Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Mental Competency

description4,419 papers
group8 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Mental competency refers to an individual's ability to understand and process information, make informed decisions, and comprehend the consequences of those decisions. It is a legal and psychological concept that assesses a person's cognitive capacity to engage in specific tasks, such as entering contracts or standing trial.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Mental competency refers to an individual's ability to understand and process information, make informed decisions, and comprehend the consequences of those decisions. It is a legal and psychological concept that assesses a person's cognitive capacity to engage in specific tasks, such as entering contracts or standing trial.

Key research themes

1. How do emotional intelligence and emotional competencies contribute to mental competency and job performance?

This theme investigates the role of emotional intelligence (EI) and emotional competencies in enhancing mental competency, individual effectiveness, and job performance across educational, organizational, and military contexts. Emotional intelligence is conceptualized both as a mental ability involving emotional problem-solving and as a trait encompassing personality-related emotional perceptions. Understanding the differential effects and measurement of ability EI and trait EI sheds light on predicting job success, managing behavior, and improving decision-making under stress, which are critical facets of mental competency.

Key finding: The paper refines the ability model of emotional intelligence by defining it as a system of mental abilities to perceive, use, understand, and manage emotions. It emphasizes that emotional intelligence should be measured as... Read more
Key finding: This study empirically demonstrates that while cognitive ability predicts individual task performance more strongly, emotional competence better predicts team performance and attitudes. Emotional competence also positively... Read more
by Marina Fiori and 
1 more
Key finding: Using teacher samples, the paper shows that intrapersonal emotional competencies, notably the identification and understanding of one's own emotions, significantly predict self-efficacy beliefs in behavior management, a core... Read more
Key finding: The study finds a positive impact of psychological capital components (hope, optimism, resilience, efficacy) and emotional intelligence on academic staff job performance in Sri Lanka, supporting the inclusion of emotional... Read more
Key finding: The study assesses the integration of psychological skills training, including mental competencies related to emotional regulation and decision-making, in elite military training for snipers. It finds that mental skill... Read more

2. What models and assessment approaches best capture mental capacity and decision-making competence in clinical and legal contexts?

This theme explores prevailing and alternative models of mental capacity, focusing on their theoretical foundations and practical application in health, legal, and ethical settings. The research discusses the Mental Capacity Act and its principles, functional versus status-based assessments of competence, the role of values and welfare in capacity determinations, and instruments for evaluating competence, providing a detailed overview on how mental competency is operationalized and assessed for clinical and forensic decision-making.

Key finding: The study reveals significant variation among health and social care practitioners in interpreting and applying mental capacity assessments under the Mental Capacity Act (MCA), especially when patient decisions conflict with... Read more
Key finding: This paper critically reviews existing models of mental capacity, distinguishing functional tests (based on understanding and decision-making abilities) from status tests (based on diagnostic or demographic proxies). It... Read more
Key finding: The paper challenges the dominant ethical principle that decision-making capacity assessments must focus exclusively on decision-making processes, arguing for a limited but necessary role of welfare impact considerations in... Read more
Key finding: The author proposes that the capacity to make medical decisions should be understood as the ability to track one’s own personal interests rather than solely based on cognitive abilities. This conceptual shift offers a... Read more
Key finding: This consensus practice resource updates forensic psychiatric evaluation protocols for competence to stand trial, integrating legal standards, clinical considerations including developmental issues, and the use of... Read more

3. How can shared mental models and competency frameworks improve group decision-making and competency assessment?

This research theme focuses on collaborative cognition through shared mental models (SMMs) and frameworks for competency assessment, particularly within healthcare and educational contexts. It examines how common understandings, team training, and structured competency dimensions facilitate more consistent and effective decision-making by teams and improved evaluation of individual competencies in complex settings.

