Theory of Fuzzy Sets: Beliefs and Realities
2015
Abstract
On two important counts, the Zadehian theory of fuzzy sets urgently needs to be restructured. First, it can be established that for a normal fuzzy number N = [α, β, γ] with membership function Ψ 1 (x), if α ≤ x ≤ β, Ψ 2 (x), if β ≤ x ≤ γ, and 0, otherwise, Ψ 1 (x) is in fact the distribution function of a random variable defined in the interval [α, β], while Ψ 2 (x) is the complementary distribution function of another random variable defined in the interval [β, γ]. In other words, every normal law of fuzziness can be expressed in terms of two laws of randomness defined in the measure theoretic sense. This is how a normal fuzzy number should be constructed, and this is how partial presence of an element in a fuzzy set has to be defined. Hence the measure theoretic matters with reference to fuzziness have to be studied accordingly. Secondly, the field theoretic matters related to fuzzy sets are required to be revised all over again because in the current definition of the complement of a fuzzy set, fuzzy membership function and fuzzy membership value had been taken to be the same, which led to the conclusion that the fuzzy sets do not follow the set theoretic axioms of exclusion and contradiction. For the complement of a normal fuzzy set, fuzzy membership function and fuzzy membership value are two different things, and the complement of a normal fuzzy set has to be defined accordingly. We shall further show how fuzzy randomness should be explained with reference to two laws of randomness defined for every fuzzy observation so as to make fuzzy statistical conclusions. Finally, we shall explain how randomness can be viewed as a special case of fuzziness defined in our perspective with reference to normal fuzzy numbers of the type [α, β, β]. Indeed every probability distribution function is a Dubois-Prade left reference function, and probability can be viewed in that way too.
References (28)
- L.Zadeh, "Fuzzy Sets", Information and Control, 1965, pp.338 -353.
- H.K.Baruah, "Set Superimposition and Its Application to the Theory of Fuzzy Sets", Journal of the Assam Science Society, 1999, pp.25 -31.
- K.Gödel, "On Formally Undecidable Propositions of Principia Mathematica and Related Systems", Translated by B. Meltzer, Dover Publications, N. Y., 1992, and included in Stephen Hawking (Ed), God Created the Integers: The Mathematical Breakthroughs That Changed History, Running Press, Philadelphia, 2005, 1931.
- A.K.Mahanta, F.A.Mazorbhuiya and H.K.Baruah, "Finding Calendar Based Periodic Patterns", Pattern Recognition Letters, 2008, pp.1274-1284.
- V.K.Rohatgi and A.K.Md.E.Saleh, "An Introduction to Probability and Statistics, Second Edition", Wiley Series in Probability and Statistics, John Wiley & Sons (Asia) Pte Ltd., Singapore, 2001.
- H.K.Baruah, "Fuzzy Membership with respect to a Reference Function", Journal of the Assam Science Society, 1999, pp.65 -73.
- M. Loeve, "Probability Theory", Springer Verlag, New York, 1977.
- H.K.Baruah, "The Randomness -Fuzziness Consistency Principle", International Journal of Energy, Information and Communications, 2010, pp.37 -48.
- H.K.Baruah, "Construction of the Membership Function of a Fuzzy Number", ICIC Express Letters, February, 2011, pp.545-549.
- H.K.Baruah, "In Search of the Root of Fuzziness: The Measure Theoretic Meaning of Partial Presence", In Press, Annals of Fuzzy Mathematics and Informatics, to appear in July, 2011.
- R.Chutia, S.Mahanta and H.K.Baruah, "An Alternative Method of Finding the Membership of a Fuzzy Number", International Journal of Latest Trends in Computing, 2010, pp.69 -72.
- S.Mahanta , R.Chutia and H.K.Baruah, "Fuzzy Arithmetic Without Using the Method of α -Cuts", International Journal of Latest Trends in Computing, 2010, pp.73 -80.
- S.Hawking, "Classical Theory, in Stephen Hawking and Roger Penrose (Editors)", The Nature of Space and Time, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 2000.
- L.Zadeh, "Probability Measures of Fuzzy Events", Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, 1968, pp.421 -427.
- L.Zadeh, "Fuzzy sets as a basis of theory of possibility", Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 1978, pp.3 -28
- G. J. Klir, "A Principle of Uncertainty and information invariance", International Journal of General Systems, 17, 1990, pp.249 -275.
- D.Dubois and H.Prade, "Scalar Evaluation of Fuzzy Sets: Overview and Applications", Applied Math. Letters, 1990, pp.37 -42.
- D.Dubois and H.Prade, "When upper probabilities are possibility measures", fuzzy sets and systems, 1992, 65 -74.
- D.Dubois and E.Hullermeier, "Comparing Probability Measures Using Possibility Theory: A Notion of Relative Peakedness", International Journal of Approximate Reasoning, 2007, pp.364 -385.
- H.K.Baruah, "Towards Forming a Field of Fuzzy Sets", International Journal of Energy, Information and Communications, February, 2011, pp.16-20.
- S.Roychoudhury and W.Pedrycz, "An Alternative Characterization of Fuzzy Complement Functional", Soft Computing -A Fusion of Foundations, Methodologies and Applications, 2003, pp.563 -565.
- J. V. Uspensky, "Introduction to Mathematical Probability", McGraw Hill Book Co., New York, 1937.
- J.J.Buckley and E.Eslami, "Uncertain Probabilities I: the Discrete Case, Soft Computing -A Fusion of Foundations", Methodologies and Applications, 2003, pp.500 -505.
- J.J. Buckley and E.Eslami, "Uncertain Probabilities II: the Continuous Case, Soft Computing -A Fusion of Foundations", Methodologies and Applications,2004, pp.193 -199.
- J.J. Buckley, "Uncertain Probabilities III: the Continuous Case, Soft Computing -A Fusion of Foundations", Methodologies and Applications, 2003, pp.200 -206.
- P.Goswami, P.Dutta and H.K.Baruah, "The Latin Square Design Using Fuzzy Data", The Journal of Fuzzy Mathematics, 1997, pp.767 -779.
- I.Guttman, S.S.Wilks and J.S.Hunter, "Introductory Engineering Statistics, Third Edition", John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1982.
- H.K. Baruah, "The Mathematics of Fuzziness: Myths and Realities", Lambert Academic Publishing, Saarbrücken, 2010.