Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Constructive Technology Assessment

description39 papers
group14 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Constructive Technology Assessment (CTA) is an approach that integrates social and ethical considerations into the development and implementation of new technologies. It aims to anticipate and shape the societal impacts of technology by involving stakeholders in the assessment process, thereby fostering responsible innovation and informed decision-making.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Constructive Technology Assessment (CTA) is an approach that integrates social and ethical considerations into the development and implementation of new technologies. It aims to anticipate and shape the societal impacts of technology by involving stakeholders in the assessment process, thereby fostering responsible innovation and informed decision-making.

Key research themes

1. How can Constructive Technology Assessment (CTA) be conceptualized to enhance democratic participation, reflexivity, and alignment in technology governance?

This theme addresses the evolving conceptualization of Constructive Technology Assessment as a socio-technical and discursive approach that seeks to integrate diverse actors early in the technology development process. The focus is on enhancing democratic participation, reflexivity among stakeholders, and alignment of interests to facilitate socially robust and ethically responsive technological innovation.

Key finding: This paper reconceptualizes CTA as a democratic, reflective, and discursive process emphasizing early and broad stakeholder involvement to foster social learning about technology impacts. It highlights the importance of... Read more
Key finding: This study critically examines limitations in broadening public participation within CTA, identifying structural factors like governance power imbalances, 'rules of access', and rhetorical skill disparities that constrain... Read more
Key finding: This paper explores how the technological mediation approach, grounded in postphenomenology, challenges traditional 'external' TA by highlighting the co-constitution of humans and technology and the morality arising 'from... Read more

2. What normative frameworks and ethical methodologies can advance the integration of values, ethics, and reflexivity into Constructive Technology Assessment?

Focusing on the ethical dimension within CTA, this theme investigates how normative theories, ethical methodologies, and value-sensitive approaches can be incorporated into the assessment process. It highlights critiques of checklist ethics, advocates for ethics embedded 'from within' technological development, and explores normative frameworks like the Capability Approach and discourse ethics to manage pluralism, uncertainty, and emergent moral dynamics in technology governance.

Key finding: This paper critiques prevalent checklist-based ethical technology assessments that narrowly predefine ethical issues and remain external to technology development. It proposes an ethical-constructive technology assessment... Read more
Key finding: The study develops the Capability Approach (CA), particularly Nussbaum's version, as a normative orientation for technology assessment, addressing challenges posed by conflicts between aggregated sustainability goals and... Read more
Key finding: This paper introduces the 'VALIDATE' approach integrating empirical analysis and normative inquiry through reconstructing stakeholders' interpretive frames—combining problem definitions, judgments, background theories, and... Read more
Key finding: The paper argues for shifting ethical evaluation in technology assessment from a focus on justification to discovery, emphasizing the role of imagination and metaphor in moral reasoning. It critiques classical and... Read more

3. How can future-oriented, participatory, and integrated frameworks improve the anticipation and governance of emerging and converging technologies in Constructive Technology Assessment?

This theme focuses on methodologies for future-oriented assessment within CTA that incorporate scenario-building, technology foresight, systemic approaches, and participatory engagement to address uncertainties in emerging and converging technologies. It highlights frameworks that combine societal functions, stakeholder interaction, and multi-criteria considerations for anticipating cross-sectoral impacts and integrating sustainability and real-world experimentation to achieve more reflexive and transformative governance.

Key finding: This study proposes a national-level, future-oriented framework for assessing converging NBIC technologies by synthesizing prior technology assessment models and emphasizing the analysis of Converging Technologies Development... Read more
Key finding: The paper conceptualizes Reflexive Sustainable Technology Labs that integrate Real-World Labs (RwLs), Technology Assessment (TA), and Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) to foster transdisciplinary, participatory, and... Read more
Key finding: Applying Constructive Technology Assessment, this study develops a typology of climate services that elucidates different types of service offerings (Maps & Apps, Expert Analysis, Climate-inclusive Consulting, Sharing... Read more

