Penn State University
Advertising and Public Relations
On a basic level, perception of user control over media content should be partially a function of control option availability. At the same time, prior user experience with control options should interact with control availability to... more
On a basic level, perception of user control over media content should be partially a function of control option availability. At the same time, prior user experience with control options should interact with control availability to produce joint effects on control perception. To assess these ideas, we present experimental data from 101 University students in the United States. Participants engaged a documentary in one of three ways: by simply watching the documentary, by watching the documentary with the option of using typical VCR-type controls (such as fast-forward or reverse), or by watching and having available both VCR-type controls and scene sequencing control. Data support our hypotheses. While there was a generally positive relationship between exposure to user control options and user control perception across all participants, those participants with relatively less prior experience with Internet-based applications demonstrated a somewhat different relationship between control availability and control perception.
Purpose – This paper aims to report a qualitative investigation of perceptions of climate change among young South Koreans to illustrate the benefits of complementary qualitative approaches. Successful marketing communication campaigns... more
Purpose – This paper aims to report a qualitative investigation of perceptions of climate change among young South Koreans to illustrate the benefits of complementary qualitative approaches. Successful marketing communication campaigns require a thorough assessment of the public’s current perceptions and attitudes toward the topic of the campaign. Such insights are most likely attained if a range of research methods are used. However, in the area of pro-environmental campaigns, there has been an over-reliance on quantitative surveys.
Design/methodology/approach – The study employed a variant of the Zaltman Metaphor
Elicitation Technique (ZMET), a hybrid protocol which combines photo elicitation with metaphor analysis of subsequent in-depth individual interviews. Unlike survey research, ZMET uncovers the emotional, interpretive and sensory mental structures which, along with factual knowledge, make up the public mindset about climate change.
Findings – The analysis revealed a multifaceted mental model of climate change, whereby factual, interpretive and emotional knowledge is organized around themes of loss, human greed, affective distress and iconic representations of tragic endings. The causal dynamics of climate change are construed along a continuum of psychological distance, with antecedents placed in proximity and effects assigned to distant temporal, geographical and psychological spaces.
Practical implications – Four message strategies for climate change mitigation campaigns are identified based on the findings.
Originality/value – The study makes a methodological argument for supplementing survey research with image-based qualitative investigations in the formative stages of pro-environmental campaigns. More specifically, the article demonstrates the applicability of ZMET to social marketing communication. Apart from the methodological implications, this appears to be the first in-depth qualitative investigation of public perceptions of climate change in East Asia, a populous and fast developing region which has become a major contributor to the world’s carbon emissions, and an important player in the global effort toward mitigation.
Keywords Climate change, Communication, South Korea, Qualitative, Social marketing, ZMET,
Public mindset
Design/methodology/approach – The study employed a variant of the Zaltman Metaphor
Elicitation Technique (ZMET), a hybrid protocol which combines photo elicitation with metaphor analysis of subsequent in-depth individual interviews. Unlike survey research, ZMET uncovers the emotional, interpretive and sensory mental structures which, along with factual knowledge, make up the public mindset about climate change.
Findings – The analysis revealed a multifaceted mental model of climate change, whereby factual, interpretive and emotional knowledge is organized around themes of loss, human greed, affective distress and iconic representations of tragic endings. The causal dynamics of climate change are construed along a continuum of psychological distance, with antecedents placed in proximity and effects assigned to distant temporal, geographical and psychological spaces.
Practical implications – Four message strategies for climate change mitigation campaigns are identified based on the findings.
Originality/value – The study makes a methodological argument for supplementing survey research with image-based qualitative investigations in the formative stages of pro-environmental campaigns. More specifically, the article demonstrates the applicability of ZMET to social marketing communication. Apart from the methodological implications, this appears to be the first in-depth qualitative investigation of public perceptions of climate change in East Asia, a populous and fast developing region which has become a major contributor to the world’s carbon emissions, and an important player in the global effort toward mitigation.
Keywords Climate change, Communication, South Korea, Qualitative, Social marketing, ZMET,
Public mindset
Marketers often use incentives such as coupons, rewards or special membership discounts in order to motivate consumers to purchase or recommend a particular brand. This practice is based on the underlying assumption that an increase in... more
Marketers often use incentives such as coupons, rewards or special membership discounts in order to motivate consumers to purchase or recommend a particular brand. This practice is based on the underlying assumption that an increase in incentives will lead to an increase in consumer response – an idea which has been at the core of traditional economic thinking for decades. Some psychologists have claimed, however, that under specific conditions an increase in incentives can reduce (rather than increase) one's willingness to perform the behavior which is being incentivized. If materialized, the possibility that extrinsic incentives may diminish consumer willingness to recommend a favorite brand could have important theoretical and practical consequences in the context of word-of-mouth or buzz marketing. This study tests that possibility in the context of an experiment about Apple computers, a favorite brand among US college students. Participants were asked to recommend the brand to a friend (1) in absence of any monetary reward and (2) for a small monetary incentive. Students who were promised a small monetary reward experienced a decrease in intrinsic motivation and wrote shorter recommendations than those who were not promised any incentives. Data also suggest that the quality of the recommendation may decrease when incentives are offered. The results are discussed in line of their possible theoretical and practical significance.
