Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Contested Pasts

description10 papers
group0 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Contested Pasts refers to the scholarly examination of historical narratives that are disputed or debated within societies. This field explores how differing interpretations of history influence collective memory, identity, and politics, often highlighting the power dynamics involved in the construction and representation of historical events.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Contested Pasts refers to the scholarly examination of historical narratives that are disputed or debated within societies. This field explores how differing interpretations of history influence collective memory, identity, and politics, often highlighting the power dynamics involved in the construction and representation of historical events.

Key research themes

1. How can conceptions of heritage accommodate historical injustices in contested pasts?

This theme investigates philosophical and moral frameworks addressing heritage's role in recognizing and responding to historical injustices. It critiques the prevalent 'Positive View' of heritage as exclusively positive and explores alternative conceptions framing heritage as encompassing both beneficial and harmful inheritances. Highlighting the normative implications for political reconciliation and community identity, this area is crucial for advancing inclusive, ethically responsible heritage practices and debates on ownership of contested pasts.

Key finding: Empirical research reveals that heritage interpretation in Colombo currently prioritizes market values of select colonial-era buildings while excluding broader social groups, leading to fragmentation and disconnection in... Read more
Key finding: This work complements prior findings by emphasizing the unsustainability of current heritage approaches in Colombo focused on monumental colonial buildings while neglecting intangible cultural values and minority narratives.... Read more

2. What role do memory, narrative, and historiographical approaches play in interpreting contested and traumatic pasts?

This theme explores methodological and philosophical challenges historiographers face when writing about contentious or traumatic histories. It foregrounds the entanglement of past and present, the ethical dilemmas of historians as secondary witnesses, narrative plurality, and memory's interplay with history. This line of inquiry elucidates how historical narratives are constructed, contested, and politically charged, shedding light on the complexity of producing and utilizing historical knowledge amid conflict, collective memory, and social transformation.

Key finding: Drawing on Walter Benjamin, Enzo Traverso, and Dominick LaCapra, the paper argues that twentieth-century historiography cannot disentangle itself from the political and ethical contingencies of its present context. It... Read more
Key finding: This article advocates embracing the inherent incompleteness, interpretive failures, and ethical openness of historical representations. Drawing on Derrida’s concept of aporia, it argues against authoritative or... Read more
Key finding: The study challenges the traditional event-centric view of historiography by elucidating the multiplicity and heterogeneity of pasts encountered in contemporary historical research. It affirms the significance of... Read more

3. How do emotions and blame shape responses to historical wrongs and accountability over time?

This theme investigates the multifaceted nature of emotional responses to historical injustices, advancing philosophical accounts of blameworthiness, resentment, and guilt. It stresses the dynamic interplay of these emotions in assessing moral responsibility across time, including the impact of remorse, repudiation, and psychological continuity. Scholars in this area contribute nuanced frameworks for understanding how communities and individuals relate to past wrongs ethically and politically, informing debates on reconciliation, justice, and historical accountability.

Key finding: The paper presents a detailed account of blameworthiness for past actions as emotion-driven and multifaceted, involving not merely resentment but also guilt and indignation, each with independent fittingness conditions. It... Read more
Key finding: This article critiques prevailing approaches to the politics of regret—wherein public discourses dominated by apologetic voices simplify historical events to enable collective guilt narratives. It conceptualizes political... Read more
Key finding: The paper analyzes the doctrine of precedent as a moral practice grounded not only in judicial decision-making but also in communal faithfulness to the past. It critiques existing justificatory theories and advances a view... Read more

All papers in Contested Pasts

oreen Massey’s essay “Places and their pasts” published 1995 highly influenced geographic thought on places by foregrounding the co-production of local histories and global processes, establishing a foundational framework for... more
The rising global importance of social networking sites (SNS) transforms them into a relevant new theatre for negotiating and constructing perceptions of reality. Aiming to bridge the material-semiotic divide, this study harkens back to... more
The article proposes some methodological reflections on doing oral history in borderland areas, starting from the case study of the Slovene-Italian borderland. It elaborates on some mistakes and difficulties the author has faced when... more
In contemporary architectural Design, we speak of a parametric structural design. A design that integrates new functionalities crossed with the spatial geometry of objects. It has been considered structured because it optimizes... more
Colombo, Sri Lanka’s commercial capital is a forceful creation of European colonialists who occupied the island for over four centuries. Its urban structure displays the social fragmentation sought by the rulers. Colombo elaborates an... more
Urban space, which is shaped by the dwelling patterns of a culture, records the evolution of its identity, and as such acquires a heritage value. This unique way of becoming a heritage emphasises that it is not the walls nor the floor nor... more
Sustainability has been a pressing, complex, and ch allenging agenda for urbanists. Its focus turns on wider issues of environment and societies thus broadening the concept d efine in the Brundtland report. Eco-city, ecologica l... more
Colombo, Sri Lanka’s commercial capital is a forceful creation of European colonialists who occupied the island for over four centuries. Its urban structure displays the social fragmentation sought by the rulers. Colombo elaborates an... more
Sustainability has been a pressing, complex, and challenging agenda for urbanists. Its focus turns on wider issues of environment and societies thus broadening the concept defined in the Brundtland report. Eco-city, ecological footprint,... more
Sustainability has been a pressing, complex, and challenging agenda for urbanists. Its focus turns on wider issues of environment and societies thus broadening the concept defined in the Brundtland report. Eco-city, ecological footprint,... more
Colombo, Sri Lanka’s commercial capital is a forceful creation of European colonialists who occupied the island for over four centuries. Its urban structure displays the social fragmentation sought by the rulers. Colombo elaborates an... more
Download research papers for free!