increaseTTefficiencyoreffectiveness.Thepresentresearch'scontributionsfocusonthreeareas: (1)AnalysingandmodellingTTOvalorizationandcommercializationprocesswithaUMLactivity diagramtoprovideaclearpictureofTTproceduresandprocesses;(2)Proposingathree-phaseDEA frameworkshowinginput/outputindicatorscloselyrelatedtoeachphaseofprocessesratherthan ablackboxorseparatedactivities;(3)OfferingastrategytoconductempiricalstudiesonTTO's operationalefficiencytherebyhelpingtobetterunderstandfutureresearchoperationalproblems.
FAQs
AI
What are the main metrics used to assess TTO efficiency?
The study identifies critical metrics such as licensing income (86.7%), royalties (66.7%), and patents (46.7%) as essential for evaluating TTO efficiency.
How does the multidimensional input-output framework enhance TTO performance evaluation?
The multidimensional framework of Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) allows for a comprehensive assessment of efficiency across critical phases of technology transfer.
Why do traditional output measures inadequately reflect TTO performance?
Traditional measures, like licensing income, often focus on blockbuster assets and fail to capture overall TTO operational efficiency, leading to misleading evaluations.
What challenges exist in evaluating TTO operations over time?
Many TTO activities involve tacit knowledge exchange and long-term strategy development, complicating longitudinal performance assessments and efficiency evaluations.
What insights does the empirical study reveal about TTO operational processes?
The study outlines three distinct sub-phases within TTO operations, emphasizing the need for specific process guidance to improve effectiveness and efficiency.