Quantum spacetime: what do we know
Abstract
I discuss nature and origin of the problem of quantum gravity. I examine the knowledge that may guide us in addressing this problem, and the reliability of such knowledge. In particular, I discuss the subtle modification of the notions of space and time engendered by general relativity, and how these might merge into quantum theory. I also present some reflections on methodological questions, and on some general issues in philosophy of science which are are raised by, or a relevant for, the research on quantum gravity.
References (39)
- Ashtekar A , Lewandowski J (1997a). Quantum Theory of Gravity I: Area Operators, Class and Quantum Grav 14, A55-A81.
- Ashtekar A, Lewandowski J (1997b). Quantum Theory of Geometry II: Volume operators, gr- qc/9711031.
- Baez J (1997). Spin networks in nonperturbative quantum gravity, in The interface of knots and physics, ed L Kauffman (American Mathematical Society, Providence).
- Baez J (1998). Spin foam models, Class Quantum Grav, 15, 1827-1858.
- Baez J (1999). In "Physics Meets Philosophy at the Planck scale", C Callender N Hugget eds, Cambridge University Press, to appear.
- Barbour J (1989). Absolute or Relative Motion? (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
- Barret J, Crane L (1998). Relativistic spin networks and quantum gravity, Journ Math Phys 39, 3296-3302.
- Belot G (1998). Why general relativity does need an interpretation, Philosophy of Science, 63, S80-S88.
- Connes A and Rovelli C (1994). Von Neumann algebra automorphisms and time versus ther- modynamics relation in general covariant quantum theories, Classical and Quantum Gravity 11, 2899. Crane L (1991). 2d physics and 3d topology, Comm Math Phys 135, 615-640.
- Descartes R (1983): Principia Philosophiae, Translated by VR Miller and RP Miller (Reidel, Dordrecht [1644]).
- Earman J (1989). World Enough and Spacetime: Absolute versus Relational Theories of Space- time (MIT Press, Cambridge).
- Earman J, Norton J (1987). What Price Spacetime Substantivalism? The Hole Story, British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 38, 515-525.
- Isham C (1999). In "Physics Meets Philosophy at the Planck scale", C Callender N Hugget eds, Cambridge University Press, to appear.
- Newton I (1962): De Gravitatione et Aequipondio Fluidorum, translation in AR Hall and MB Hall eds Unpublished papers of Isaac Newton (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
- Norton J D (1984). How Einstein Found His Field Equations: 1912-1915, Historical Studies in the Physical Sciences, 14, 253-315. Reprinted in Einstein and the History of General Relativity: Einstein Studies, D Howard and J Stachel eds., Vol.I, 101-159 ( Birkhäuser, Boston).
- Penrose R (1995). The Emperor's new mind (Oxford University Press)
- Reisenberger M, Rovelli C (1997). Sum over Surfaces Form of Loop Quantum Gravity, Physical Review, D56, 3490-3508, gr-qc/9612035.
- Rovelli C (1991a). What is observable in classical and quantum gravity?, Classical and Quantum Gravity, 8, 297.
- Rovelli C (1991b). Quantum reference systems, Classical and Quantum Gravity, 8, 317.
- Rovelli C (1991c). Quantum mechanics without time: a model, Physical Review, D42, 2638.
- Rovelli C (1991d). Time in quantum gravity: an hypothesis, Physical Review, D43, 442.
- Rovelli C (1991e). Quantum evolving constants. Physical Review D44, 1339.
- Rovelli C (1993a). Statistical mechanics of gravity and thermodynamical origin of time, Classical and Quantum Gravity, 10, 1549.
- Rovelli C (1993b). The statistical state of the universe, Classical and Quantum Gravity, 10, 1567.
- Rovelli C (1993c). A generally covariant quantum field theory and a prediction on quantum measurements of geometry, Nuclear Physics, B405, 797.
- Rovelli C (1995). Analysis of the different meaning of the concept of time in different physical theories, Il Nuovo Cimento, 110B, 81.
- Rovelli C (1996). Relational Quantum Mechanics, International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 35, 1637.
- Rovelli C (1997a). Half way through the woods, in The Cosmos of Science, J Earman and JD Norton editors, (University of Pittsburgh Press and Universitäts Verlag Konstanz).
- Rovelli, C. (1997b) Loop Quantum Gravity, Living Reviews in Relativity (refereed electronic journal), http://www.livingreviews.org/ Articles/Volume1/1998-1rovelli; gr-qc/9709008
- Rovelli C (1998). Incerto tempore, incertisque loci: Can we compute the exact time at which the quantum measurement happens?, Foundations of Physics, 28, 1031-1043, quant-ph/9802020.
- Rovelli C (1999). Strings, loops and the others: a critical survey on the present approaches to quantum gravity, in Gravitation and Relativity: At the turn of the millennium, N Dadhich J Narlikar eds (Poona University Press), gr-qc/9803024.
- Rovelli C and Smolin L (1988). Knot theory and quantum gravity, Physical Review Letters, 61, 1155.
- Rovelli C and Smolin L (1990). Loop space representation for quantum general relativity, Nuclear Physics, B331, 80.
- Rovelli C, Smolin L (1995a). Spin Networks and Quantum Gravity, Physical Review, D 53, 5743.
- Rovelli C and Smolin L (1995b). Discreteness of Area and Volume in Quantum Gravity, Nuclear Physics B442, 593. Erratum: Nuclear Physics B 456, 734.
- Smolin L (1997). The future of spin networks, gr-qc/9702030.
- Stachel J (1989). Einstein search for general covariance 1912-1915, in Einstein Studies, D Howard and J Stachel eds, vol 1, 63-100 (Birkhäuser, Boston).
- Stein H (1999). Physics and philosophy meet: the strange case of Poincaré. Unpublished.
- Zeilinger A, in Gravitation and Relativity: At the turn of the millennium, N Dadhich J Narlikar eds (Poona University Press).