Key finding: The study synthesizes literature on shared mental models (SMMs), demonstrating that SMMs improve team performance and decision consistency in clinical competency committees (CCCs) by establishing common understanding of... Read more
Key finding: Using data from 932 applicants, this work reveals that psychologists emphasize cognitive ability when assessing 'Thinking' competencies, personality and interview performance for 'Feeling' competencies, and mainly personality... Read more
Key finding: This paper details the design and validation of the KOPS scale, a vignette-based, knowledge test measuring therapeutic competencies in evidence-based problem-solving mental health interventions delivered by non-specialists.... Read more
Key finding: The chapter articulates an interactionist framework integrating individual traits (abilities, personality) and environmental experiences to explain the development of expertise. It distinguishes between typical behavior and... Read more

All papers in Mental Competency

Human adults attribute traits to faces readily and with high consensus. In two experiments investigating the development of face-trait inference, adults and children ages 3-12 attributed trustworthiness, dominance and competence to pairs... more
Human adults attribute character traits to faces readily and with high consensus. In two experiments investigating the development of face-to-trait inference, adults and children ages 3 through 10 attributed trustworthiness, dominance,... more
Enteral feeding (or ‘tube feeding’) is a very common inpatient intervention to maintain nutritional status where the oral route is inadequate, unsafe or inaccessible. A proportion of patients will need to continue tube feeding in the... more
Background-Surrogates frequently are unable to predict which treatment their charges would want and also can experience significant distress as a result of making treatment decisions. A new method, the patient preference predictor (PPP),... more
Surrogates frequently are unable to predict which treatment their charges would want and also can experience significant distress as a result of making treatment decisions. A new method, the patient preference predictor (PPP), has been... more
Driving simulation has become popular in the context of assessment of driving ability, as it provides a safe and economical method of assessing driving behaviors in comparable, controlled and repeatable driving conditions. The objective... more
Legal research in Sweden has traditionally focused on a systematization of the legal rules and their practical application, while the task of studying the effects of the application of the laws has been handed over to other branches of... more
In modern medicine professional relationship between the clinician and the patient is patient-centered. Patients become actively involved in the treatment decision making process and are encouraged to express their health-related... more
Objective: To investigate the understanding and expectations of defendants referred to Valkenberg Hospital for 30-day observation. Design: Defendants referred for 30 days of psychiatric assessment were surveyed by means of a... more
Aggressive challenging behaviour is frequently reported in adults with intellectual disability and it is often treated with antipsychotic drugs. However, no adequate evidence base for this practice exists. We compared flexible doses of... more
The aim of the study was to provide a standardization of self-reported competences and emotional/behavioural problems in Spanish adolescents, using the Achenbach's Youth Self-Report (YSR), and to compare our results to those from... more
Leaders of research infrastructures (RIs) in Europe who are scientists require competencies in management. RItrain has addressed this issue by identifying skills required, locating relevant courses and finding gaps, whilst establishing a... more
Prospective studies of intergenerational continuity in parenting quality remain scarce, with little attention given to the potential role of social competence as a mediator of continuity. This study examined social competence as a... more
In Canada, Review Boards are mandated to evaluate individuals found Not Criminally Responsible on Account of Mental Disorder (NCRMD) on an annual basis and render 1 of 3 dispositions: (a) custody, (b) conditional discharge, or (c)... more
In the Sydney 2000 Paralympic Games it was found that some people competing in the intellectual disabilities class in basketball did not have intellectual disabilities. This was a major, purposeful, transgression of the rules and as a... more
In 1984, Louisiana joined the trend towards legislative recognition of a right to refuse medical treatment.' The need for legislative action in this area is generally acknowledged: courts have frequently requested legislative guidance to... more
Background and Aims: Inflammatory bowel disease [IBD] is characterized by recurrent disease flares. The impact of psychosocial wellbeing on the occurrence of flares is unclear. In this prospective study, we aimed to evaluate the... more
Background The concept of autonomy in bioethics is subject to significant debate, with scholars describing it in contradictory terms-ranging from "fundamental" and "universal" to "blurry" and "flawed". Despite its central role in... more
Objectives:To evaluate the performance of a one-minute screening test measured against a validated 10-minute screening test for mild cognitive impairment (MCI) in detecting CI in patients aged ≥ 65 years with two or more vascular risk... more
Competent patients who refuse life saving medical treatment present a dilemma for healthcare professionals. On one hand, respect for autonomy and liberty demand that physicians respect a patient's decision to refuse treatment. However, it... more
pattern than controls. Whereas, in the link 1 the results obtained were similar to the showed by Hooker et al. (2000). The fact that the link 2 was preserved in schizophrenic suggests that could be efficacy the counterfactual therapy... more
