Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Outline

Shock/Vortex Interaction and Vortex-Breakdown Modes

1993, Fluid Dynamics of High Angle of Attack

https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-52460-8_13

Abstract

Computational simulation and study of shock/vortex interaction and vortex-breakdown modes are considered for bound (internal) and unbound (external) flow domains. The problem is formulated using the unsteady, compressible, full Navier-Stokes (NS) equations which are solved using an implicit, flux-difference splitting, finite-volume scheme. For the bound flow domain, a supersonic swirling flow is considered in a configured circular duct and the problem is solved for quasi-axisymmetric and three-dimensional flows. For the unbound domain, a supersonic swirling flow issued from a nozzle into a uniform supersonic flow of lower Mach number is considered for quasi-axisymmetric and three-dimensionai flows. The results show several modes of breakdown; e.g., no-breakdown, transient single-bubble breakdown, transient multi-bubble breakdown, periodic multi-bubble multi-frequency breakdown and helical breakdown. Highlights of Formulation and Computational Scheme Formulation: The conservative,unsteady, compressible, fullNavier-Stokes equations in terms of time-independent,body-conformed coordinates_I, _2 and _3 are used to solve the problem. The equations arc given in Ref. [II] and hence they are not presented hem. Along with these equations, boundary conditions arc specifiedat the computational-domain inlet, side wall and downstream exit.The downstream exit boundary conditions will be presented and discussed in the next sectionof the computational results. The initial conditionsarc also presented in the next section. Computational Scheme: The computational scheme used to solve the unsteady, compressible full NS equations is an implicit, upwind, flux-difference splitting, finite-volume scheme. It employs the flux-difference splitting scheme of Roe which is based on the solution of the approximate one-dimensional Riemann problem in each of the three directions. In the Roe scheme, the inviscid flux difference at the interface of a computational cell is split into left and right flux differences. The splitting is accomplished according to the signs of the eigenvalues of the Roe averaged-Jacobian roan'ix of the inviscid flux at the cell interface. The smooth limiter is used to eliminate oscillations in the shock region. The viscous and heat-flux terms am differenced using second-order spatially accurate central differencing. The resulting contours for this case. These snapshots show a vortex breakdown mechanism of evolution, Concluding Remarks Computational simulation and study of shock/vortex interaction and vortex breakdown have been considered for internal and external supersonic swirling flow. The time-accurate computation for full Navier-Stokes equations is used to produce all the present cases.

References (73)

