Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Winner Determination

description21 papers
group1 follower
lightbulbAbout this topic
Winner determination is a process in operations research and game theory that identifies the optimal choice or outcome among competing alternatives based on predefined criteria and constraints. It involves evaluating options to ascertain which one maximizes utility or satisfies specific objectives, often within competitive environments such as auctions or resource allocation scenarios.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Winner determination is a process in operations research and game theory that identifies the optimal choice or outcome among competing alternatives based on predefined criteria and constraints. It involves evaluating options to ascertain which one maximizes utility or satisfies specific objectives, often within competitive environments such as auctions or resource allocation scenarios.

Key research themes

1. How can winner determination be efficiently solved and approximated in combinatorial and multi-attribute auctions?

This research area focuses on algorithmic and heuristic techniques for deciding the winning bids in auctions where multiple items with diverse attributes are involved and bids may be for combinations of items. Efficient winner determination is critical as such problems are computationally challenging (often NP-hard), requiring novel optimization methods to find near-optimal or exact solutions within reasonable time, particularly for real-time and large-scale applications.

Key finding: This paper proposes a genetic algorithm (GA) approach for winner determination in combinatorial reverse auctions incorporating all-units discounts and sellers' stock availability. The method effectively minimizes procurement... Read more
Key finding: The authors present GACRA, a GA-based method with enhanced repair and crossover strategies to maintain feasible and diverse candidate solutions for winner determination. Statistical experiments across multiple runs show... Read more
Key finding: This work extends classical Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT) and Conditional Preference networks (CP-nets) to enable buyer preference specification including quantitative, qualitative, and conditional preferences for... Read more

2. What is the computational complexity landscape and parameterized tractability in winner determination for voting and judgment aggregation?

This theme explores the computational difficulty of identifying winners in social choice contexts such as Dodgson elections and judgment aggregation, with particular focus on hardness results, parameterized complexity analysis, and the existence of efficient algorithms or kernels. Understanding this landscape informs the design of practical voting systems and aggregation rules by highlighting algorithmic limitations and guiding approximations or parameter-based strategies.

Key finding: The paper establishes that computing the Dodgson score of a candidate is computationally hard, specifically showing that the problem parameterized by the number of votes is W[1]-hard and that parameterization by the target... Read more
Key finding: This study delineates the computational complexity of three judgment aggregation problems: winner determination, strategic manipulation, and agenda safety. It demonstrates that winner determination is polynomial-time solvable... Read more
Key finding: The authors develop practical algorithms for computing necessary and possible winners under incomplete voter preferences, including polynomial-time methods for scoring rules and NP-hard cases resolved via Integer Linear... Read more

3. How do multi-winner contest formats and decision-theoretic approaches influence winner determination and strategic behavior?

This area examines the extension of single-winner contest models to multi-winner scenarios, comparing simultaneous versus sequential winner selection, and the implications on effort and adaptation dynamics. It also includes examination of theoretical decision frameworks like Tournament Decision Theory, connecting winner determination with decision-dependence and pairwise competitions. Insights into voting paradoxes and committee selection paradoxes further motivate design considerations for multi-winner election procedures.

Key finding: This experimental study establishes strategic equivalence between two multi-winner winner selection mechanisms in Tullock contests: joint selection and survivor (sequential loser elimination) selection. Despite equivalence in... Read more
Key finding: The paper analyzes four multi-winner voting rules generalized from single-winner scoring rules with respect to Condorcet committee efficiency and occurrence of paradoxes when committee members leave. It provides probabilistic... Read more
Key finding: This theoretical work introduces Tournament Decision Theory which models decision-making as a round-robin style tournament among options, each competing pairwise. It addresses limitations of causal and evidential decision... Read more