Introduction: In today's world, having principle and targeted management is one of the progress and development factors of any organization. Effective use of time for each manager is the most important base for managing current affairs... more
The paper discusses the impact which recent advances in gene technology may have for people with intellectual disabilities. It highlights a conflict between the apparent benefits of advances in genetics for the population in general and... more
This article reports on a survey of forensic psychiatrists and psychologists who read two case study vignettes and assessed whether each criminal defendant was competent to stand trial, using three differently worded standards of... more
This paper presents an analysis of the applicability of a principalist approach for a global, or cross-cultural, bioethics. We focus especially on the principle of individual autonomy, a core value in ethical discourse. We echo some... more
Psychiatrists in the UK have recently lamented the need for a code of ethics for psychiatry. There is a clear difference between a code of ethics and a code of practice (such as the non-statutory one of the UK Mental Health Act of 1983)... more
In this article, we examine one of the most contentious and divisive issues in mental health law: the right of the involuntary patient to refuse treatment. The recognition of this right can be traced to American case law starting in... more
Dr. Gill's rehab inpatient, Joel, is a decorated former Navy Seal. By age 35, he had served around the globe for a decade. His military career ended two years later, when he suffered a spinal cord injury from two gunshot wounds to his... more
Thirty five states, as of August 1997, had laws outlawing physician-assisted suicide and no state had passed a law similar to the Oregon statute.
After adjudication by the courts that an individual is not criminally responsible for the offense committed, forensic psychiatrists/psychologists are tasked with evaluating an acquittees' ongoing risk of violence. These findings... more
After adjudication by the courts that an individual is not criminally responsible for the offense committed, forensic psychiatrists/psychologists are tasked with evaluating an acquittees' ongoing risk of violence. These findings determine... more
This longitudinal study examined internalizing behavior problems (anxiety/depression) in early adolescence in relation to adversity in early childhood and child verbal competence. We hypothesized that verbal competence would act as a... more
This study looks at the vocabulary used in Pakistani English fiction that has been Urduized. This study, which uses data from the one million-word Pakistani English Fiction corpus (PEF), examines the impact that the Urduized words used in... more
Background Consent to treatment is a cornerstone of medical ethics and law. Nevertheless, very little empirical evidence is available to inform clinicians and policymakers regarding the capacities of forensic patients with schizophrenia... more
The aim of the research was to determine the quantitative structure of winning systems of the world's leading women players in table tennis in the years 1970-2021. The study used the Wu Huanqin game analysis method. It consists of... more
Nearly all general practitioners meet representatives of drug companies.' The drug industry spent an estimated £5000 per general practitioner promoting its products in the United Kingdom in 1985.2 Drug representatives are a crucial... more
Background: This study was designed to explore the neuropsychological basis of competence to consent to treatment in first-episode schizophrenia by evaluating its differential and joint links with cognitive versus metacognitive... more
To explore the doctrine of informed consent and the development of capacity in adolescents with psychiatric problems to help clinicians better reflect on the relevant ethical issues. We discuss the relevant literature and explore the role... more
This article examines the legal implications linked to recent scientific research on human consciousness. The article contends that groundbreaking revelations about consciousness expose the frailties of the criminal law's traditional dual... more
Background and Purpose—Little is known about informed consent for tissue plasminogen activator (tPA). Our objectives were to determine how frequently informed consent is obtained when tPA is given to stroke patients in clinical practice... more
It's about the legal provisions, judicial practices, history and challenging ensuring fair justice.
claims that the argument from marginal cases is 'the central argument' behind the claim that nonhuman animals have rights. But she thinks, along with Cora Diamond, that the argument is 'obtuse'. Two different meanings could be intended... more
In this paper we develop a hermeneutic approach to the concept of competence. Patient competence, according to a hermeneutic approach, is not primarily a matter of being able to reason, but of being able to interpret the world and respond... more
The notion that physicians can simply "lock people up" has contributed to much of the stigma associated with psychiatry, and this is not mitigated by pointing out-as the authors do-that physicians are acting as extensions of the state. As... more
The notion that physicians can simply "lock people up" has contributed to much of the stigma associated with psychiatry, and this is not mitigated by pointing out-as the authors do-that physicians are acting as extensions of the state. As... more
The British Parliament stated that health services would be covered by the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 (the act). However, when people with disabilities are at their most vulnerable, for example when in hospital or subject to... more
Download research papers for free!