Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Outline

Title
Abstract
Conclusion: On the Unbearable Weightiness of Being
References
All Topics
Theology
Religion

Violence, Ethics, and Divine Honor in Modern Jewish Thought

Profile image of Don SeemanDon Seeman

2005, Journal of The American Academy of Religion

https://doi.org/10.1093/JAAREL/LFI113
visibility

…

description

34 pages

link

1 file

Abstract

Although little analyzed, the concept of divine honor or glory (kavod shamayim) has been central to formulations of classical Jewish thought and ethics. In the aftermath of the 1994 Hebron massacre, Rabbi Yitzhak Ginsburg deployed the concept of divine honor as a religious sanction for murder. His tract Barukh Ha-Gever treats attrocity as a mystical technique for the attainment of unmediated, ecstatic, and personal experience of the divine. This article examines the genealogy of Ginsburg's anarchic ideology, which it contrasts with that of Rabbi Abraham Issac Kook and the philosopher Emmanuel Levinas, two important twentieth-century Jewish thinkers for whom divine honor was also central, but whose vision for that honor was antithetical to the quest for unmediated divine experience, or to acts that violate religious law and human dignity. This article assays a phenomenology of divine honor and its relationship to violence in modern times. Don Seeman is an assistant professor of religion and Jewish studies at

Related papers

The Paradox of Jewish Ethics of Martyrdom and Preventive Homicide: Notes on Deviance in Heteronomous & Autonomous Behavior. In Devianz und Dynamik. FS für Hubert Seiwert, Edited by Edith Franke, Thomas Hase, Christoph Kleine und Heinz Mürmel. 47-61. Berlin: De Gruyter, 2013.
Giuseppe Veltri

Bibliografische Information der Deutschen Nationalbibliothek Die Deutsche Nationalbibliothek verzeichnet diese Publikation in der Deutschen Nationalbibliografie; detaillierte bibliografische Daten sind im Internet über http://dnb.d-nb.de abrufbar.

View PDFchevron_right
Towards a Jewish Theology of Nonviolence
Aaron Hahn Tapper
View PDFchevron_right
Wrestling with God: Jewish Theologians Facing the Shoah
Shoshana Ronen

Jewish History Quarterly, 2013

This article deals with Jewish theological reactions to the Holocaust, concentrating on the image of God which these thinkers illustrate. The theologists who are discussed are divided into two main groups. The first struggle with the dilemma of “where was God in Auschwitz” with different variations on the theological concept of hester panim (God hides his face). Among the ideas discussed here the feminist approach is perceived as the most convincing and less self-contradicting. The second group of thinkers made Auschwitz into a “Mysterium Tremendum” and gave it a transcendent tone, the ethics of which this article severely questions.

View PDFchevron_right
Byron L. Sherwin. In Partnership With God: Contemporary Jewish Law and Ethics. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, 1990. xiv, 290 pp
moshe sokol

Ajs Review-the Journal of The Association for Jewish Studies, 1993

View PDFchevron_right
A JEWISH CONCEPTION OF HUMAN DIGNITY
Doron Shultziner

Journal of Religious Ethics, 2006

This paper depicts the meanings of human dignity as they unfold and evolve in the Bible and the Halakhah. I posit that three distinct features of a Jewish conception of human dignity can be identified in contrast to core characteristics of a liberal conception of human dignity. First, the original source of human dignity is not intrinsic to the human being but extrinsic, namely in God. Second, it is argued that the "dignity of the people" has precedence over personal autonomy and liberty, which are core liberal pillars. The third characteristic pertains to the potential conflict between personal autonomy and liberty, and God's commandments. The theoretical analysis of human dignity is then examined in light of several Supreme Court decisions in Israel during the 1990s. I illustrate that Jewish religious and secular-liberal conceptions pull in different directions in the rulings of liberal and religious Justices in Israel.

View PDFchevron_right
To sanctify the name of God: ritual precision and martyrdom in Rabbi Ephraim Oshry’s Holocaust responsa
Nehemia Stern

This article will analyze a collection of religious queries and responses written by Rabbi Ephraim Oshry, a well-known halakhic decisor of the Kovno Ghetto. It will demonstrate how Rabbi Oshry utilized questions concerning ritual practice and precision to empirically quantify and categorize a new reality of genocide. Here classical forms of Jewish martyrdom were used as a framework through which ghetto inmates could exert a certain amount of ritualized control over a genocide whose scale was difficult to comprehend, and whose extent they could not predict. Rabbi Oshry’s text also demonstrates some of the tragic limitations of ritual activity to act as either an explanatory or efficacious model for confronting the Nazi genocide.