All papers in Winner Determination

Electronic procurement is defined as the outsourcing of goods or services via internet. The decision processes surrounding are complicated by the uncertainty involved in the outsourcing process and by poor supplier management. A major... more
Developing intelligent and interactive systems with visual user interfaces is essential for any website and mobile device. In this study, we propose a new web-based shopping system to elicit buyer's requirements and preferences and to... more
In this research, we extend online auction theory by considering set theory in terms of a staged buying process. Success of online auction marketplaces depends on the efficacy of individual buyers searching for and finding desired items... more
Combinatorial auctions can be used to reach efficient resource and task allocations in multiagent systems where the items are complementary or substitutable. Determining the winners is N Pcomplete and inapproximable, but it was recently... more
Mobile ad hoc networks (MANETs) present similarities with Peer to Peer (P2P) systems in terms of decentralization, equality and autonomy. This results in the rise of new collaborative and spontaneous P2P applications over MANETs such as... more
We study a model of procurement auctions in which information policies can be used to treat two heterogeneous suppliers asymmetrically. The buyer is shown to be better off revealing information about her preferences to the weak supplier... more
Indonesian online sales have received remarkable growth with as high as 20% consistently every year. In 2016, there were estimated more than 180 million internet users and have reached 40% of 250 million total inhabitants. Based on the... more
We analyse the computational complexity of three problems in judgment aggregation: (1) computing a collective judgment from a profile of individual judgments (the winner determination problem); (2) deciding whether a given agent can... more
Solving winner determination problem in multiunit double auction has become an important E-business task. The main issue in double auction is to improve the reward in order to match the ideal prices and quantity and make the best profit... more
How useful are publicly available data, paired with machine-learning models, for assessing seller deception risk in online auctions? The authors use eBay transaction data (n = 1,600) from a quantitative, case-control research design to:... more
Online auctions are a popular and convenient way to engage in ecommerce. However, the amount of auction fraud has increased with the rapid surge of users participating in online auctions. Shill bidding is the most prominent type of... more
A user-centered approach in the development lifecycle of e-commerce websites is nowadays a crucial factor in the success of any on-line business. The purpose of this paper is twofold: a) to identify the factors that affect e-commerce... more
Outsourcing of services has been an industry trend for more than two decades. In particular, public software acquisitions have followed this trend. Governments are significant consumers of software and these processes may fail due to... more
Any automated decision support software must tailor its actions or recommendations to the preferences of different users. Thus it requires some representation of user preferences as well as a means of eliciting or otherwise learning the... more
In this paper, a combinatorial reverse auction mechanism is proposed to select suppliers for the required items of a company. As a contribution, it is assumed that the task of supplying each required item is indivisible to multiple... more
Note to users: The section "Articles in Press" contains peer reviewed accepted articles to be published in this journal. When the final article is assigned to an issue of the journal, the "Article in Press" version... more
Any automated decision support software must tailor its actions or recommendations to the preferences of different users. Thus it requires some representation of user preferences as well as a means of eliciting or otherwise learning the... more
The 31st International Conference on Industrial, Engineering and Other Applications of Applied Intelligent Systems (IEA/AIE-2018) was held at Concordia University in Montreal, Canada, June 25–28, 2018. This report summarizes the The 31st... more
The option of organizing E-auctions to purchase electricity required for anticipated peak load period is a new one for utility companies. To meet the extra demand load, we develop electricity combinatorial reverse auction (CRA) for the... more
Utility companies can organize e-auctions to procure electricity from other suppliers during peak load periods. For this purpose, we develop an efficient Combinatorial Reverse Auction (CRA) to purchase power from diverse sources,... more
— This study introduces a new type of Combinatorial Reverse Auction (CRA), products with multi-units, multi-attributes and multi-objectives, which are subject to buyer and seller constraints. In this advanced CRA, buyers may maximize some... more
Multi-Attribute Reverse Auctions (MARAs) are excellent protocols to automate negotiation among sellers. Eliciting the buyer s preferences and determining the winner are both challenging problems for MARAs.
Winner(s) determination in combinatorial reverse auctions is a very appealing application in e-commerce but very challenging especially when multiple attributes of multiple instances of items are considered. The difficulty here is to... more
Nowadays, winner determination problem is one of the main challenges in the domain of real-time applications such as combinatorial reverse auctions. To determine the winner(s) in combinatorial reverse auctions, in our previous work, we... more