  1. Dclery, J.; Horowitz, REFERENCES
  2. Hallock, J. N. and Eberle, W. R., "Aircraft Wake Vortices: A State-of-the-Art Review of the United States R&D Program," FAA RepL FAA-RD-77-23, February 1977.
  3. Dee, F. W. and Nicholas, O. P., "Flight Measurements of Wing tip Vortex Motion Near the Ground," C'P 1065, British Aeronautical Research Council, London, 1968.
  4. Harvey, J. K. and Pen V, F. J., "Flowfieid Produced by Trailing Vortices in the Vicinity of the Ground," AIAA Journal, Vol. 9, Aug. 1977, pp. 1659-1660.
  5. _. El-Rarely, Z., "Induced Rolling Moment on Trailing Wings," AIAA 10th Fluid & Plasma-dynamics Con- feronc._, Albuquerque, NM, June 1977.
  6. Wood, W. D. and McW'dliams, T. G., "Wake Turbu- lence Detection and Economic hnpact of Proposed Im- provements," SAE Air T_ Meeting,Wash- ington,D.C., May 1977.
  7. Gardoz, L. J., "Federal Aviation Administration Full- Scale Aircraft Vortex Wake Turbulence Flight Test Investigations: Past, Present, Future," AIAA Paper No. 71-97, January 1971.
  8. Cliffone, D. L. and Lonzo, C., Jr., "Flow Visualiza- tion of Vertex Interactions in Multiple vortex Wakes Behind Aircraft," NASA TMX 62, 459, June 1975.
  9. Olwi, I. A. and Ghazi, M. A., "An Expmd.meatal Inves- tigation of the Turbulence Effect of a Leading Wing on a Trailing Aircraft," AIAA 91-3309-CP, A/AA 1001
  10. Applied Aerodynamics Confea_x:e, September 1991, pp. 830-837.
  11. Liu, H.-T., "Effects of Ambient Turbulence on the Lifespanof a Trailing Vo_.x Wake," Quest Integrated, Inc.,Technicalpaper No. 268, Kent, Washington, October 1991.
  12. Liu,H.-T.,Hwang, P_. and Srnsky,R.A.,"Physical Modeling of Ground Effects on Vor,ex Wakes," Quest Integrated, Inc., Technical paper No. 274, Kent, Washington, October 1991.
  13. Cborin, A. J. and Bernard, P. S., "Discrelo.__;,aion of a Vortex Sheet, with m Example of Roll-up," Journal of Computational Physics, Vol. 13, November 1973, pp. 423--429.
  14. Hackett, J. E. and Evans,M. R.,"VortexWakes BehindHigh LiftWings,"Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 8,May 1971,pp. 334-340.
  15. Yates, J.E.,"Calculation ofInitial VortexRoll-Upin Aircraft Wakes," Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 11, July 1974, pp. 397-400.
  16. Iversen, J. D. and Bernstein, S., "Trailing Vortex Effects on Following Aircraft," Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 11, January 1974, pp. 60-61.
  17. Rossow, V. J., "Inviscid Modeling of Aircraft Trail- ing Vortices," Proceedings of NASA Symposium on Wake Vortex Minimization," Washington, D.C., Feb- ruary 1976, pp. 4-54.
  18. Kandil, O. A., Mook, D. T. and Nayfeh, A. H., "Ap- plication of the Nonlinear vortex-Lattice Concept to aircraft-Interference Problems," Advances in Engi- neering Science, NASA CP-2001, Vol. 4, November 1976, pp. 1321-1326.
  19. Kandil, O. A., Mook, D. T. and Nayfeh, A. H., "Nonlinear Prediction of the Aerodynamics Loads on Lifting Surface," Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 13, No. 1, January 1976, pp. 22-28.
  20. McCormick, B. W., Tangler, J. L. and Sherrieb, H. E., "Structure of Trailing vortices," Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 5, No. 3, May-June 1968, pp. 260-267.
  21. Bilamn, A. J., Teske, M. E. and Williamson, G. G., "Vortex Interactions and Decay in Aircraft Wakes," AIAA Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, Feb. 1977, pp. 250--260.
  22. Bilanin, A. J., Teske, M. E. and Hirsh, J. E., "Neutral Atmospheric Effects on the Dissipation of Aircraft Vortex Wakes," AIAA Journal, Vol. 16, No. 9, September 1978, pp. 956-961.
  23. Liu, C. H. and Ting, L., "Interaction of Decaying Trailing vortices in spanwise Shear How," Computer and Fluids, Vol. 15, No. 1, 1987, pp. 77-92.
  24. Weston,R. P.,Tmg, L. and Liu,C. H.,"Numerical Studies of theMerging Vortices," AIAA 86-0557, January 1986.
  25. Liu, C. H., Tavantzis, J. and "l'mg, L., "l_lumerical Studies of Motionand Decay of vortex Filaments," AIAA Journal, 'Col.24,No. 8, August 1986,pp. 1290-1297.
