Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Outline

Discussion: Is the future of fluid power digital?

2012, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part I: Journal of Systems and Control Engineering

https://doi.org/10.1177/0959651812443935

Abstract

Imagine the scenario in which an electric motor company came to the (correct) conclusion that the power density of hydraulic pumps and motors is much higher than that of electric generators and motors. Then imagine that the board of this company gave the (wrong) instruction to the R&D department to utilize the concept of hydrostatic machines to develop electric generators and pumps with the same power density as their hydraulic equivalents. The reasoning of the board parallels the reasoning of the Forward Look article 1 in which Rudolf Scheidl, Matti Linjama and Stefan Schmidt argue that the future of fluid power will become partly digital: ''The overwhelming success of digital concepts in information, communication and power electronics, as well as the analogy between electrical and fluid power systems, suggest that digital concepts should be beneficial in fluid power''. Or, to recast this statement: ''The overwhelming success of feathers for making birds fly, as well as the analogy between birds and fish, suggests that feathers should also be beneficial for fish''. In addition the authors emphasize that ''the positive connotations of the word 'Digital' are good selling points''. Do not be mistaken! I am a strong supporter of research in digital hydraulic systems, although I am not at all convinced that the future of fluid power will be digital. To quote Einstein: ''If at first, the idea is not absurd, then there is no hope for it.'' A lot of research in digital fluid power I consider to fall in the category 'absurd', in the sense of 'out of tune' or 'dissonant' with the ruling technology, and I am very curious to see what will be useful in the end. The idea to copy successful electrical concepts in the design of hydraulic systems and components is as old as the hydraulic industry itself. Examples are 'fluidics' or 'fluidic logics' in which a fluid flow is directed in order to perform analog or digital operations, similar to electronic devices. 2 The authors of the Forward Look article refer to another example, AC hydraulics, in which the principle of a three-phase a.c. network is converted to a three-phase alternating flow network. 3,4 Other examples are 'switched reactance hydraulics' 5 and 'PWM electrohydraulic control systems'. 6 Aside from some niche applications, none of these promising developments has been applied successfully in the market. In 2011, Linjama presented an overview of the stateof-the-art of digital fluid power. 7 In that article he

References (13)

  1. Scheidl R, Linjama M and Schmidt S. Is the future of fluid power digital? Proc IMechE, Part I: J Systems and Control Engineering 2012; 226(6): 721-723.
  2. Henke R. Fluidics and fluid power -impact and implica- tions. In: Proceedings of the national conference on fluid power, 1985, pp.84-98.
  3. Marcu I.L. Functional parameters monitoring for an alternating flow driven hydraulic system. In: Proceedings of the international conference on automation, quality and testing, robotics (AQTR 2008) IEEE, 2008, pp.239-242.
  4. Dantlgraber J. Hydro-transformer. Patent WO 00/08339 (A1), 2000.
  5. Brown FT. Switched reactance hydraulics. In: Proceed- ings of the national conference on fluid power, NFPA, 1987, pp.25-33.
  6. Hanxiu L and Xuli YY. The PWM electrohydraulic control system using a computer. In: Proceedings of the national conference on fluid power, NFPA, 1987, pp.15-23.
  7. Linjama M. Digital fluid power -state of the art. In: Proceedings of the 12th Scandinavian international confer- ence on fluid power, 18-20 May 2011, Tampere, Finland, Vol. 4, pp.331-354. Tampere, Finland: Tampere Univer- sity of Technology.
  8. Wang F, Gu L and Chen Y. (2011) A continuously vari- able hydraulic pressure converter based on high-speed on-off valves. Mechatronics 2011; 21(8): 1298-1308.
  9. Flu¨gge-Lotz I and Taylor CF. (1956) Synthesis of a non- linear control system. In: IRE transactions on automatic control 1, 1956, pp.3-9. New York: IEEE.
  10. Achten P. Horsepower with brains -the design of the CHIRON free piston engine. SAE paper 2000-01-2545, 2000.
  11. Pollard H. Research investigation of hydraulic pulsation concepts. 1963, Defense Technical Information Center.
  12. Republic Aviation Corporation. Final report on the pro- gram for research investigation of hydraulic pulsation concepts, 1964.
  13. Sosnowski T, et al. Pump/motor displacement control using high-speed on/off valves. SAE paper 981968, 1998. P Achten Innas BV, Nikkelstraat 15, 4823AE Breda, The Netherlands. Email: pachten@innas.com