When I saw that Martin Redish 2 and Burt Neuborne 3 had written reviews of my book, Brandishing the First Amendment, 4 for the Texas Law Review I was both pleased and apprehensive. The apprehension is easy to understand. As Professor...
moreWhen I saw that Martin Redish 2 and Burt Neuborne 3 had written reviews of my book, Brandishing the First Amendment, 4 for the Texas Law Review I was both pleased and apprehensive. The apprehension is easy to understand. As Professor Larry Kramer has observed, "Having one's work closely criticized is never pleasant: hugely complimentary, and oh-so-much better than having it ignored, but still difficult and painful." 5 Thus, I approached both reviews with some trepidation. On the one hand, it was a compliment to be reviewed in such a prominent journal. On the other, I had little reason to