Book reviews and notices : RAMACHANDRA GUHA, Savaging the civilized: Verrier Elwin, his tribals and India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 1999. 398 pp. Plates, notes, refer ences, appendices, index. Rs. 595 (hardback)
Contributions to Indian Sociology, 2000
The articles by Stanley Tambiah and Lloyd Rudolph address another of Madan’s central concerns, th... more The articles by Stanley Tambiah and Lloyd Rudolph address another of Madan’s central concerns, that is, sociological representation and the problem of reflexivity. Tambiah re-examines Bemier’s text Travels in the Mughal empire, which was a primary source for the representation of oriental despotism for scholars as varied as Montesquieu and Marx. More importantly, he shows that the stereotypical ways of presenting the ’orient’ had a precise political agendait served as a warning to absolutist tendencies in Europe. While restricting himself to a specific historical period, Tambiah’s essay is framed by contemporary sociological concerns about ethnographic representation and its location in colonial structures of power. Colonial structures are not merely experienced as repressive by subject societies, they may also create institutions that generate possibilities for reflexivity and the expression of desire. In a fascinating account of Amar Singh’s diary, Rudolph shows how a Rajput prince is able to use this new genre of writing to reflect critically on his own society. In Rudolph’s account the diary becomes the space for the construction of native ethnography. The book includes a biographical note on T.N. Madan and an introductory essay by Veena Das that not only draws the different themes together and puts them in the framework of Madan’s own intellectual concerns, but also frames
Uploads
Papers by A.R. Vasavi