Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Civil Discourse

description254 papers
group15 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Civil discourse refers to the engagement in conversation or debate that is respectful, constructive, and aimed at understanding differing viewpoints. It emphasizes the importance of listening, reasoning, and communicating in a manner that fosters mutual respect and promotes democratic dialogue, particularly in contexts of disagreement or conflict.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Civil discourse refers to the engagement in conversation or debate that is respectful, constructive, and aimed at understanding differing viewpoints. It emphasizes the importance of listening, reasoning, and communicating in a manner that fosters mutual respect and promotes democratic dialogue, particularly in contexts of disagreement or conflict.

Key research themes

1. How does civility shape the quality and outcomes of political discourse in democratic societies?

This theme investigates the role of civility—understood both as politeness and as public-mindedness—in facilitating or hindering effective political discourse. It examines how civil and uncivil disagreement affect emotions, participation, and democratic deliberation, alongside the normative expectations and tensions around civility in political contexts, including power dynamics and inclusion.

Key finding: This experimental study (N=272) found that both civil and uncivil disagreement in online news comments induce negative emotions and aggressive intentions, but only uncivil disagreement leads to uncivil retaliatory responses... Read more
Key finding: This paper disaggregates the concept of civility into politeness and public-mindedness, with further dimensions differentiating moral and justificatory civility, clarifying normative claims about civility's roles. It argues... Read more
Key finding: Highlighting civility as a civic virtue with moral and political tension, this work reveals that promoting civility can have asymmetrical effects—benefiting some groups more than others and potentially suppressing... Read more
Key finding: This multidisciplinary volume reviews the decline of political civility in U.S. public life, highlighting causes such as technological change, growing polarization, and increasing incivility in both elite and citizen... Read more
Key finding: This article critically examines the expectation of civility in academic discourse, revealing how calls for 'civil' behavior often function as racialized strategies that protect whiteness and silence marginalized voices,... Read more

2. How do communicative practices and discourse structures facilitate or hinder political dialogue and deliberation in contexts of polarization?

This theme focuses on the dynamics of political dialogue and deliberation amid polarization, including how discursive strategies, dialogic ethics, and norms influence openness or closure in political exchanges. It explores the conditions allowing sustained dialogue, challenges posed by social fragmentation, and how discourse analyses illuminate the coherence and dysfunctionality of political interactions.

Key finding: Through Action Implicative Discourse Analysis of public dialogue sessions, this study identified discursive strategies—such as questioning, rearticulating claims, reframing, and controlled silence—that participants use to... Read more
Key finding: Analyzing a campus public dialogue, the study identified three interaction patterns—conceptual expansion, deliberation of meaning, and dialogic moments—and two communicative practices—discursive vulnerability and critical... Read more
Key finding: This work problematizes when discourse qualifies as coherent interactive communication versus disjointed utterances. Using examples from political discourse, the author reveals frequent deficiencies in interactivity and... Read more
Key finding: Applying critical discourse analysis to the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) 2013 election manifesto, this study reveals linguistic strategies used to influence public opinion and exercise socio-political dominance. It uncovers... Read more
Key finding: This paper argues much political 'disagreement' is illusory, often reflecting expressive responding or partisan hostility rather than genuine divergent policy beliefs. It shows that partisan antipathy can exist independently... Read more

3. What are the theoretical and methodological frameworks to analyze political and public discourse, including argumentation and the role of speech acts?

This theme centers on the conceptual and analytical tools for studying political and public discourse, focusing on argumentation theory, speech act theory, and discourse analysis methodologies. It covers the normative ideals of public argumentation, the structure and interactional nature of arguing as a speech act, and reflexive critiques on discourse analysis methods applied to education, politics, and social power relations.

Key finding: This paper surveys normative ideals governing public argumentation, namely correctness (truth, validity, moral optimality) and participation (inclusion, diversity, equality), highlighting their general coherence and potential... Read more
Key finding: Extending Searle's speech act theory, this article proposes a two-level analysis of arguing: first, the illocutionary act by the speaker securing uptake (making the argument graspable), and second, an interactive level where... Read more
Key finding: Through auto-analytical reflection on research projects, this paper critiques the assumption of discourse analysis as a methodological monolith, emphasizing its diverse ontological and epistemological foundations. It... Read more
Key finding: This paper traces the intertwined nature of language and politics, reviewing historical and contemporary perspectives including rhetorical traditions and post-structuralist critiques. It highlights the linguistic turn in... Read more
Key finding: The article critically reassesses Habermas’ practical discourse theory to explore extending its framework to justify animal rights. It revises the principle of universalization to include animal interests mediated by human... Read more

