Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Sacrifice (Philosophy)

description428 papers
group4,037 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
In philosophy, sacrifice refers to the act of giving up something valued for the sake of something considered to have a higher value or purpose. It often involves moral and ethical considerations regarding the implications of self-denial, altruism, and the nature of value in human decision-making.
lightbulbAbout this topic
In philosophy, sacrifice refers to the act of giving up something valued for the sake of something considered to have a higher value or purpose. It often involves moral and ethical considerations regarding the implications of self-denial, altruism, and the nature of value in human decision-making.

Key research themes

1. How has the concept of self-sacrifice evolved and persisted in secular modern societies?

This research theme explores the historical transformation of sacrifice from ritual immolation to self-sacrifice focused on individual relinquishment. It investigates how secularization processes have not eliminated sacrifice but rather redefined it as intentional self-gift for a greater good within modern social and cultural frameworks. The theme also examines contemporary embodiments of self-sacrifice among frontline heroes, analyzing how the sacredness of the person as a secular religiosity sustains sacrifice today.

Key finding: This paper elucidates the historical shift during the Axial Age from violent immolation rituals to self-sacrifice conceptualized as individual gift exchange and intentional embracing of sacrifice. It highlights the... Read more
Key finding: Analyzing data from religious adolescents across faiths, this study substantiates that sacrifice remains a vital religious expression despite cultural secularization. It finds that youth willingly accept sacrifices in... Read more
Key finding: Through empirical moral psychology experiments, the paper finds that people approve of self-sacrifice more than harming others to achieve the same good, revealing a unique moral valuation of self-sacrifice distinct from... Read more
Key finding: This phenomenological analysis articulates the indispensable role of sacrifice in underpinning morality, politics, and religion, highlighting the limits and social dimensions of sacrifice. It proposes that radical sacrifice... Read more

2. What roles and meanings do animal and human sacrifices hold in ancient and modern religious and social systems?

This theme focuses on the symbolic, ritualistic, and ethical dimensions of animal and human sacrifice across historical contexts from ancient Mediterranean civilizations to contemporary practices. It examines how sacrifices construct social hierarchies, mediate human-divine relationships, and reflect cultural attitudes toward life and suffering. It also addresses the evolving ontological and moral status of sacrificial victims, including debates over suffering and value, highlighting performative violence as a conduit for social cohesion and power negotiation.

Key finding: This study reveals that Roman animal sacrifice functioned as a performative enactment of social hierarchy, placing gods above humans and humans above animals, simultaneously reinforcing mortality acceptance and divine... Read more
Key finding: By applying reciprocity theory to Hebrew prophetic texts, this paper refutes the thesis that prophets like Amos and Jeremiah reject all sacrifices outright. Instead, it demonstrates these prophets critically addressed... Read more
Key finding: The paper historically traces the evolution of human attitudes toward animal sacrifice, demonstrating increased awareness of animal suffering across cultures and epochs despite ritualistic killing practices. It highlights how... Read more
Key finding: Through a longue durée archaeological and anthropological analysis, this research situates human sacrifice within dynamic socio-political and ritual contexts, emphasizing its dependence on social authority and sacred... Read more
Key finding: Using an interdisciplinary approach, this study illustrates that ancient Greek sacrificial rituals, particularly blood sacrifices, functioned as vital performative acts establishing and maintaining communion between mortals... Read more

3. How do philosophical and ethical perspectives conceptualize the limits, nature, and moral status of sacrifice and supererogation?

This theme interrogates the nexus between sacrifice, moral duty, and supererogation within philosophical and ethical discourse. It critically examines whether all supererogatory acts necessarily involve sacrifice, challenges assumptions about sacrifice as a cost to the agent, and explores alternative explanations for moral obligation boundaries. It also engages with the interplay between individual agency, voluntariness, and ethical justification, contributing to contemporary debates on moral theory and action evaluation.