View PDFchevron_right
The Necessary Critique of Divine Violence
Frank Ruda
View PDFchevron_right
A Theological Response to Biblical Violence
Erika Barnard

Scriptura

The overwhelming number of violent texts within the Old Testament raises serious theological and ethical problems for those who read the Bible in search of spiritual devotion and ethical direction. This article aims to explore one of the most ethically challenging texts in this regardthe conquest narrative in Joshua 6-11. An interdisciplinary study is presented in which social identity theory, the concept of hybridity and the role of courage and fear within an ancient community are discussed. This response is largely based upon the work of Baumann (2006) who also urges contemporary scholars to not only engage with the violent images within the Old Testament but also to earnestly seek to understand the functioning thereof within its original Ancient Near Eastern context.

View PDFchevron_right
The Violent God of the Bible: A Study on the Historical Background and Its Impact on the Discussion on Human Dignity
Klaas Spronk

Scriptura, 2013

This article seeks for a good method to use the Bible in a fruitful way in discussions about religion and violence. First some general remarks are made on the hermeneutics of sacred texts. Then the discussion is presented about the assumed direct relation between monotheism and violence, evaluating the positions of Assmann and Albertz. Much attention is paid to the image of Yhwh as a jealous god with jealous (zealous) followers. It can be demonstrated that the picture of a violent God is much influenced by historical circumstances. Already within the Old Testament the central confession about Yhwh in Exodus 34:6-7 describing him as both merciful and violent has been applied differently, depending on the changing situation. As a conclusion some indications are given about the way the Bible can act as an agent of change.

View PDFchevron_right
Rabbinic Judaism’s Perspective on the First Crimes Against Humanity
ROman Kralik

Bogoslovni vestnik, 2021

This article focuses on the first recorded crimes (sins) against humanity in the context of the broader and more fundamental issue of human life's intrinsic value and dignity. An analysis of the views of rabbinic Judaism reveals a network of concepts that are dynamically intertwined. They originate from a strictly monotheistic framework (worldview) of Judaism that helps resolve whether a person is allowed to end his life for the sake of others. Careful analysis and interpretation of the first three acts of violence recorded in the Hebrew Bible (Tanakh) reveal the catastrophic consequences of choosing to end another's life without considering its intrinsic value while ignoring the intrinsic value of the other and his dignity and assuming that humans have the power to decide the fate of another human being, to distance humanity from God (from God's presence), trapping humans in the idolatry of materialism. Moreover, the Hebrew Bible (Tanakh) allows for a factual assessment and distinction between different acts of violence. It offers guidance, protection, and hope, for both victims and perpetrators, in the drama of creation and salvation.

View PDFchevron_right

References (48)