Winner determination in combinatorial reverse auctions is very important in e-commerce especially when multiple instances of items are considered. However, this is a very challenging problem in terms of processing time and quality of the... more
Since commercially efficient, combinatorial auctions are getting more interest than traditional auctions. However, winner determination problem is still one of the main challenges of combinatorial auctions. In this paper, we propose a new... more
Winner determination is one of the main challenges in combinatorial auctions. However, not much work has been done to solve this problem in the case of reverse auctions using evolutionary techniques. This has motivated us to propose an... more
Multi-Attribute Reverse Auctions (MARAs) are excel-lent protocols to automate negotiation among sellers. Eliciting the buyer s preferences and determining the winner are both challenging problems for MARAs. To solve these problems, we... more
Auctioning multi-dimensional items is a key challenge, which requires rigorous tools. This study proposes a multi-round, first-score, semi-sealed multi-attribute reverse auction system. A fundamental concern in multi-attribute auctions is... more
Auctioning multi-dimensional items is a key challenge, which requires rigorous tools. This study proposes a multi-round, first-score, semi-sealed multi-attribute reverse auction system. A fundamental concern in multi-attribute auctions is... more
Nowadays, winner determination problem is one of the main challenges in the domain of real-time applications such as combinatorial reverse auctions. To determine the winner(s) in combinatorial reverse auctions, in our previous work, we... more
Designing interactive systems with graphic user interfaces is an important step in the development of online devices and websites. Online shopping systems and recommender applications have improved in the last decade and they are now... more
Winner determination in combinatorial reverse auctions is very important in e-commerce especially when multiple instances of items are considered. However, this is a very challenging problem in terms of processing time and quality of the... more
Winner determination is one of the main challenges in combinatorial auctions. However, not much work has been done to solve this problem in the case of reverse auctions using evolutionary techniques. This has motivated us to propose an... more
Winner(s) determination in online reverse auctions is a very appealing e-commerce application. This is a combinatorial optimization problem where the goal is to find an optimal solution meeting a set of requirements and minimizing a given... more
Winner(s) determination in combinatorial reverse auctions is a very appealing application in e-commerce but very challenging especially when multiple attributes of multiple instances of items are considered. The difficulty here is to... more
Winner determination in combinatorial reverse auctions is very important in e-commerce especially when multiple instances of items are considered. However, this is a very challenging problem in terms of processing time and quality of... more
Nowadays, winner determination problem is one of the main challenges in the domain of real-time applications such as combinatorial reverse auctions. To determine the winner(s) in combinatorial reverse auctions, in our previous work, we... more
The paper examines use of electronic auctions (e-auctions) as an allocation mechanism in public procurement in Slovak public sector. It is based on data from 32 procurement bodies and 725 procurements in the public sector in the period... more
Since commercially efficient, combinatorial auctions are getting more interest than traditional auctions. However, winner determination problem is still one of the main challenges of combinatorial auctions. In this paper, we propose a new... more
Nowadays, winner determination problem is one of the main challenges in the domain of real-time applications such as combinatorial reverse auctions. To determine the winner(s) in combinatorial reverse auctions, in our previous work, we... more
Winner determination is one of the main challenges in combinatorial auctions. However, not much work has been done to solve this problem in the case of reverse auctions using evolutionary techniques. This has motivated us to propose an... more
Winner determination is one of the main challenges in combinatorial auctions. However, not much work has been done to solve this problem in the case of reverse auctions using evolutionary techniques. This has motivated us to propose an... more
Abstract Two problems may arise when an intelligent (recommender) system elicits users' preferences. First, there may be a mismatch between the quantitative preference representations in most preference models and the users' mental... more
Abstract Any automated decision support software must tailor its actions or recommendations to the preferences of different users. Thus it requires some representation of user preferences as well as a means of eliciting or otherwise... more
Abstract In a service-oriented e-commerce environment, it is a crucial task to help consumers choose desired products efficiently from a huge amount of dynamically configured product candidates. Decision agents can be designed to provide... more
Multi-Attribute Reverse Auctions (MARAs) are excellent protocols to automate negotiation among sellers. Eliciting the buyer s preferences and determining the winner are both challenging problems for MARAs.
Any automated decision support software must tailor its actions or recommendations to the preferences of different users. Thus it requires some representation of user preferences as well as a means of eliciting or otherwise learning the... more
Download research papers for free!