  26. Liu, C. H., Krause,E. and "I'nag, L., "Vortex- Dominated Flow with Viscous Core Structure," AIAA 85-1556,invited paper, July1985.
  27. Greene,G. C.,"An ApproximateModel of Vortex Decay intheAtmosphere," Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 23,No. 7,July1986,pp. 566-573.
  28. Greene,G. C.,Lamar,J.E. and Kubendran, L. R., "Aircraft Vortices: Juncture, Wing and Wake," A/AA 88--3743, July 1988.
  29. Kandil, O. A., Wung, 1".C. and Liu, C. H., "Analysis and Computations of Trailing Vortices and their Haz- ardous Effects," WAKE VORTEX SYMPOSIUM, FAA, Washington, D.C., October 1991.
  30. Cebeci, T., "C.alculat/un of Compressible Turbu- lent BoundaryLayers with heat and Mass Transfer," AIAA Paper 70-741, June 1970.
  31. Baldwin, B. S. and Lomax, H., "Whin-LayerApproxi- mation and Algebraic Model for Separated Turbulent Flows," AIAA Paper 78-257, January 1978.
  32. Wong, T. C. Kandil, O. A. and Liu, C. H., '`Navier- Stokes Computations of Separated Vortical Flows Past Prolate Sphen3id at Incidence," AIAA 89--0553, January 1989.
  33. Kandil, O. A., Kandil, H. A. and Liu, C. H., "Su- personic Quasi-Axisymmetrie Vortex Breakdown," AIAA 91-3311-CP, Sept. 1991, Vol. 1I, pp.
  34. Yip, L. P. and Shubert, G. L., "Pressure Distributions on a I-By 3-Meter Semispan Wing at Sweep Angles from 0°-.40 °in Subsonic Flow." NASA TN D-8307, December 1976.
  35. I. Kandil,O. A.,Wong, T-C. and Liu,C. H.,'Prediction of Steady and Unsteady Asymmetric VorticalFlow Around Cones," AIAA 90-0598, 1990. Also in AlAA Journal, Vol. 29, No. 12, pp. 1269-1278, 1991.
  36. Kandil, O. A., Wong, T-C. and Liu, C. H., "Asym- metric Flow Around Cone,s with Noncircular Sec- tions," AGARD Symposium on Missile Aerodynam- ics, AGARD CP No. 493, Friedrickshafen, Germany, pp. 16.1-16.11, 1990.
  37. Kandil, O. A., Wong, T-C. and Liu, C. H., "Numerical Simulation of Steady and Unsteady Asymmetric Vor- tical Flows," ASME Symposium on Non-Steady Fluid Dynamics, FED-Vol. 92, Toronto, Canada, pp. 99- 108, 1990. To appear in the Journal of Fluids and Structures, 1991.
  38. Kand/l, O. A., Wong, T-C., Kandil, H., A. and Liu, C. H., "Computation and Control of Asymmetric Vor- tex Flow Armmd Circular Cones Using Navier-Stokes Equations,"ICAS Paper No. 3.5.3,Vol. 2, Stock- holm, Sweden, pp. 883--893,1990.
  39. Kandil, O. A., Wong, T-C., Kandil, H. A. and Liu, C. H., "Thin-Layer and Full Navier-Smkes, Locally- Conical and Three-Dimensional Asymmetric
  40. Solu- tions," AIAA 91--0547, 1991.
  41. Stab1, W., "SuPl_e_on of Asymmetry of Vortex Flow Behind a Circular Cone at High Incidence," Pro- ceedings of the AIAA Atmesphcric Flight Mechan- ics Conference, Boston, MA, AIAA 39-3372-CP, pp. 231-236, 1989.
  42. Ng, T. T., "On Leading Edge Vortex and Its Con- Urol," Proceedingsof the AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Boston, MA, AIAA 89-3346- CP, pp. 1-15, 1989.
  43. Moskovitz, C., Hall, R. and DeJmwaxe, "Experimen- tal Investigation of a New Device to Control the
  44. Asymmetric Flowtield on Forehodies at Large Angles of Attack," ALKA 90-0069, 1990.
  45. Skow, A. M. and Peake, D. J.,"Contm4 of the F, om- body Vo_,x Orientationby Asymmetric Air Injec- tion, (Part B) --Details of the Flow Structure," AGARD-LS-121, High Angle-of-Attack Aerodynam- ics, pp. 10.1-10.22, 1982.
  46. Ng, T. T., Suarez, C. J. and Malcolm, N., "Forebody Vortex ControlUsing SlotBlowing," Proceedingsof the AIAA 9th Applied Aerodynamics Conference, Baltimore,Maryland, AIAA 91-3254-CP, pp. 412- 421, 1991.
  47. II. Gitmcr, M. N. and Chokani, N., "An Experimental Study of the Effectsof Aft Blowing on a 3.0 Cal- iberTangent Ogive Body at High Angles of Attack," Proceedings of the AIAA 9th Applied Aerodynam- ics Confczence, Baltimore, Maryland, AIAA 91-3252- CP, pp. 390-399, 1991.
  48. Font, G. I., Celik, Z. Z. and Roberts, L., "A Numer- ical and Experimental Study of Tangential Jet Blow- ing Applied to Bodies at High Angles of A_ack," Proceedings of the AIAA 9th Applied Aerodynam- ics Confen_r,e,Baltimore, Maryland, A/AA 91-3253- CP, pp. 400-411, 1991.