  1. Amital, R. Yehudah 1985 "The Meaning of Rav Kook's Teaching for our Generation" (Hebrew). In Yovel 'Orot: Haguto shel ha-Rav Avraham Yitzhak Ha-Cohen Kook, 333-341. Ed. by Benjamin Ish-Shalom and Shalom Rosenberg. Jerusalem: Histadrut.
  2. Aran, Gidon 1986 "From Religious Zionism to Zionist Religion: The Roots of Gush Emunim." In Studies in Con- temporary Jewry II. Ed. by Peter Medding, 116-143. New York: Oxford University Press.
  3. Asad, Talal 1993 Genealogies of Religion: Discipline and Reasons of Power in Christianity and Islam. Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins University Press.
  4. Ben-Shlomo, Yosef 1988 "The Divine Ideals in Rav Kook's Teaching." In Bar Ilan Sefer ha-Shana (Moshe Schwarcz Anni- versary Volume). Ed. by Moshe Halamish. Ramat Gan: Bar-Ilan University.
  5. Berger, Peter 1973 "On the Obsolescence of the Concept of Honor." In The Homeless Mind: Modernization and Conscious- ness, 83-96. Ed. by Peter Berger, Brigitte Berger, and Hansfried Kellner. New York: Random House.
  6. Bin-Nun, R. Yoel 1985 "Nationalism, Humanity and the Congregation of Israel" (Hebrew). In Yovel 'Orot: Haguto shel ha-Rav Avraham Yitzhak Ha-Cohen Kook, 333-341. Ed. by Benjamin Ish-Shalom and Shalom Rosenberg. Jerusalem: Histadrut.
  7. Borowitz, Eugene 1983 Choices in Modern Jewish Thought: A Partisan Guide. New York: Behrman House.
  8. Chalier, Catherine 1995 "The Philosophy of Emmanuel Levinas and the Hebraic Tradition." In Ethics as First Philosophy: The Significance of Emmanuel Levinas for Philosophy, Literature and Religion, 3-23. Ed. by Adriaan Pep- erzak. London: Routledge.
  9. Cohen, Steven M., and Robert M. Eisen 2000 The Jew Within: Self, Family and Community in America. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
  10. de Boer, Theo 1995 "Theology and the Philosophy of Religion Accord- ing to Levinas." In Ethics as First Philosophy: The Significance of Emmanuel Levinas for Philosophy, Literature and Religion, 161-172. Ed. by Adriaan Peperzak. London: Routledge.
  11. Ginsburg, Yitzhak 1994
  12. Barukh Ha-Gever: Five General Commandments that Constitute Five Inner Perspectives on the Deed of the Holy Rabbi Barukh Goldstein, May God Avenge His Blood (Hebrew pamphlet, n.p.). 1995 "Barukh Ha-Gever." In Barukh Ha-Gever: Sefer Zikharon la-Kadosh Barukh Goldstein, 18-47. No editor given. Jerusalem: n.p. Haivry, Ofir 1996 "Act and Comprehend." Azure 1.
  13. Ish-Shalom, Benjamin 1995 "Tolerance and Its Theoretical Basis in the Teaching of Rav Kook." In Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook and Jewish Spirituality, 178-204. Ed. by Lawrence J. Kaplan and David Shatz. New York: New York University Press.
  14. Jackson, Michael 1998
  15. Minima Ethnographica: Intersubjectivity and the Anthropological Project. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
  16. Jacobs, Louis 1963 Tract on Ecstasy. London: Valentine Mitchell.
  17. Kaplan, Lawrence J. 1995 "Rav Kook: The Philosophical Tradition." In Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook and Jewish Spiritual- ity, 41-77. Ed. by Lawrence J. Kaplan and David Shatz. New York: New York University Press.
  18. Kook, R. Abraham 1967 'Eder Ha-Yakar. Jerusalem: Mossad Ha-Rav Kook. 1984
  19. Ma'amarei Ha-Ra'ayah. Jerusalem: n.p. 1985 Middot Ha-Ra-ayah. Jerusalem: Mossad Ha-Rav Kook. 2004 Pincas 13: Kitvei Ha-Rav Avraham Yitzkak Ha-Cohen Kook. Jerusalem: Ha-Machon al shem R. Tzvi Yehudah Kook.
  20. Leibowitz, R. Yeruham 2000
  21. Da'at Chochmah U-Mussar, 2. Jerusalem: Me'Oray Oros Hamussar Publications.
  22. Levinas, Emmanuel 1969 Totality and Infinity. Trans. by Alphonso Lingis. Pittsburgh, PA: Duquesne University. 1990 "A Religion for Adults." In Difficult Freedom: Essays on Judaism, 11-23. Trans. by Sean Hand. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press. 1994a "Revelation in the Jewish Tradition." In Beyond the Verse: Talmudic Readings and Lectures, 129-150. Trans. by Gary D. Mole. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. 1994b " 'In the Image of God' According to Rabbi Hayyim Volozhiner." In Beyond theVerse: Tal- mudic Readings and Lectures, 151-167. Trans. by Gary D. Mole. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. 1994c "On Religious Language and the Fear of God." In Beyond the Verse: Talmudic Readings and Lec- tures, 86-98. Trans. by Gary D. Mole. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
  23. 2000 God, Death and Time. Trans. by Bettina Bergo. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
  24. Lobel, Diane 2000
  25. Between Mysticism and Philosophy: Sufi Language of Religious Experience in Judah Ha-Levi's Kuzari. Albany: State University of New York Press. Loewenthal, Naftali 1987 "The Apotheosis of Action in Early Habad." Da'at 18: v-xix.
  26. Luzzatto, R. Moshe 1999
  27. Mesilat Yesharim. Ed. by Avraham Shoshana. Jerusalem: Machon Ofek
  28. Michaelson, Jay 1994
  29. Saadia Gaon's Kavod Nivra and Its Place in His Philosophy of Judaism. Available at http:// www.metatronics.net/lit/saadia.html. Accessed November 2004.
  30. Rakover, Nahum 1998
  31. Human Dignity in Jewish Law (Hebrew). Jerusalem: Ministry of Justice.
  32. Ravitzky, Aviezer 1995
  33. Messianism, Zionism and Jewish Religious Radi- calism. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
  34. Robbins, Jill 2000 Is It Righteous to be? Interviews with Emmanuel Levinas. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
  35. Ross, Tamar 1982 "The Concept of God in the Thought of Rav Kook (Hebrew)." Da'at 8: 109-128. 1995 "What Would Rav Kook Have to Say about the State of Israel Today?" In Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook and Jewish Sprituality, 301-307. Ed. by Lawrence J. Kaplan and David Schatz. New York: New York University Press.
  36. Safranski, Rudiger 1998
  37. Martin Heidegger: Between Good and Evil. Trans. by Ewald Osers. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Uni- versity Press.
  38. Scheersohn, Menahem 1991
  39. Derekh Mitzvotecha. New York, NY: Kehot Publications.
  40. Schneersohn, Dov Beer 1988
  41. Drushei Chasunah 1. New York, NY: Kehot Publications. 1991 Maamorei Admur HaEmtzoee: Kuntresim. New York, NY: Kehot Publishing.
  42. Scholem, Gershom 1941
  43. Major Trends in Jewish Mysticism. New York, NY: Schocken Books.
  44. Seeman, Don 2003 "Emotion, Martyrdom and the Work of Ritual in R. Mordecai Leiner of Izbica's Mei Ha-Shiloah." AJS Review 27/ 2: 253-280. 2004 "Otherwise than Meaning: On the Generosity of Ritual." Social Analysis 48/ 2: 55-71.
  45. Sikka, Sonia 1998 "Questioning the Sacred: Heidegger and Levinas on the Locus of Divinity." Modern Theology 14/ 3: 299-322
  46. Singer, David 1996 "Rav Kook's Contested Legacy." Tradition 30: 6-20.
  47. Taylor, Charles 1991 The Ethics of Authenticity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
  48. Tracy, David 1995 "Response to Adriaan Peperzak on Trans- cendence." In Ethics as First Philosophy: The Sig- nificance of Emmanuel Levinas for Philosophy,

