Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Civil-military relations

description4,082 papers
group29,191 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Civil-military relations is the study of the interactions and balance of power between civilian authorities and military organizations within a state. It examines how these relationships influence governance, policy-making, and the role of the military in society, particularly in democratic and authoritarian contexts.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Civil-military relations is the study of the interactions and balance of power between civilian authorities and military organizations within a state. It examines how these relationships influence governance, policy-making, and the role of the military in society, particularly in democratic and authoritarian contexts.

Key research themes

1. How do models of civilian control and military integration impact durable civil-military relations in transitioning and established democracies?

This research theme explores theoretical frameworks and empirical analyses that examine the effectiveness of different civil-military relations models—specifically Huntington's 'separation model' emphasizing institutional differentiation and civilian supremacy, and Schiff's 'concordance model' highlighting integration and consensus among military, political elites, and society—to establish stable democratic civilian control over the military. Understanding these models is crucial when assessing varied experiences of civil-military relations in countries undergoing democratic transition or consolidating democracy, like Turkey, and how structural adaptations or cultural factors affect military political influence and institutional stability.

Key finding: This paper empirically analyzes Turkish civil-military relations through the lens of Huntington's separation model and Schiff's concordance model. It finds that while the separation model predominantly shapes professional... Read more
Key finding: This article delineates the historical evolution of the Turkish civil-military relationship, showing how initial military guardianship during democratization after the 1960 coup evolved into a pattern of recurrent military... Read more
Key finding: This comprehensive overview highlights four central pillars to understanding civil-military relations—military coups, democratic transitions, civilian control mechanisms, and military-society relations—and notes that... Read more

2. What is the role and impact of military political engagement and professional military culture on civil-military relations in democratic contexts?

This theme investigates the nuanced and evolving understanding of military politics within democratic societies, focusing on the political roles military leaders assume beyond conventional civilian control paradigms. It emphasizes how military professionalism, political engagement, and the exercise of practical wisdom by military elites shape democratic civil-military relations. Recognizing that military politics can be virtuous and supportive of democracy challenges traditional prescriptions that view any political engagement by military officers with suspicion. This theme has implications for managing military influence in policymaking in democracies such as the United States.

Key finding: This paper reinterprets Janowitz's and Huntington's foundational theories to argue that military politics—political engagement by senior military officers—is an inherent and necessary component of healthy civil-military... Read more
Key finding: By analyzing a novel dataset of 511 Chiefs of Defence across 82 countries, the study reveals that elite military leaders’ transnational professional experiences—such as international education, multinational deployments, and... Read more
Key finding: This editorial commentary reflects on the interdisciplinary and international evolution of civil-military relations scholarship over 50 years since Janowitz’s foundational work. It highlights how shifts in military... Read more

3. How do civil-military relations dynamics manifest in contexts of political instability, coups, and authoritarian influences, and what implications arise for democracy and security?

This theme addresses the conditions under which military institutions intervene politically, either through coups or more subtle forms of political influence, and how these dynamics challenge democratic consolidation and national security. It engages with case studies from diverse geopolitical contexts—including Brazil, Greece, the Sahel, Turkey, and the United States—highlighting institutional bargaining power, foreign influence, praetorianism, militarization of civilian government, and military politicization. These studies illuminate risks to democratic governance from military autonomy, political manipulation, and the resurgence of authoritarian tendencies within militaries.

Key finding: The study identifies that post-conflict Ukraine faces significant civil-military challenges, including rising political infighting, militarization of government functions, fractures within society regarding the military’s... Read more
Key finding: This paper demonstrates that Brazil's democratic deficit in civil-military relations is rooted historically in the military's entrenched institutional autonomy and significant bargaining power. The military’s strong corporate... Read more
Key finding: The research finds that US geopolitical objectives during the Cold War led to political penetration of Greek military and security institutions, weakening democratic civilian control and ultimately fostering undemocratic... Read more
Key finding: This article connects the recent wave of coups in the Sahel to a resurgence of praetorianism, where cohesive military elites perceive themselves as national guardians amid weak civilian institutions and widespread popular... Read more
Key finding: Through examination of current US civil-military dynamics, this paper warns that increased partisan identification of the military and appointments of politically aligned, often unqualified individuals to leadership posts... Read more

