Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Outline

Synthesis in nursing knowledge: an analysis of two approaches

1998, Journal of Advanced Nursing

https://doi.org/10.1046/J.1365-2648.1998.00553.X

Abstract

Synthesis in nursing knowledge: an analysis of two approaches The need for synthesis in nursing knowledge development has been attested to by many authors. It is consistent with nursing's holistic focus and is the mark of a mature discipline. This paper examines two approaches to synthesis: the use of multiple paradigms and the possible emergence of a new paradigm based on chaos theory. It argues that in their current form both approaches have flaws and neither achieves synthesis as it is here defined. However, both may make significant contributions to the development of nursing knowledge.

FAQs

sparkles

AI

What are the primary paradigms in nursing knowledge synthesis?add

Nursing knowledge is derived from logical positivism, interpretive paradigm, and critical theory, each providing distinct insights but struggling with integration due to inherent limitations.

How does chaos theory contribute to understanding nursing knowledge?add

Chaos theory suggests that human behavior in nursing is unpredictable yet structured, offering new modes of inquiry for synthesizing nursing knowledge amidst complex interactions.

What methodologies promote synthesis in nursing knowledge development?add

A four-phase methodology combining participant observation, surveys, and phenomenology has effectively produced integrated insights about the human-environment relationship in nursing.

What challenges are associated with blending qualitative and quantitative methods?add

Blending methodologies faces criticism due to contradictory underlying assumptions, making it difficult to achieve true synthesis without compromising rigor or outcomes.

Why is synthesis considered essential for the future of nursing?add

Synthesis is viewed as necessary for adapting nursing knowledge to evolving holistic perspectives, facilitating a unified understanding of nursing practice in a complex world.

References (23)

  1. B. Copnell paradigms for nursing research: a poststructuralist perspective. Nagle L.M. & Mitchell G.J. (1991) Theoretic diversity: evolving paradigmatic issues in research and practice. Advances in Advances in Nursing Science 11(4), 69-77.
  2. Emden C. (1991) Ways of knowing in nursing. In Towards a Nursing Science 14(1), 17-25.
  3. Newman M.A., Sime A.M. & Corcoran-Perry S.A. (1991) The focus Discipline of Nursing (Gray G. & Pratt R. eds), Churchill Livingstone, Melbourne, pp. 11-30. of the discipline of nursing. Advances in Nursing Science 14(1), 1-6.
  4. Firth W.J. (1991) Chaos -predicting the unpredictable. British Journal of Medicine 303, 1565-1568.
  5. Phenix P. (1964) Realms of Meaning. McGraw-Hill, New York.
  6. Phillips J.R. (1991) Chaos in nursing research. Nursing Science Gleick J. (1988) Chaos: Making a New Science. William Heinemann, London. Quarterly 4(3), 96-97.
  7. Phillips J.R. (1992) Order in chaos. Response: jaundiced eyes of Goodwin L.D. & Goodwin W.L. (1984) Qualitative vs. quantitative research or qualitative and quantitative research? Nursing linearity of eyes jaundiced. Nursing Science Quarterly 5(3), 107-111. Research 33(6), 378-380.
  8. Gregersen H. & Sailer L. (1993) Chaos theory and its implications Pool R. (1989a) Is it chaos, or is it just noise? Science 243, 25-28. Pool R. (1989b) Chaos theory: how big an advance? Science 245, for social science research. Human Relations 46(7), 777-802.
  9. Haase J.E. & Myers S.T. (1988) Reconciling paradigm assumptions 26-28.
  10. Powers B.A. (1987) Taking sides: a response to Goodwin and of qualitative and quantitative research. Western Journal of Nursing Research 10(2), 128-137. Goodwin. Nursing Research 36(2), 122-126.
  11. Puskar K., Hardin S.B. & Updike P. (1992) Order in chaos.
  12. Hamilton P., West B., Cherri M., Mackey J. & Fisher P. (1994) Preliminary evidence of nonlinear dynamics in births to ado- Commentary: chaos and the totality perspective. Nursing Science Quarterly 5(3), 107. lescents in Texas, 1964-1990. Theoretic And Applied Chaos In Nursing 1(1), 15-22.
  13. Rogers M. (1992) Nursing science and the space age. Nursing Science Quarterly 5(1), 27-34.
  14. Levenson E.A. (1994) The uses of disorder: chaos theory and psychoanalysis. Contemporary Psychoanalysis 30(1), 5-24.
  15. Schon D. (1983) The Reflective Practitioner. Basic Books, New York.
  16. Maliski S.L. & Holditch-Davis D. (1995) Linking biology and biography: complex nonlinear dynamical systems as a frame-Schultz P.R. (1987) Toward holistic inquiry in nursing: a proposal for synthesis of patterns and methods. Scholarly Inquiry for work for nursing enquiry. Complexity and Chaos in Nursing 2(1), 25-35. Nursing Practice 1(2), 135-146.
  17. Spruiell V. (1993) Deterministic chaos and the sciences of com- Mark B.A. (1994) Chaos theory and nursing systems research. Theoretic And Applied Chaos In Nursing 1(1), 7-14. plexity: psychoanalysis in the midst of a general scientific revol- ution. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association Meleis A.I. (1985) Theoretical Nursing: Development and Progress. J.B. Lippincott, Philadelphia. 41(1), 3-44.
  18. Stevenson J.S. (1988) Nursing knowledge development: into era Meleis A.I. (1987) ReVisions in knowledge development: a pas- sion for substance. Scholarly Inquiry for Nursing Practice II. Journal of Professional Nursing 4(3), 152-162.
  19. Tripp-Reimer T. (1985) Combining qualitative and quantitative 1(1), 5-19.
  20. Meleis A.I. (1992) Directions for nursing theory development in methodologies. In Qualitative Research Methods in Nursing (Leininger M. ed.), Grune and Stratton, Orlando, pp. 179-194. the 21st century. Nursing Science Quarterly 5(3), 112-117.
  21. Mitchell E.S. (1986) Multiple triangulation: a methodology for Vicenzi A.E. (1994) Chaos theory and some nursing consider- ations. Nursing Science Quarterly 7(1), 36-42. nursing science. Advances in Nursing Science 8(3), 18-26.
  22. Moccia P. (1988) A critique of compromise: beyond the methods Walters A.J. (1994) Phenomenology as a way of understanding in nursing. Contemporary Nurse 3(3), 134-141. debate. Advances in Nursing Science 10(4), 1-9.
  23. Murray P.J. (1992) Chaos theory -a useful addition to the critical care curriculum? Intensive and Critical Care Nursing 8, 240-244.