Related papers

God's Honor, Violence and the State
Don Seeman

Published in: Robert W. Jensen and Eugene Korn editors, Swords into Plowshares: Reflections on Religion and Violence (Essays from the Institute for Theological Inquiry). Center for Jewish and Christian Understanding and Cooperation (Kindle Edition 2014). ABSTRACT Don Seeman, the author of the chapter “Violence, Divine Honor and the State,” has published a number of studies touching on the relationship between the idea of divine honor and religious violence in different Jewish intellectual settings and he has also written as an anthropologist on the relationship between honor and political violence in modern Israel. Here, for the first time, he offers a synthetic reading that attempts to account for the close relationship between the anthropological and theological registers and to account in a systematic way for differences in approach between Jewish thinkers as diverse as Maimonides, R. Moshe Hayyim Luzzatto, Rav Kook, Moses Mendelssohn and Emmanuel Levinas. He begins with a phenomenological critique of the way honor and shame have been treated in recent social science literature. He argues that honor and shame are “bridge concepts” that are applied in classical conceptions to human beings as well as to God and that they therefore help to condition theological as well as political or anthropological conceptions of ethics and violence. After brief analyses of key biblical and rabbinic texts, Seeman argues that Jewish approaches to divine honor and violence can be divided into three dominant paradigms: vernacular, mystical and philosophical. The vernacular paradigm treats divine honor in anthropomorphic terms that are indistinguishable from those used to explain human social relations and recourse to violence. The mystical or kabbalistic paradigm builds, in a sense, on this robust vernacular sensibility, but adds a distinctive and subtle metaphysics of divine presence. This is the context in which the utter rejection of the vernacular sensibility by philosophical Judaism — exemplified by Maimonides and by modern thinkers such as Moses Mendelssohn — takes on such importance. Seeman argues that the very shape of Jewish modernity has been conditioned by arguments over the nature of divine honor and by the political ramifications of those differences. The rejection of vernacular divine honor is a central theme of Mendelssohn’s Jerusalem to which contemporary Jews are still implicitly or explicitly responding. We cannot understand the complex relationships between religion, violence and the state without a much better understanding of these dynamics. "

