Positivism, Post-Positivism, and Intelligence Analysis
International Journal of Intelligence and CounterIntelligence, 2013
In recent years, the Intelligence Community has been rather infatuated with positivist social sci... more In recent years, the Intelligence Community has been rather infatuated with positivist social science. Analysts like Stephen Marrin and Gregory Treverton have suggested that the best way for practitioners to reform intelligence analysis (and indeed the whole intelligence cycle) is to borrow positivist methodologies such as evidence-based practices and hypothesis testing from academic scientists and social scientists. Here, analysts seem particularly drawn to making analogies with the medical profession. The constraints which practitioners face and the methodologies they use in making an assessment or diagnosis are frequently compared. For example, Gary McClelland noted that:
Uploads
Books by Mary Manjikian
This work breaks new ground through using the lens of security to examine property squatting – which has thus far been considered either as an economic externality or a social problem. In this work, I argue that developments within the EU – including terrorist attacks in London and Madrid, the rise of right wing extremist parties and the lifting of barriers to immigration and travel within the EU – have had effects on housing policy, which has become the subject of state security policy in Europe’s urban areas. Housing is not merely about having a place to live – but about state pressures to conform, norms and policies regarding citizenship and about practices of surveillance and security.
Apocalyptic concepts provide a way for contemporary Americans to view the international system from below: from the perspective of those who are powerless rather than those who are powerful. This sort of theorizing is also useful for intelligence analysts who question how it all will end, and whether America’s decline can be predicted or prevented.
Show More
Show Less
Show More
Show Less
Papers by Mary Manjikian