All papers in Civil-military relations

Common wisdom dictates that safety lies in silence and obscurity-that to avoid conflict, one must avoid attention. This paper challenges that notion, proposing a counter-intuitive strategy for self-protection: the cultivation of strategic... more
Abstract This study examines the Challenges of Implementing E-Government Initiatives for Service Delivery in Public Tertiary Institutions in Adamawa State, Nigeria. A survey research design was used and the sample population was drawn... more
ABD merkezli Palantir Technologies Inc. tarafından geliştirilen, teslim edilen ve uygulamaya koyulan bu yazılım, NATO’nun yapay zekâ destekli ilk harp komuta ve kontrol sistemi olacaktır. Sistem; geniş bir yapay zekâ uygulama... more
China-Pakistan maintain a strategic cooperative partnership lasting six decades. Historically, the two sides have built strong military-strategic relations as well as people-to-people contacts. With the launch of China's Belt and Road... more
A larger role for Private Security Companies (PSCs) could make a huge difference in international peacekeeping and stability operations. But utilizing this resource should be done correctly.
Tuntutan masyarakat agar pemerintah mereformasi kepolisian muncul pasca banyaknya perilaku represif aparat Polri dalam penanganan demonstrasi akhir Agustus lalu. Perilaku aparat kepolisian banyak disorot merujuk tindak kekerasan yang... more
Peringatan HUT Tentara Nasional Indonesia (TNI) ke-80 pada 5 Oktober ini diselenggarakan secara gegap gempita. Rangkaian peringatan sudah bergulir sejak Agustus lalu yang diwarnai oleh kegiatan perlombaan olahraga, pameran, hingga acara... more
La reforma constitucional de 2024 que amplió las atribuciones de las Fuerzas Armadas en materia de seguridad interna ha suscitado un intenso debate sobre los límites de dicha intervención. Este trabajo busca profundizar en los... more
Commoner Royal Relations (CRR) is the application of rule of law (RoL) methodologies of international relations diplomacy and civil military relations (CRM) to monarchic states open governance. Its open research began when I had the honor... more
Brigata Reggimenti Data creazione Distretti rifornitori Depositi di provenienza Soldati dispersi Ufficiali dispersi Soldati feriti Ufficiali feriti Soldati morti Ufficiali morti Sede in tempo di pace Tempo in linea (giorni) Tempo in... more
El contenido, uso de fotografías, gráficos, cuadros, tablas y referencias es de exclusiva responsabilidad del autor.
O presente estudo trata-se de uma resenha do livro “El Tren de Aragua: La banda que Revolucionó el Crimen Organizado en América Latina”, publicado, em Caracas Capital da Venezuela, em 2023. O livro aborta como as facções criminosas como o... more
Substantial military service has been a part of world history and defined state sovereignty, citizenship, and social cohesion. This paper will discuss the different evolution of conscription, its legal frameworks, and sociopolitical roles... more
This systematic review analyzed the Military Forces' approach to road construction between 2018-2024. For this purpose, 44 articles on the topic were reviewed. More than half were found on Google Scholar, while the rest the Escuela... more
The decennial exposition of St. Francis Xavier concluded on the 5th of January 2025. Lakhs upon lakhs converged in Old Goa to pay their respect to the relics of the saint. While being loved and shown reverence around the globe, the... more
In this presentation I:  provide an overview of the origins and evolution of the Information Operations (IO) concept; the challenges with training and maintaining an IO workforce; and outline a potential solution.
Recent statements by Donald Trump and Pete Hegseth made at the Quantico base in Virginia during a large forced mass bringing together some 800 US generals and admirals show an authoritarian and repressive shift in the use of the armed... more
This paper analyzes the relationship between the politics of memory, austerity measures, the implications of neoliberalism, and the importance of collective agency in Brazil. The study analyzes how implementing austerity measures between... more
Conformément à la coutume adoptée par le périodique de la Section des Sciences Historiques et Archéologiques, nous présentons un bref texte dédié à la célébration de lʼAcadémicien Victor Spinei, dont le jalon biographique impressionnant... more
Filósofo con maestría y doctorado en Filosofía. Ha publicado trabajos sobre filosofía política y seguridad urbana, entre otros temas. Entre sus obras: El rastro de Caín (2001) y Guerra civil posmoderna (2009). Recientemente, ha editado:... more
Drawing on extensive original empirical research, this article examines the adoption of NATO's lessons-learned process within the Netherlands Army. It finds that existing accounts of military learning inadequately explain how practices... more