Key finding: Although primarily a historical-literary investigation, this paper situates debates on sacrifice in premodern India within broader ethical considerations of sacrifice's role in religious reform and critique. It underscores... Read more
Key finding: This historical-theological work examines the semantic and ritual evolution of the concept of 'victim' and sacrifice in European religion, emphasizing the complex interplay between ritual sacrifice and metaphorical sacrifice... Read more

All papers in Sacrifice (Philosophy)

Wenn man von Martin Heideggers Wahrheitsbegriff spricht, kommt man nicht umhin, ein äußerst umfangreiches Problemfeld zu eröffnen, das immer noch für unterschiedliche Interpretationen offen ist. Die fast unermessliche kritische Produktion... more
Resumen: A la luz de la distinción elaborada por E. Tugendhat entre religión y mística, retomada a su modo por el teólogo J. Ratzinger, se examina la idea hegeliana según la cual la filosofía eleva la forma representativa propia de la... more
| The "sin offering" in Lev 4 has had a significant role in the development of a doctrine of the atonement. The article considers further what Leviticus means by sin or offense, sin offering or offense offering, mistake, guilt offering or... more
There is a story published by O. Henry (William Sydney Porter) in The New York Sunday World, December 10 1905. It was titled "Gifts of the Magi." In the story, Christmas is approaching and the young married couple does not have much money... more
This study explores the phenomenon of female child sacrifice as represented in mythology, ancient African and Arabian societies, and sacred texts. Anchored by the myth of Iphigeniaimmortalized in a mosaic unearthed in Perge, Antalya-the... more
This study explores the phenomenon of female child sacrifice as represented in mythology, ancient African and Arabian societies, and sacred texts. Anchored by the myth of Iphigeniaimmortalized in a mosaic unearthed in Perge, Antalya-the... more
M. Ertan Kardeş, "Benjamin ve Kafka: Paraboller, hasta gelenek ve unutma", Birikim , no. 435-436, Temmuz-Ağustos 2025, 46-56.
Belief in the Real Presence of Jesus substantially contained in the Eucharist is central to Catholicism (John 6:27-58; CCC, 1374-1375), but Catholics show declining Real Presence beliefs (Gray & Perl, 2008), possibly due to a decrease in... more
Abstract – The ADAM Model The ADAM Model presents a holistic view of the human being on eight levels. It is not bound to any ideology or religion but is developed from inner experience, structural clarity, and symbolic integration.... more
Durant l'accouchement, nous avons remarqué qu'il existe une grande disparité dans les gestes, d'une sage-femme à une autre. Parties de ce constat, nous nous sommes axées sur la seconde phase du travail, nous intéressant à la... more
Hesiod's Works and Days shows a number of peculiarities. Both the Winter segment and the Nautilia contain doublets; significant narrative details are omitted in both the myths; there are internal contradictions; the poem hints at material... more
This paper explores, in the context of incarceration and correctional chaplaincy, René Girard's hypothesis of mimetic desire (and its resulting violence) in conversation with Maximus the Confessor. It identifies Girard's mimetic... more
Le taux d’accouchements par césariennes en Turquie est le plus élevé des pays de l’OCDE : de 21 % en 2002, il est passé à 62,8 % en 2022 (MoH, 2024 : 89). Malgré les mesures de la « loi de la césarienne » de 2012, ce taux n’a pas fléchi.... more
This paper purposes to discuss about the memorial aspect of the Last Supper in view of eternal life promised by Christ. In other words, the aim of this paper is to answer the questions - how the event of the Last Supper transforms and... more
O presente artigo busca investigar a suposta ruptura que o próprio Foucault identifica no início de sua trajetória filosófica como um distanciamento em relação à filosofia institucional de sua época. Para tal fim, apresentamos uma... more
In this article, I offer a reading of the pirate in Carl Schmitt inspired by Reinhart Koselleck's study on asymmetric counterconcepts. I argue that the pirate in Schmitt marks a negative asymmetric counterconceptual position associated... more
Crvenog srca, crvene krvi, oživljavamo sećanje na nemilosrdno oduzete živote, istrajnim prisustvom kojem se neprestano pridružujemo i sa kojim bivamo, podsećajući da kolateralna šteta korupcije kao direktne posledice sakralizacije profita... more
The article “Beyond Unhappy Consciousness: Plotinus and Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit” by Sui Han begins by discussing the historical and conceptual links between Plotinus and Hegel. She references Jens Halfwassen's work, which provides... more
Las elecciones de 2024 en Alemania se llevaron a cabo en un escena rio de polarización social, cuya magnitud hubiese sido inimaginable a inicios del siglo XXI. La transformación acelerada de la sociedad —en parte, debido a la crisis de... more