Purpose -The effectiveness of social marketing communication should depend both on message features and on the psychological characteristics of message recipients. This premise was tested in an experiment focused on why consumers may... more
Purpose -The effectiveness of social marketing communication should depend both on message features and on the psychological characteristics of message recipients. This premise was tested in an experiment focused on why consumers may respond differently to different types of pro-recycling advertisements. The message feature was the way in which the advertisements were framed. The psychological characteristic of the message recipient was the respondent's mood. The paper aims to discuss these issues. Design/methodology/approach -Hypotheses were tested in the context of an experiment focused on paper recycling. Findings -It was hypothesized that congruity between mood and the frame of the message would result in more favorable message evaluations and higher intentions to recycle than incongruity. Supporting the study's hypotheses, the data showed that participants in a negative mood had higher intentions to recycle paper and evaluated pro-recycling advertisements more favorably when the ads emphasized avoiding negative consequences as opposed to attaining desired benefits. Among participants in a positive mood, desired benefit advertisements induced higher intentions to recycle paper and were evaluated more favorably than advertisements framed in terms of avoiding negative consequences. Practical implications -A clear message placement strategy is suggested to increase the effectiveness of social marketing communication campaigns. Originality/value -This mood congruity effect has not been reported before in the context of pro-environmental communication. Furthermore, the study provides empirical evidence of the underlying psychological mechanisms that cause the observed interaction. The evidence suggests the data could be predictive of similar response patterns in other social marketing communication domains (e.g. in response to health messages, volunteering, charity, etc.).
While mood has been found to affect brand extension evaluations, the specific mechanisms by which it affects those evaluations remain largely untested. This study suggests that mood-induced differences in cognitive processing style... more
While mood has been found to affect brand extension evaluations,
the specific mechanisms by which it affects those evaluations remain
largely untested. This study suggests that mood-induced differences
in cognitive processing style (relational vs. item-specific elaboration)
are possible explanations affecting brand extension evaluations.
Results of two experiments showed that consumers in a positive (vs.
negative) mood engaged in relational (vs. item-specific) elaboration
and consequently evaluated brand extensions and brand extension
fit more favorably than consumers in a negative mood. The effects
were found immediately after exposure (Experiment 1) and after a
one-week delay (Experiment 2). Theoretical and practical implications are discussed.
the specific mechanisms by which it affects those evaluations remain
largely untested. This study suggests that mood-induced differences
in cognitive processing style (relational vs. item-specific elaboration)
are possible explanations affecting brand extension evaluations.
Results of two experiments showed that consumers in a positive (vs.
negative) mood engaged in relational (vs. item-specific) elaboration
and consequently evaluated brand extensions and brand extension
fit more favorably than consumers in a negative mood. The effects
were found immediately after exposure (Experiment 1) and after a
one-week delay (Experiment 2). Theoretical and practical implications are discussed.
- by Brittany Duff and +1
- •
- Emotion, Brand Management, Brand equity, Affect/Emotion
Multitasking with media is increasing. This shift in media consumption presents challenges to advertising practitioners and researchers because it may affect people's attention, perception, and memory for advertising contained in those... more
Multitasking with media is increasing. This shift in media consumption presents challenges to advertising practitioners and researchers because it may affect people's attention, perception, and memory for advertising contained in those media. However, while audience multitasking behavior has recently received increased attention, the individual predictors of media multitasking are underexplored. To better understand the audience factors associated with heavy media multitasking we conducted a survey with samples from a student population (N = 308) and a national consumer population (N = 501). Age and gender were significant predictors only in the national sample, while personal control and need for simplicity were predictors only in the student sample. Results also indicated that sensation seeking and creativity were significant predictors of multitasking in both samples. Interestingly for advertisers, increased perception of advertising utility was also a predictor of multitasking in both the student and national sample.