  49. Ng, T. T., "Aerodynamic Control of NASP-Type Ve- hicles Through Vortex Manipulation," AIAA 90-0594, 1990.
  50. Tavell& D. A., Schiff, L. B. and Cummings, R. M., "Pneumatic Vortical Flow Control at High Angles of Attack," AIAA 90-0098, 1990.
  51. Gee, K., Tavella, D. and Schiff, L. S., "Comptuta- tional Olzimization of a Pneumatic Forebody Flow Control Concept," Proceedings of the AIAA 9th Ap- plied Aerodynamics Confez'ence, Baltimore, Mary- land, AIAA 91-3249-CP, pp. 370-380, 1991.
  52. Grabowski, W. J. and Berger, S, A., "Solutions of the Navier-Stokes Equations for Vortex Breakdown," Journal of Fluid Mechanics, Vol. 75, Part 3, 1976, pp. 525-544.
  53. Hafez, M., Kuruvila, G. and Salas, M. D., "Numeri- cal Study of Vortex Breakdown," Journal of Applied Numerical Mathematics, No. 2, 1987, pp. 291-302.
  54. Salas, M. D. and Kuruvila, G,. "Vortex Breakdown Simulation" A Circumspect Study of the Steady, Lam- inar, Axisymmetric Model," Computers and Fluids, Vol. 17, No. I, 1989, pp. 247-262.
  55. Menne, S., "Vortex Breakdown in an Axisymmetric Flow," AlAA 88-0506, January 1988.
  56. Wu, J. C. and Hwang, S., "Computational Study of Vortex Breakdown in Circular Tube," AIA.A 91-1820, June 1991.
  57. Menne, S. and Liu, C. H., "Numerical Simulation of a Three-Dimensional Vortex Breakdown," Z. Flugwiss.
  58. Weltraumforsch. 14, 1990, pp. 301-308.
  59. Spall, R. E., Gatski, T. B. and Ash, R. L., "The Structur and Dynamics of Bubble-Type Vortex Break- down," Proc. R. Soc., London, A429, 1990, pp. 613- 637.
  60. Breuer, M. and Hand, D., "Solution of the 3-D In- compressible Navier-Stokes Equations for the Simu- lation of Vortex Breakdown," Eight GAMM Confer- ence, Delft, Netherlands, September 27-29, 1989.
  61. Krause, E., "Vortex Breakdown: Physical Issues and Computational Simulation," Third International Con- gress of Fluid Mechanics, Cairo, Egypt, Janury 1990, Voi. 1, pp. 335-344.
  62. Krause, E., "The Solution of the Problem of Vortex Breakdown," Invited paper, International Conference on Numerical Methods for Fluid Dynamics, Oxford, England, June 1990.
  63. Delery, J., Homwitz, E., Leuchter, O. and Solignac, J. L., "Fundamental Studies of Vortex Flows," La Recherche A_xospatiale, No. 1984-2, 1984, pp. 1-24.
  64. Metwally, O., Settles, G. and Horstman, C., "An Experimentally Study of Shock Wave/Vortex Interac- tion," AIAA 89-0082, January 1989.
  65. Cutler, A.D .rod Levey, B. S., "'Vortex Breakdown in a Supersonic Jet," AIAA 91-1815, June 1991.
  66. Rhode, D. L., Lilley, D. G. and McLaughlin, D. K., "On the Prediction of Swirling Flowfields Found in Axisymmetrie Combustor Geomeu'ies," Transactions of ASME, Vol. I04, September 1982, pp. 378-384.
  67. Altegeld, H., Jones, W. P. and Wilhelmi, "Velocity Measurements in a Confined Swirl Driven Recircu- lating Flow," Experiments in Fluids, Springer Verlag, Vol. I, 1983, pp. 73-78.
  68. Liu, C. H., Krause, E. and Menne, S., "Admissible Upstream Conditions for Slender Compressible Vor- tices," AIAA 86-1093, 1986.
  69. Copening, G. and Anderson, J., "Numerical Solutions to Three-Dimensional Shock/Vortex Interaction at Hy- personic Speeds," AIAA 89-0674, January 1989.
  70. Kandil, O. A. and Kandil, H. A., "Computation of Compressible Quasi-Axisymmetrie Slender Vor- tex Flow and Breakdown," IMACS 1st International Conference on Computational Physics, University of Colorado, Boulder, June 1990, pp. 46-51. Also in Computer Physics Communications, Vol. 65, North- Holland, March 1991, pp. 164-172.
  71. Meadows, K., Kumar, A. and Hussaini, M., "A Com- putational Study on the Interaction Between a Vortex and a Shock Wave," AIAA 89-1043, April 1989.'
  72. Kandil, O. A., Kandil, H._I. and Liu, C. H., "Compu- tation of Steady and Unsteady Compressible Quasi- Axisymmetrie Vortex Flow and Breakdown," AIAA 91-0752, January 1991.
  73. Kandil, O. A., Kandil, H. A. and Liu, C. H., "Su- personic Quasi-Axisymmetric Vtme.x Breakdown," AIAA 91-3311-CP, September 1991, pp. 851-863.