How did the sense of smell play a role in childbirth in early modern France? Looking at the history of smell, I analyse medical reports of how bolth midwives and male practitioners believed 'good' and 'bad' smells could affect  childbirth.
Ist eine auf den Kopf gestellte Utopie! Darin wird die Idee "abstrakt" gesetzt, aus dem Hut gezaubert: ins Dasein "gesetzt": und Mensch und Welt müssen sich danach richten: wer nicht hört, muß fühlen: er kommt nach Auschwitz oder in den... more
This research proposal aims to investigate the phenomenon of Eucharistic miracles as reported across Christian history, particularly within the Roman Catholic tradition. It will explore the theological implications, historical accounts,... more
In our understanding of the Eucharist could we be suffering from a kind of 'chinese-wispers'? Have we lost the original reason why Jesus said 'Do This' and are we focusing only on the need to provide Communion? Are we then in danger of... more
O presente artigo tem em vista possíveis aproximações entre a figura do soberano, de Carl Schmitt a Giorgio Agamben, e o pai da horda primitiva, de Sigmund Freud. A partir de tais aproximações, pensarei a ascensão de um novo tipo de... more
This is the fifth edition of Palaver, a journal created in 2020 by Stevens students and Professor Benjamin Ogden to facilitate philosophical and intellectual discussion. The theme of this year’s issue is solitude. Solitude has widely... more
Mystagogical Study of the Eucharistic Fast explores the spiritual and theological dimensions of fasting in relation to the Eucharist. It follows the development of the Eucharistic fast starting with its scriptural roots and then following... more
importance of the spiritual provisions which Christians need in order to follow Christ such as prayer, reading Scripture, frequenting the sacrament of reconciliation and the Eucharist. In Chapter 4, Pope Benedict XVI's writings on... more
importance of the spiritual provisions which Christians need in order to follow Christ such as prayer, reading Scripture, frequenting the sacrament of reconciliation and the Eucharist. In Chapter 4, Pope Benedict XVI's writings on... more
This paper argues that Louis-Ferdinand Céline and Georges Bataille use voyeurism as a transgressive mechanism to confront death through the female body, a paradoxical site of life and decay. Though Céline's clinical, disenchanted gaze... more
In the film BLACK SWAN, the protagonist Nina undergoes a character metamorphosis as she struggles to act out the roles of both the White Swan and the Black Swan in the ballet Swan Lake. In the process, she undergoes several instances of... more
Much like the paradox of God's omnipresence in His absence, Halanaerobiales invert traditional life conditions, thriving at the edges of viability. This biological extremism mirrors Bataille’s fascination with limits, transgression, and... more
Сагничит Трисахасра Атиратра — сложнейший двенадцатидневный шраута-ритуал во время которого после четырех дней предварительных церемоний, в течение следующих дней из 3000 кирпичей сооружается Агни-алтарь в форме птицы на котором... more
El presente trabajo da cuenta de la actividad de extensión “Latín en latín: taller de latín oral y escrito”, que tuvo como objetivo fundamental que los participantes se iniciaran en la adquisición de la lengua latina mediante la... more
This paper seeks to explore an existential study of the crisis of the person which is a phenomenon of both personal and community decadence. It plunges us into the heart of faceless societies characterized by established disorder and the... more
Und was zur Hölle versteht man unter ‚Theologie der Digitalisierung'?
Kierkegaard was, at least during his early years, an avid reader of Hegel's philosophy. For example, his dissertation, The Concept of Irony, constitutes a careful study of, among other things, Hegel's account of Socrates in the Lectures... more
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or... more
The book “Philosophy of Religion: An Introduction” is written by William L. Rowe. It is the fourth edition published by Wadsworth Publishing Company, 2007. This book is about critical examination of the development of philosophy of... more
In the Statesman (287c3-5), Plato proposes that the philosophical divider should divide analogously to how the butcher divides a sacrificial animal. According to the common interpretation, the example of animal sacrifice illustrates that... more
Opfer, Schonung, Aufopferung – mit diesen "dreierlei Wahrheiten" des menschlichen Lebens fasst Kafka im Januar 1918 die Aporien einer zwischen "Drückebergerei und Kriegslust" schwankenden Essay-Figur Joseph Körners zusammen, die in... more
The present article takes up the issue of whether Hegel’s accounts of religion can be regarded as phenomenological analyses. This is a complex issue that concerns both the “Religion” chapter of the Phenomenology of Spirit and the Berlin... more
Download research papers for free!