Sentence Combing Plus (SC+): Its Effects on Students' Writing Quality and Strategy Use. (On-Going Topics)
Academic exchange quarterly, Mar 22, 2002
Abstract The purpose of the present study was to check, on the one hand, whether or not Sentence ... more Abstract The purpose of the present study was to check, on the one hand, whether or not Sentence Combining Plus (SC+) can affect L2 learners' writing performance, and on the other hand, in what type of strategies are learners involved when doing SC+ exercises. Two homogenous groups of sophomore students were randomly assigned to experimental and control groups. The study consisted of two parts. In the first part, the experimental group was exposed to SC+ exercises as treatment and the control group practiced SC (Sentence Combining) only. The results of t-tests revealed that the practice of SC+ caused a significant improvement on the students' writing performance. This improvement was, in particular, evident in the areas of content, organization, and language use. In the second part of the study, ten students--five from the experimental and five from the control group--were randomly selected and studied for the type of strategies they used through introspective interviews. Results of the quantitative and qualitative analyses of the introspective interviews showed that students who had practiced SC+ used more effective strategies. Moreover, they paid more attention to aspects of cohesion and evaluation than did the students from the control group. Based on the findings of the study, we can safely state that the practice of SC+ in intermediate writing courses will improve students' writing skill. An evidence for this, besides students' well performance on a posttest writing task, has been an enhancement of effective strategy use by them. ********** Sentence Combining (SC) and Writing Quality Different techniques have been innovated to help L2 learners to improve their overall writing ability and quality. Sentence combining (SC) is one of these activities. By definition, SC is a technique in which the learner combines basic sentences to produce longer and more complex sentences. Several pieces of research have been done into the effects of SC on L2 learners' writing ability and quality. The results obtained from these bodies of research show that this technique can enhance the quality of learners' writing (see, for example, Miller and Ney, 1967; Combs, 1975; Cooper, 1977, 1981; Klassen, 1977; Daiker et al., 1978; Swan, 1979; Kerek et al., 1980). While these pieces of research show the usefulness of SC technique, other investigations have criticized SC as a legitimate practice in writing classes (see, for example, Zamel, 1980; Crowhurst and Klein, 1983; Holzman, 1983; Enginarlar, 1994). Enginarlar (1994: 217) states the weaknesses of SC as following: Firstly, although they involve some meaning negotiation and composing at sentence level, they are in fact non-rhetorical exercises, removed from the realities of real composing processes. Secondly, in the absence of a context beyond sentence level, as is often the case, the class discussion of various solutions created by students is doomed to be ineffectual. As such, Enginarlar (1994) presents a new form of the older technique. This is Sentence Combining Plus (SC+), which involves not only sentence combining but also ordering jumbled sentences to make meaningful texts. With regard to the type of strategies second language writers use at the time of writing, Johnson (1992) conducted a study on the learning strategies L2 writers used when doing SC tasks. The strategies reported to include: questioning, planning, restating content, constructing meaning, constructing cohesion, and evaluation. The present study intended firstly to investigate whether or not SC+ exercises have any effects on the overall writing ability and quality of L2 learners by testing the following null hypothesis: H0: There is no significant difference between students' quality of writing whether taught by SC+ or SC. The study also attempted to investigate the type of learning strategies the participants used during the completion of SC+ and SC exercises. …
Uploads
Papers by Mehdi Riazi