Film The 15:17 to Paris (2018) yang disutradarai Clint Eastwood merekonstruksi kisah nyata upaya tiga pemuda Amerika yang berhasil menggagalkan serangan teror di kereta cepat Thalys pada 2015. Kajian ini menempatkan film tersebut dalam... more
califican Bueno, cuatro Regular y dos Malo. La evaluación del Proceso, da como resultado, 74.7% y una calificación Regular. La Evaluación de resultados permite ver una asociación no lineal, entre aspectos de la organización, su... more
Toffler e sua esposa Heidi, em sua obra Guerra e antiguerra, afirmam que as civilizações atravessam ondas de desenvolvimento no seu modo de produção no transcurso da história. Os ciclos ou ondas levantados são o agrícola, industrial e o... more
La militarización de la política democrática es la concesión, por gobernantes electos democráticamente, de poder y tareas al personal militar en diferentes áreas. Ello excede la seguridad pública, pues en Brasil, Colombia y México abarca... more
identities, beliefs, values, and attitudes.5 Understanding the dynamic association between these central life interests and knowing which of them are most important to individuals' self-conceptions will help explain and predict behavioral... more
Ce texte est issu de l’intervention de Alessandro Pagani dans la Table ronde IX « La guerre froide » dans le cadre du « Deuxième Congrès d’Histoire et de Société Contemporaine de l’Université Autonome de la Ville de México (UACM) : cent... more
Peace for the world is not merely the absence of violence but the presence of justice, cooperation, and human security that enables societies to flourish. This paper develops an integrated approach to world peace by combining theoretical... more
Este ensaio analisa a formação e consolidação da "Síndrome Golpista Originária" no Brasil republicano, tendo Hermes da Fonseca (1855-1923) como figura paradigmática da institucionalização do militarismo político brasileiro. A partir da... more
يتناول هذا المقال كتاب إفريقيا وإعادة النظر في العلاقات المدنية–العسكرية (2023م)، الذي يستعرض تحولات أدوار الجيوش في القارة من الانقلابات المباشرة التي ميّزت عقود ما بعد الاستقلال، إلى أشكال جديدة من النفوذ عبر الاقتصاد والسياسة والأمن... more
The Philippine Army's Strategies on Crisis Communication: Public Affairs Officers' Practices explored the current strategies of the Philippine Army on crisis communication. The objectives were to determine the profile of the Public... more
Методичні рекомендації розроблені на основі дослідження та аналізу стратегій поведінки військових, які отримали тяжкі поранення чи ампутації. У роботі визначено ключові соціально-демографічні, освітньо-професійні та особистісні чинники,... more
With the evolving integration of conventional, irregular and cyber capabilities, the contemporary landscape of warfare is undergoing with a substantial transformation. This trend has been generally identified as a hybrid or multi-domain... more
The study of corruption in political economy is inseparable from the question of how states allocate resources, maintain legitimacy, and confront collective resistance. Nowhere is this clearer than in Nepal, Indonesia, and the... more
Det norske systemet for krisehåndtering gjennomgås og er i endring. Denne artikkelen diskuterer noen åpenbare organisatoriske, politiske og juridiske utfordringer som man står ovenfor ved krisehåndtering i Fiskevernsonen rundt Svalbard.... more
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk provided by FHS Brage 2-2015 Oberst Gjert Lage Dyndal er avdelingssjef for «Militaermakt, strategi og doktrine» ved Forsvarets stabsskole. Han jobbet før det som ledende forsker og... more
Essa pesquisa tem como tema geral a presença de pessoas abertamente LGB (lésbicas, gays e bissexuais) nas Forças Armadas da Argentina e do Brasil no século XXI. A partir da compreensão de que as Relações Internacionais são impactadas... more
A poetic essay bridging Romanian myth and cosmic imagination, this piece explores the symbolic resonance of flight — from the contemplative shepherd in Miorița to Major Tom’s orbital solitude in Space Oddity. Mociulschi reinterprets... more
The study here proposed is an analysis of militarisation processes of hegemonic masculinities by an intersectional feminist lens and their impacts on peacebuilding and international security, taking Italy as contextual reference.... more
This article uses urban semiotics as a lens to analyze elite power relations in Iraqi politics, as well as the role and limits of impunity therein. The article focuses on the contestation of symbolism in Baghdadi public space between... more
Myanmar is not merely a fragile state trapped in a cycle of authoritarianism and conflict—it is a shattered home, ruled by fear, betrayal, and silence. Its crisis is not just political; it is deeply psychological, rooted in patterns of... more
Download research papers for free!