CAD systems and the division of labour in knitwear design
1994
Abstract
The design of knitted garments is an activity shared by knitwear designers (who are almost all young and female) and knitting machine technicians (who are almost all male and usually older). The process involves programming knitting machines using CAD systems, which are designed for and used by the technicians. The designers get much less training and access to the CAD systems than they want. This paper examines why this is, and what would be involved in creating a situation where the designers are empowered over the technology of knitwear design. It concludes that the limitations of the technology cause this situation, which is reinforced by economic and attitudinal factors.
References (26)
- AITKENHEAD, M. and LIFF, S. (1991) 'The effectiveness of equal oportunity policies' in J. FIRTH-COZENS and M.A. WEST (Eds) Women at work, Milton Keynes, Open University Press.
- ALBAN-METCALF, B. and WEST, M. (1991) 'Woman managers' in J. FIRTH-COZENS and M.A. WEST (Eds) Women at work, Milton Keynes, Open University Press.
- ASHBY, C. (1992) 'Design by Software' in W. ALDRICH (Ed) CAD in clothing and textiles: a collection of expert views, Oxford, BSP Professional.
- BIJL, A. (1989) Computer Discipline and Design Practice, Edinburgh, Edinburgh University Press.
- BURCE, M. and LEWIS, J. (1990) 'Women designers -is there a gender trap?', Design Studies, 11, pp. 114-120.
- CASSELL, C. (1991) 'A woman's place is at the word processor: technology and change in the office' in J. FIRTH-COZENS and M.A. WEST (Eds) Women at work, Milton Keynes, Open University Press.
- COCKBURN, C. (1985) Machinery of Dominance, London, Pluto Press.
- COLWILL, G. and JOSEPHSON, W.L. (1983) 'Attitudes towards equal opportunity in employment: the case of one government department', Business Quarterly, 48, pp. 87-93.
- DEVANE, J. (1992) 'Training and Eduction in CAD clothing/ textile systems', in W. ALDRICH (Ed) CAD in clothing and textiles: a collection of expert views, Oxford, BSP Professional.
- ECKERT, C. and MURRAY, B.M. (1993) CAD/CAM for Knitwear Design and Development: User Study, ACME Grant GR/J40331 D1-Report. Loughborough, LUTCHI.
- GREENO, J. G. (1980) 'Trends in the theory of knowledge for problem solving' in D.T. TUMA and R. REIF (Eds), Problem solving and education: Issues in teaching and learning, Hillsdale, NJ, Lawrence Erlbaum.
- HAMMOND, V. (1986) 'Management training for women', Journal of European Industrial Training, 10 , pp. 15 -22.
- HEWSON, R. (1994) Making and marking: how typographic designers use sketches. Ph.D. Thesis, Institute of Educational Technology, The Open University.
- HUDSON, L. (1966) Contrary Imaginations, London, Methuen.
- HUDSON, L. (1968) Frames of Mind, London, Methuen.
- LIU, Y. (1991) 'Schematic-Designer: a knowledge-based CAD system for schematic design in architecture', Design Studies, 12, pp. 151-167.
- LOCKWOOD, E. and KNOWLES, W. (1984) 'Women at Work in Great Britain', in M.J. DAVIDSON and C.L. COOPER (Eds) Working Women, Chichester, John Wiley.
- PERKINS, D. (1981) 'The mind's best work', Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press.
- RUBERY J., HUMPHRIES J. and HORRELL S. (1992) 'Women's Employment in Textiles and Clothing' in R.M. LINDLEY (Ed) Women's Employment: Britain in the Single European Market, London, HMSO.
- SCRIVENER, S.A.R., CLARK, S.M., CLARKE, A., CONNOLLY, J., GARNER, S., PALMEN, H., SMYTH, M. and SCHAPPO, A. (1993)'Real-time Communication Between Dispersed Work Groups via Speech and Drawing', Wirtshaftsinformatik, 35, pp. 149-156.
- TOVEY, M. (1989) 'Drawing and CAD in industrial design', Design Studies, 10, pp. 24-39.
- TOVEY, M. (1992) 'Intuitive and objective processes in automotive design', Design Studies, 13, pp. 23-41.
- WADDELL, G. (1992) 'CAD for clothing and textiles' in W. ALDRICH (Ed) CAD in clothing and textiles: a collection of expert views, Oxford, BSP Professional.
- WEBB, J. (1991) 'The gender relation of assessment' in J. FIRTH-COZENS and M.A. WEST (Eds) Women at work, Milton Keynes, Open University Press.
- WEISBERG, R. W.(1986) Creativity, Genius and other myths, New York, NY, Freeman.
- WEISBERG, R. W.(1988) Problem solving and creativity, In R.J. STERNBERG (Ed) The Nature of Creativity, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.