All papers in Constructive Technology Assessment

De wereld van de gemeentelijke uitvoeringsdiensten van werk en inkomen is de laatste jaren aan vele veranderingen onderhevig. Verantwoordelijkheden van de centrale overheden zijn decentraal neergelegd en de budgetten staan onder druk.... more
Within the FP6 project, ORGANIC REVISION a public web-based database was implemented to support the revision of the EU Regulation on organic agriculture. The database describes differences between the major European organic production... more
Over dienstbaarheid 10 uitdagingen voor een klantgericht lokaal bestuur Tom Vandooren met medewerking van Mathias Van Compernolle Eerste editie, januari 2021 218 p. ISBN 978 90 4961 864 3 D/2020/0783/044 Art. nr. 06LM004916 NUR 820 © 2021... more
In close relationships, snooping on device is commonly regarded as an invasion of privacy. The prevalence of such behavior is, however, difficult to assess. We compared two in-person survey techniques, one in which the question about... more
Center for Stabilization and Reconstruction Studies Workshop
In an effort in bringing together stakeholders of the organic farming and general agricultural policy sector within the EU in April May 2004 a group of stakeholders met for a one day- workshop in 11 European countries (AT, GB, DE, DK, IT,... more
Cost-effective restoration measures that promote wider ecosystem and societal benefits. (Deliverable; No. D5.2). EU FP7 REFORM project.... more
The railway industry is pushing for market uptake of research for better and competitive products and services as resulted from the workshop of the European Railway Advisory Council held this year 2010 . What seems less considered by the... more
Future Oriented Technology Analysis (FTA) has been visible in railway planning since 2001. Over a dozen reports have been produced in the past thirteen years, the majority being descriptive endogenous technocentric visions. They have... more
support. Also, Jens Schippl, a researcher on Transport Scenarios at ITAS-KIT, became influential in my work and co-author. Both Douglas and Jens directed me to the relevant theoretical references and methods in TA. My PhD was not only a... more
Future Oriented Technology Analysis (FTA) has been visible in railway planning since 2001. Over a dozen reports have been produced in the past thirteen years, the majority being descriptive endogenous technocentric visions. They have... more
The present article posits constructive technology assessment as the dominant perspective of societal embedding practices in the technical development process by the high-speed train manufacturing industry, resulting from a research study... more
In this article the authors explore the application of artificial intelligence (AI) in the public safety domain at the example of the Living Lab Scheveningen (LLS). The boulevard of Scheveningen serves as a testing ground for... more
Content  Abstracts must focus on scientific results or their application. The Program Committee may decline to consider abstracts with other focus. Note: abstracts cannot be accepted for review after 5 August.  Following the abstract... more
In Europe, the technology development of high-speed trains is increasingly exposed to societal needs, driven by ICT advancements, external to traditional design. Together with the liberalisation of the rail markets and increase pressures... more
A comprehensive typology or characterization of the various types of climate services is needed to give an overview that makes (potential) users aware of which climate services are available and where to look for them. It helps identify... more
Marine stewardship and complexity-How to enhance a better process of risk governance in the Norwegian area of the Arctic Ocean? In 2006, the Norwegian government published a white paper that presented an integrated oceans management plan... more
The use of permit trading for the abatement of atmospheric emissions of various substances has received much attention, and is a favored option due to its ability to induce efficient reduction of emissions. In a permit-based system, the... more
A report based on an interactive, anticipatory assessment of the dynamics of governance instruments, 26 April 2013
Researcher studies the development of race attitudes in children Study shows that discriminatory practices are internalized in young children Author: Amanda Hamermüller Maybe you've never noticed, but fictional characters in children's... more
The Welikeia project and the corresponding free online tool Visionmaker.NYC focus on the historical landscape ecologies of New York City. This article provides a brief introduction to online participatory tools, describes the Visionmaker... more
This paper aims at contributing to theoretical aspects of Foresight from the perspective of the interdisciplinary body of knowledge that has become known as STS- Science and Technology Studies (c.f. Jasanoff 1994). Drawing in particular... more
Part of the Law Commons This Editorial is brought to you for free and open access by the Faculty Scholarship at Osgoode Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in News, Editorials, and Commentaries by an authorized... more
The purpose of this paper is to explore the area of complexity and its link to systems thinking, with a view to defining the methodological requirements for extension services targeting complex problem situations. Agriculture in Australia... more
The purpose of this paper is to explore the area of complexity and its link to systems thinking, with a view to defining the methodological requirements for extension services targeting complex problem situations. Agriculture in Australia... more
A networked collection, also called a virtual collection, is located at more than one geographical/institutional site, spans the genetic diversity of a given species (genepool) and gathers stakeholders having a mutual interest in... more
The Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) is the cornerstone of the land consolidation (LC) project process. In the Walloon context, SEA h as to be renewed for technical and legal reasons. The concept of ecosystem services (ES) off ers... more
This work identifies and describes residue treatment technologies for the tannery industry. The objective was considering each technology face to its potential to fulfill the requirements of a clean development mechanism (CDM) project.... more
Maglev technologies are at an historical turn, with the first commercial implementation of the Transrapid in China. This article examines what are the causes of market barriers encountered by such disruptive technologies and what are the... more
The recently finished EU funded project MACIS reviewed observed and projected climate change impacts on biodiversity. It assessed mitigation and adaptation options. It also reviewed and developed methods to assess future impacts of... more
ETHNA System Project – Deliverable 2.3: Review article. This article provides a review of responsible research and innovation (RRI) literature, with a particular focus on how to provide open and inclusive ethical governance of research... more
Із збільшенням швидкостей руху поїздів TGV, виникає багато проблем, пов'язаних з дизайном використовуваними матеріалами та безпекою. Вирішення цих проблем потребує великих інвестицій від залізниць Франції в науково-дослідні проекти.... more
Introduction 9 1 Introduction 21 Part 2  Approaching RRI Governance 23 2 RRI as a governance paradigm: What is new? 31 3 Framings and frameworks: six grand narratives of de facto rri 39 4 Evolution of a concept: a scientometric analysis... more
Introduction 9 1 Introduction 21 Part 2  Approaching RRI Governance 23 2 RRI as a governance paradigm: What is new? 31 3 Framings and frameworks: six grand narratives of de facto rri 39 4 Evolution of a concept: a scientometric analysis... more
2.1.1 Introduction This section provides theory on innovation processes and innovation methods for industrial design engineering. The theory will be illustrated by results of design cases with sustainable energy technologies that have... more
Increasing public investments in distributed platform infrastructures have created new opportunities for economic growth and social welfare but at the same time have been associated with growing societal distrust in the power of science... more
Orde van de Dag is een uitgave van Wolters Kluwer, Motstraat 30, 2800 Mechelen, in samenwerking met de projectgroep «Criminaliteit & Samenleving». Redactieadres Orde van de Dag Wolters Kluwer Motstraat 30 2800 Mechelen Alle... more
In the first phase of the research project Nanotechnologies for tomorrow’s society (www.nanosoc.be), the research consortium explored a variety of futuristic visions or techno-scientific imaginaries. This exploration took the form a... more
Download research papers for free!