View PDFchevron_right
The Overcoming of Biblically-Mandated Violence in Rabbinic Judaism
J. H. Chajes

The Jewish tradition — technically speaking, the rabbinic tradition that establishes what is called “Judaism” and which is known in emic terms as “the Oral Tradition” — might be described as a courageous and even audacious attempt of the ancient rabbis to read and implement the Bible in a manner consistent with their own ethical ideals. This, even when doing so required them to assert readings that clearly contradicted the plain sense of Scripture. In this lecture, I explore the ways in which rabbinic morality and commitment to the sanctity of human life led to the neutralization of biblically-mandated violence.

View PDFchevron_right
Review of Alan Mittleman, _Does Judaism Condone Violence? Holiness and Ethics in the Jewish Tradition_ (Princeton UP, 2018)
Martin Shuster

Reading Religion, 2020

Reading Religion welcomes comments from AAR members, and you may leave a comment below by logging in with your AAR Member ID and password. Please read our policy on commenting.

View PDFchevron_right
Review of Jewish Justice: The Contested Limits of Nature, Law and Covenant by David Novak, Political Theology 19:6 (2018).
Ayelet Hoffmann Libson
View PDFchevron_right
“The Foremost Amongst the Divine Attributes Is to Hate the Vulgar Power of Violence”: Aharon Shmuel Tamares and Recovering Nonviolence for Jewish Ethics
Aryeh Cohen

In this paper I am trying to recover Tamares for contemporary ethical discourse by putting his nonviolence and pacifism in dialogue with Levinas’s “pacifism” in Totality and Infinity. They share a common aim of eradicating war and violence, or for Levinas, war and “bad” violence. However, they come to this end from very different philosophical places. Tamares’s thought starts with a religious humanism which holds that being created in the Divine Image means that humans are at the center of creation and that the purpose of creation is to bring an excellence to human beings. For Levinas it is a basic recognition of the transcendence of another person, which leads to the impossibility of using or harming another person and only leaves open the possibility of responding to their needs, which is the path of peace.

View PDFchevron_right

Related topics

  • Religion
  • Abrahamic Religions
  • Comparative Religion
  • Sociology of Religion
  • Jewish Law
  • Philosophy Of Religion
  • Moral Psychology
  • Jewish Studies
  • Violence
  • History of Religion
  • Israel Studies
  • Religion and Politics
  • Jewish Mysticism
  • Political Violence and Terrorism
  • Jewish Ethics
  • Middle East Anthropology
  • History of Religions
  • Theology and Culture
  • Comparative Mysticism
  • Spirituality & Mysticism
  • Epistemology Of Religious Experi...
  • Political Theology
  • Religion, Conflict and Peacebuil...
  • Jewish Thought
  • Ethics and Religion
  • Jewish Philosophy
  • Religion and Modernity
  • Modern Jewish Philosophy
  • Religious Experience
  • Religion & Politics
  • Religion and Violence
  • Phenomenology of Religion
  • Jewish Cultural Studies
  • Theology of Suffering and Evil
  • Modern Judaism
  • Religious Zionism
  • Mystical Theology
  • Israel and Zionism
  • Religious Studies
  • Philosophy and Religion
  • Judaic Studies
  • Modern Jewish Thought
  • Philosophy and Religious Studies
  • Orthodox Judaism
  • Comparative Mystical Literature
  • Religion and Conflict
  • Rav Kook
  • Social Suffering
  • Mystical experience
  • HaRav Kook
  • Theology and Religious Studies
  • Mystical literature
  • Culture of Honor
  • Hebrew and Jewish studies
  • Jewish Thought and Philosophy
  • Jewish Religion and Thought
  • Anthropology of Religion
  • History of Philosophy
  • Jewish political thought
  • Hebrew Language Mysticism
  • Rabbi A.i. Kook
  • Mystical Psychology
  • Modern Orthodox Theology
  • Religious and Political Violence
  • Rabbi Kook
  • Middle Eastern Religions
  • Comparative Philosophy and Religion
  • Law, Religion and Violence
  • Modern Jewish Thought and Theology
  • Chabad-Lubavitch
    • 580 California St., Suite 400
    San Francisco, CA, 94104
    © 2025 Academia. All rights reserved