- by George Anghelcev and +1
- •
- Marketing, Interactive Advertising
Most health communication research is grounded in theories of rational human behavior, which emphasize the role of cognition in health-related decision making. The role of affect-particularly pre-exposure mood-as a determinant of... more
Most health communication research is grounded in theories of rational human behavior, which emphasize the role of cognition in health-related decision making. The role of affect-particularly pre-exposure mood-as a determinant of responses to health campaigns is underexplored. Using experimental data, the present study describes variations in attitudinal and behavioral responses to health communication as a function of preexisting mood (positive/negative), message relevance (high/low), and health message type (prevention/detection). Data show that message relevance moderated the effects of health message type under positive, but not under negative, mood.
Purpose -The aim of the paper is to investigate the impact of pre-existing audience mood on responses to health public service advertisements (PSAs). The paper also aims to show the practical and theoretical importance of mood as a... more
Purpose -The aim of the paper is to investigate the impact of pre-existing audience mood on responses to health public service advertisements (PSAs). The paper also aims to show the practical and theoretical importance of mood as a variable in health communication. Design/methodology/approach -Hypotheses regarding the impact of audience mood on the outcome of health PSAs were tested experimentally using health PSAs about vaccination and virus detection behaviors. Findings -The influence of pre-existing mood was mediated by the perceived risk of contracting the illness mentioned in the health advertisement. Personal estimations of risk mediated the impact of audience mood on behavioral intent and actual behavior. The more negative one's mood, the higher the perceived risk of contracting the disease mentioned in the message, and the more likely one was to adopt the precautionary behavior recommended by the PSA. Positive mood had opposite effects. Practical implications -The findings suggest a novel media planning approach to maximizing the effectiveness of health risk messages. Due to the impact of context-induced mood on perceptions of risk, messages could be more effective if placed in editorial contexts which induce negative mood (e.g. crime investigation reports) versus environments which induce positive mood (e.g. sitcoms), because negative mood makes people think they are more at risk and motivates them to act. Originality/value -The mood-and-risk mediation hypothesis proposed here has never been examined in public health marketing. Findings call for further research on the impact of contextual affect on responses to public health communication. The paper suggests a new placement technique for media planners working in public health advertising.
Alcohol-impaired driving (AID) has devastating effects on society. To decrease the incidence of AID, high-risk populations like college students are often targeted by anti-AID advertising campaigns. The present study examines the... more
Alcohol-impaired driving (AID) has devastating effects on society. To decrease the incidence of AID, high-risk populations like college students are often targeted by anti-AID advertising campaigns. The present study examines the effectiveness of anti-AID advertisements as a function of pre-existing audience mood. Two experiments showed that congruity between the mood of the audience (positive, negative) and the regulatory focus of the ad (promotion, prevention) can increase advertising effectiveness. Positive mood enhanced the effectiveness of promotion-framed ads, whereas negative mood enhanced the effectiveness of prevention-framed ads. The effects were attributable to differential engagement in global or local processing. Positive mood induced a tendency to engage in global processing, and negative mood fostered engagement in local processing. Theoretical contributions are considered along with actionable recommendations for the creators of anti-AID advertising campaigns.
- by George Anghelcev and +1
- •
- Marketing
Using motivation crowding theory, the study examined the possibility that low monetary incentives may reduce (rather than increase) students’ motivation to volunteer as mentors, compared to situations when no incentives are offered. Data... more
Using motivation crowding theory, the study examined the possibility that low monetary
incentives may reduce (rather than increase) students’ motivation to volunteer as mentors, compared to situations when no incentives are offered. Data from an experiment supported this counter-intuitive proposition. Advertising students exposed to an ad promising a small monetary reward experienced a significant drop in intrinsic motivation and were overall less likely to volunteer as peer mentors than those exposed to an ad promising no reward. The impact of high incentives on motivation was studied also. Students exposed to an ad that promised a large monetary reward were more likely to volunteer than the low incentive and no-incentive groups, but their intrinsic motivation to help was replaced by the desire for monetary gain. The study has theoretical and practical implications for the use of incentives in advertising education to promote peer mentorship and for motivating volunteers in general.
incentives may reduce (rather than increase) students’ motivation to volunteer as mentors, compared to situations when no incentives are offered. Data from an experiment supported this counter-intuitive proposition. Advertising students exposed to an ad promising a small monetary reward experienced a significant drop in intrinsic motivation and were overall less likely to volunteer as peer mentors than those exposed to an ad promising no reward. The impact of high incentives on motivation was studied also. Students exposed to an ad that promised a large monetary reward were more likely to volunteer than the low incentive and no-incentive groups, but their intrinsic motivation to help was replaced by the desire for monetary gain. The study has theoretical and practical implications for the use of incentives in advertising education to promote peer mentorship and for motivating volunteers in general.