All papers in Civil Discourse

Monologic follow-ups in political legitimization discourse: The case of the Iraq war Framing as a continual and repetitive process in political communication Quotations in monologic and dialogic political discourse Establishing... more
Increased polarization and divisive political speech threaten meaningful civic discussion. This study examines a campus public dialogue to understand how dialogic commitments sustained discursive openings for talking across polarizing... more
As the number of freelance journalists increases, the changing nature of work in journalism has effects and possible implications for the kinds of news discourses that are circulated. This paper explores the experiences of freelance... more
by Alexis Thouki and 
1 more
Employing a realist ontology of discourse, this theoretical paper aims to clarify some assumptions that form the theoretical backdrop of the authorised heritage discourse (AHD) that remain under-theorised, parti cularly its... more
Language is the basic feature of any society which reflects its social norms and culture. The language patterns vary from culture to
People, as members of a society and members of the intelligentsia, are, inevitably, involved in discourse and conversational systems which define their diverse positions of power in the discourse. The term "discourse" is used mostly to... more
هدفت الدراسة إلى تحليل ركائز تركيبة الامتحانات الرسمية لمادة اللغة العربية وأهدافها في نماذج امتحانات البكالوريا الجديدة في الجزائر، واعتمدت الدراسة منهجية تحليل المحتوى للأسئلة المقررة في الامتحانات الرسمية، مستخدمةً أداة تحليل نصوص... more
Journalistic discourse is a fertile through which most of the segments of the society interact in all their platforms: intellectual, cultural, social, and various settings between the vital structures of the state; which makes it the link... more
Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) is an interdisciplinary theoretical and methodological approach with a range of conceptual and methodological perspectives on discourse and global journalism. Thus, concept definitions, data selection and... more
This article focuses on the English-language migration discourse and aims to develop its methodology through the lens of cognitive pragmatics and cognitively oriented critical discourse analysis. The analysis is underpinned by... more
The article considers some peculiarities of manipulation and pragmalinguistic aspects of political discourse. The purpose of the article is to study and make clear the role of use of manipulative and pragmalinguistic elements in political... more
Although both are fundamental terms in the humanities and social sciences, discourse and knowledge have seldom been explicitly related, and even less so in critical discourse studies. After a brief summary of what we know about these... more
This paper explores a new approach to researching leadership in organizations by drawing on cognitive maps of individuals within two school settings who articulate what ‘leadership’ means for them. This study through a critical discourse... more
ЗАСТОСУВАННЯ ДИСКУРС-АНАЛІЗУ В СУЧАСНИХ СОЦІАЛЬНИХ ДОСЛІДЖЕННЯХ У статті розглянуто основні теорії дискурсу (підходи Фуко, Лакло і Муфф та критичний дискурс-аналіз) і застосування запропонованих цими теоріями підходів до дискурс-аналізу в... more
It is an accepted truth that Discourse Analysis is the analysis of language in use. The results of the study showed how discourse analysis can be used in decoding facts and fore-grounded information in Imam Khomeini's will. The discourse... more
This article aims to clarify the meaning of “renovation of religious discourse”, specifically by defining the disciplines of this renovation and their importance in determining its meaning. The disciplines play a pivotal role in... more
Discourse Analysis as Theory and Method is a systematic introduction to discourse analysis as a body of theories and methods for social research. It brings together three central approaches, Laclau and Mouffe's discourse theory, critical... more
GAGIK TUMANYAN-Modern Conceptions of Civil Society in the Context of Democratisation Discourse.-As we know nowadays in many publications of social sciences, as well as in mass media and public discourse, the idea of civil society often... more
Symposium: Religious Liberty at the Dawn of a New Millennium held at Indiana University School of Law-Bloomington on April 9, 1999.
Discourse Analysis as Theory and Method is a systematic introduction to discourse analysis as a body of theories and methods for social research. It brings together three central approaches, Laclau and Mouffe's discourse theory, critical... more
We propose a unified model of syntax and discourse in which text structure is viewed as a tree structure augmented with anaphoric relations and other secondary relations. We describe how the model accounts for discourse connectives and... more
Дискурс-аналіз як метод дослідження прихованих семіотичних аспектів текстів ЗМІ останнім часом поширюється в українській соціологічній науці. Це позначається на актуалізації специфічних проблем його використання. У статті запропоновано... more
Сборник по результатам LV заочной научной конференции International Research Journal. За достоверность сведений, изложенных в статьях, ответственность несут авторы. Журнал имеет свободный доступ, это означает, что статьи можно читать,... more
The article outlines the field of FOUCAULTian discourse analysis. The FOUCAULTian concept of discourse is introduced, and methodological positions and methodological developments are sketched. Compared to other qualitative social research... more
Discourse analysis can reveal what texts leave out, and how texts transform and evaluate the social realities they represent but critical discourse analysis must also evaluate the findings of discourse analysis, and, this paper argues,... more
The Handbook is divided into four sections. Part I, Domains of Discourse, focuses on specific discursive domains or 'forms' of organizational discourse. Part II, Methods and Perspectives, plots the contrasting methodological approaches... more
Currently, he works on far-right activism, environmental communication and in the field of critical discourse studies. His recent publications include the edited volume The Far Right and the Environment (Routledge, 2019), 'Towards a... more
In this paper, I revisit and reflect on my own and my research partners' attempts at investigating the relationship between education and politics through the lens of discourse theory and discourse analysis methodology. This... more
Strategy has become ubiquitous in contemporary societies. Accordingly, the expansion of strategy discourse beyond corporate management and its colonization of various aspects of economic and organizational life are important phenomena for... more
This paper is aimed at analysing the use of redundancy in Oral Questions in the Andalusian Parliament. The corpus is made up of 12 oral questions raised by the two main political parties at the Committee for Equality and Social Welfare.... more
Discourse Analysis as Theory and Method is a systematic introduction to discourse analysis as a body of theories and methods for social research. It brings together three central approaches, Laclau and Mouffe's discourse theory, critical... more
This study aims at emphasizing the institutional transformations that occurred in the public environment following the events in December 1989 in Romania, focusing on the dismantling of mechanisms that marked the transition from the... more
OR CENTURIES, issues of civil discourse only arose concerning written and oral communication. but now, new technologies for communication and social interaction, particularly social media, have dramatically expanded the potential for... more
The article outlines the field of FOUCAULTian discourse analysis. The FOUCAULTian concept of discourse is introduced, and methodological positions and methodological developments are sketched. Compared to other qualitative social research... more
The article discusses linguistic approaches to power and deals with question-answer types of interaction in institutional discourse. The main focus is on discursive tools available to participants with an institutional status and the way... more
Download research papers for free!