The Arabian Seas: The Indian Ocean World of the Seventeenth Century (review)
Journal of World History, 2004
nations as an object of philological and, later, historical, study. A reliance on Tacitus’s Germa... more nations as an object of philological and, later, historical, study. A reliance on Tacitus’s Germania as a historiographical model produced problems from the start, according to Geary, because Tacitus relied less on Herodotus (whom Geary sees as a “pre-Orientalist” [p. 47] in his “value-neutral approach to the customs and peoples he observed” [p. 46]) than on Pliny the Elder and the subsequent Christian historiographical tradition that originated with Augustine and Jerome. It is Herodotus’s identification of peoples and tribes based on fluid geographic and cultural distinctions subject to change over time that Geary praises over Pliny’s insistence that peoples possessed eternal, essentially distinguishing characteristics. As well, Geary usefully provides a survey of the breakup of the Roman empire, arguing that this event as crucial to nationalist claims of primary acquisition. Again, he reiterates that historiography is at fault here, especially a narrative historiography that makes the continuity of an ethnic continuity its major theme. As a corrective, Geary disrupts this continuity by demonstrating the fluid nature both of peoples and the geographic territories they occupied. Rather than any real continuous link with the past, Geary posits a nominal one in which, despite “the constant shifting of allegiances, intermarriages, transformations, and appropriations, it appears that all that remained constant were names” (p. 118). Geary thus presents nationalism as a consequence of a production of its objects of study and opposes the position that ethnic groups “exist before intellectuals recognize them” (p. 18). While Geary intends this argument to work against essentialism, he theoretically denies the potential for nationalism to arise from popular sources. Wiebe’s book, then, serves as a productive foil for Geary’s, and vice versa. ernst gerhardt University of Alberta
Uploads
Papers by rene barendse