An experiment was conducted to investigate the effects of attentional focus on viewers' evaluation of TV commercials. A positive relationship was hypothesized between a commercial's congruity with viewers' attentional focus and viewers'... more
An experiment was conducted to investigate the effects of attentional focus on viewers' evaluation of TV commercials. A positive relationship was hypothesized between a commercial's congruity with viewers' attentional focus and viewers' evaluation of the commercial. The data supported the study hypotheses. Two sets of commercials were evaluated more favorably under congruity (vs. incongruity) between the executional style of the commercials and participants' cognitive or affective attentional focus (induced by the television program in which the ads were embedded and by specific instructions). The study helps address inconsistencies in the literature though methodological improvements over previous research, aimed at maximizing internal validity. Implications for theory and practice are discussed.
- by George Anghelcev and +1
- •
Brand zealotry was defined as a specialized form of opinion leadership. Brand zealots are consumers who frequently engage in brand-related opinion leadership, report high interest in identifying the best brands to buy, and regularly... more
Brand zealotry was defined as a specialized form of opinion leadership. Brand zealots are consumers who frequently engage in brand-related opinion leadership, report high interest in identifying the best brands to buy, and regularly purchase the brand name products they favor. The concept was operationalized by means of an index of the propensity to engage in brand zealotry. Brand zealotry was found to be associated with the demographic factors such as younger and higher income consumers. Certain personality characteristics and media preferences pointed to the possibility that brand zealots are discerning consumers who rely on information provided in advertising and on the Internet.
This research examines the impact of Web-based anthropomorphic agents on consumers' attitudes toivard the Web site and the brand, with particular focus on two mediating factors. An experiment found that the presence {versus absence) of an... more
This research examines the impact of Web-based anthropomorphic agents on consumers' attitudes toivard the Web site and the brand, with particular focus on two mediating factors. An experiment found that the presence {versus absence) of an anthropomorphic agefit led to significantly more favorable attitudes toward the Web site, buf had ininimum influence on attitudes toward the brand. In addition, the influence of the ngent on attitudes toivard the Web site was mediated by perceived credibility of the Web site and positive emotional responses.
This research examines the impact of Web-based anthropomorphic agents on consumers' attitudes toivard the Web site and the brand, with particular focus on two mediating factors. An experiment found that the presence {versus absence) of an... more
This research examines the impact of Web-based anthropomorphic agents on consumers' attitudes toivard the Web site and the brand, with particular focus on two mediating factors. An experiment found that the presence {versus absence) of an anthropomorphic agefit led to significantly more favorable attitudes toward the Web site, buf had ininimum influence on attitudes toward the brand. In addition, the influence of the ngent on attitudes toivard the Web site was mediated by perceived credibility of the Web site and positive emotional responses.
Most health communication research is grounded in theories of rational human behavior, which emphasize the role of cognition in health-related decision making. The role of affect-particularly pre-exposure mood-as a deterrninant of... more
Most health communication research is grounded in theories of rational human behavior, which emphasize the role of cognition in health-related decision making. The role of affect-particularly pre-exposure mood-as a deterrninant of responses to health campaigns is underexplored. Using experimental data, the present study describes variations in attitudinal arid behavioral responses to health communication as a function of preexisting mood (positive/negative), message relevance (high/low), and health message type (prevention/detection). Data show that message relevance moderated the effects of health message type under positive, but not under negative, mood.
Brand zealotry was defined as a specialized form of opinion leadership. Brand zealots are consumers who frequently engage in brand-related opinion leadership, report high interest in identifying the best brands to buy, and regularly... more
Brand zealotry was defined as a specialized form of opinion leadership. Brand zealots are consumers who frequently engage in brand-related opinion leadership, report high interest in identifying the best brands to buy, and regularly purchase the brand name products they favor. The concept was operationalized by means of an index of the propensity to engage in brand zealotry. Brand zealotry was found to be associated with the demographic factors such as younger and higher income consumers. Certain personality characteristics and media preferences pointed to the possibility that brand zealots are discerning consumers who rely on information provided in advertising and on the Internet.
An experiment was conducted to investigate the effects of attentional focus on viewers' evaluation of TV commercials. A positive relationship was hypothesized between a commercial's congruity with viewers' attentional focus and viewers'... more
An experiment was conducted to investigate the effects of attentional focus on viewers' evaluation of TV commercials. A positive relationship was hypothesized between a commercial's congruity with viewers' attentional focus and viewers' evaluation of the commercial. The data supported the study hypotheses. Two sets of commercials were evaluated more favorably under congruity (vs. incongruity) between the executional style of the commercials and participants' cognitive or affective attentional focus (induced by the television program in which the ads were embedded and by specific instructions). The study helps address inconsistencies in the literature though methodological improvements over previous research, aimed at maximizing internal validity. Implications for theory and practice are discussed.
- by George Anghelcev and +1
- •
Multitasking with media is increasing. This shift in media consumption presents challenges to advertising practitioners and researchers because it may affect people’s attention, perception, and memory for advertising contained in those... more
Multitasking with media is increasing. This shift in media consumption presents challenges to advertising practitioners and researchers because it may affect people’s attention, perception, and memory for advertising contained in those media. However, while audience multitasking behavior has recently received increased attention, the individual predictors of media multitasking are under explored. To better understand the audience factors associated with heavy media multitasking we conducted a survey with samples from a student population (N = 308) and a national consumer population (N = 501). Age and gender were significant predictors only in the national sample, while personal control and need for simplicity were predictors only in the student sample. Results also indicated that sensation seeking and creativity were significant predictors of multitasking in both samples. Interestingly for advertisers, increased perception of advertising utility was also a predictor of multitasking in both the student and national sample.
- by Brittany Duff and +2
- •
Esta es la traducción al español de un artículo publicado originalmente en inglés. Para citar, por favor utilice lo siguiente: Anghelcev, George y otros: "A ZMET-based Resumen Propósito: este documento tiene como objetivo informar de la... more
Esta es la traducción al español de un artículo publicado originalmente en inglés. Para citar, por favor utilice lo siguiente: Anghelcev, George y otros: "A ZMET-based Resumen Propósito: este documento tiene como objetivo informar de la investigación cualitativa sobre las percepciones que existen entre los jóvenes surcoreanos acerca del cambio climático, para ilustrar los beneficios de los enfoques cualitativos complementarios. Las campañas de comunicación de márketing exitosas requieren de una evaluación exhaustiva de las percepciones y actitudes actuales del público hacia el tema de la campaña. Es muy probable que se obtengan estos conocimientos si se utilizan diversos métodos de investigación; sin embargo, en el ámbito de las campañas a favor del medio ambiente, ha existido una dependencia excesiva de las encuestas cuantitativas. Diseño / metodología / enfoque: el estudio empleó una variante de la Técnica Zaltman de Investigación por Metáforas (ZMET, por sus siglas en inglés), un protocolo híbrido que combina fotografías con las metáforas que se obtienen del análisis de esas imágenes en una entrevista más posterior más profunda. A diferencia de la investigación de encuestas, la ZMET destapa las estructuras mentales emocionales, interpretativas y sensoriales que, junto con el conocimiento fáctico, conforman la mentalidad pública sobre el cambio climático. Hallazgos: el análisis reveló un modelo mental multifacético del cambio climático, por el que el conocimiento fáctico, interpretativo y emocional se organiza en torno a temas de pérdida, codicia humana, angustia afectiva y representaciones icónicas de finales trágicos. Las dinámicas causales del cambio climático se construyen a lo largo de un continuo psicológico de distancia, con los antecedentes colocados en la proximidad, y los efectos asignados a espacios temporales, geográficos y psicológicos, a lo lejos. Implicaciones prácticas: se identifican cuatro estrategias de mensajes para las campañas de mitigación del cambio climático con base en los hallazgos. Originalidad/valor: el estudio presenta un argumento metodológico para complementar la investigación mediante encuestas con investigaciones cualitativas basadas en imágenes en las etapas formativas de campañas ambientalistas. Más específicamente, el artículo demuestra la aplicabilidad de la ZMET a la comunicación de márketing social. Aparte de las implicaciones metodológicas, esta parece ser la primera investigación cualitativa en profundidad de las percepciones públicas del cambio climático en el este de Asia, una región poblada y de rápido desarrollo que se ha convertido en un importante contribuyente a las emisiones de carbono del mundo, y un actor valioso en el esfuerzo global hacia la mitigación de los efectos del fenómeno.
This study examined psychological constructs related to the subjective experience of binge-watching serial video content. The results underscore the centrality of transportation in shaping viewers' perceptions of the binge-watching... more
This study examined psychological constructs related to the subjective experience of binge-watching serial video content. The results underscore the centrality of transportation in shaping viewers' perceptions of the binge-watching experience and their binge-watching behaviors. Transportation was positively related to binge-watching frequency and mediated the impact of binge-watching session length on development of parasocial interactions (full mediation) and on binge-watching enjoyment (partial mediation). Ability to experience flow was found to predict the length of a binge-watching session. Other significant relationships were revealed. Theoretical and practical implications are discussed , along with suggestions for future research and the possibility of expanding current conceptual views of binge-watching.