A mathematical model for optimal tuning systems
2008
Abstract
N THIS PAPER WE PROPOSE a mathematical framework for the optimization of tuning systems. We begin with an informal definition of “tuning system.” We then propose five general constraints that seem common to their evolution. The central idea of this paper is the quantification of those constraints in terms of a set of numerical parameters. Given a choice of parameter values we use appropriate optimization methods to produce an optimal tuning for a specific set of values. Finally, we consider some historical and Javanese tunings from ...
References (62)
- Arom, Simha. 2001. "Prolegomena to a Biomusicology." In Wallin, Merker, Brown, eds., The Origins of Music. Cambridge, Mas- sachusetts: MIT Press: 27-30.
- Balzano, Gerald. 1980. "The Group-Theoretic Description of 12-fold and Microtonal Pitch Systems." Computer Music Journal 4/4: 66-84.
- Barbour, James M. 1948. "Music and Ternary Continued Fractions." The American Mathematical Monthly 55/9: 545-555.
- ---. 1953. Tuning and Temperament: A Historical Survey. East Lansing: Michigan State College Press.
- Barlow, Clarence. 2001. "On the Quantification of Harmony and Metre." In Barlow, ed., The Ratio Book. Cologne: Feedback Papers 43: 2-23.
- Blackwood, Easley. 1985. The Structure of Recognizeable Diatonic Tun- ings. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
- Brinner, Benjamin. 2008. Music in Central Java. Oxford: Oxford Uni- versity Press.
- Brun, Vijjo. 1964. "Euclidean Algorithms and Musical Theory." L'En- seignement Mathématique 10: 125-137.
- Burns. Edward M., and W. Dixon Ward. 1982. "Intervals, Scales and Tuning." In Deutsch, Diana, ed., The Psychology of Music. New York: Academic Press.
- Burt, Warren. 2007. Algorithms, Microtonality, Performance: Eleven Musical Compositions. PhD Thesis, University of Wollongong, Aus- tralia.
- Carlos, Wendy. 1987. "Tuning at the Crossroads." Computer Music Journal 11/1: 29-43.
- Chalmers, John. 1974. "Some New Linear Temperaments." Xenhar- monikon 2.
- ---. 1993. Divisions of the Tetrachord. Lebanon, NH: Frog Peak Music.
- Donahue, Thomas. 2005. A Guide To Musical Temperament. Toronto: Scarecrow Press.
- Doty, David. 1993. The Just Intonation Primer. San Francisco: The Just Intonation Network.
- Dunne, Edward, and Mark McConnell. 1999. "Pianos and Continued Fractions." Mathematics Magazine 72/2: 104-115.
- Erlich, Paul. 1998. "Tuning, Tonality, and Twenty-two-tone Tempera- ment." Xenharmonikon 17 (Spring). Revised version: http:// lumma.org/tuning/erlich/erlich-decatonic.pdf.
- Fokker, Adriaan. 1987. Rasch, R., ed., Selected Musical Compositions. Rasch, R. (Ed.). Corpus Microtonale. Utrecht: The Diapason Press.
- Gräf, Albert. 2006. "On Musical Scale Rationalization." Proceedings of the International Computer Music Conference. Tulane University, New Orleans. ICMA Publication, 91-98.
- Harrison, Lou. 1971. Music Primer. New York: C.F. Peters.
- ---. 1985. "Thoughts About Slippery Slendro." Selected Reports in Ethnomusicology VI: 111-117.
- Hauser, Mare, and Josh McDermott. 2003. "The Evolution of the Music Faculty: A Comparative Perspective." Nature Neuroscience 6/7 (July): 663-668.
- Isacoff, Stuart. 2001. Temperament: The Idea That Solved Music's Great- est Riddle. New York: Knopf.
- Jairazbhoy, Nazir. 1971. The rãgs of North Indian Music: Their Struc- ture and Evolution. London: Faber and Faber.
- Jorgensen, Owen H. 1991. Tuning. East Lansing: Michigan State Uni- versity Press.
- Johnston, Ben. 1976-77. "Rational structure in music." American Soci- ety of University of Composers Proceedings I/II: 102-108.
- Keislar, Douglas. 1991. "Six American Composers on Nonstandard Tunings." Perspectives of New Music 29/1: 176-211.
- Keenan, David. 1999. "A Method for Optimally Distributing Any Comma." http://users.bigpond.net.au/d.keenan/Music/Distribut- ingCommas.htm. Accessed 26 Jan, 2009.
- Kraehenbuehl, David, and Christopher Schmidt. 1962. "On the Devel- opment of Musical Systems." Journal of Music Theory 6/1: 32-65.
- Krumhansl, Carol. 1987. "General Properties of Musical Pitch Systems: Some Psychological Considerations." In Sundberg, ed., Harmony and Tonality. Stockholm: Royal Academy of Music.
- ---. 1990. Cognitive Foundations of Musical Pitch. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Ledbetter, David. 2002. Bach's Well-tempered Clavier. New Haven: Yale University Press.
- Lerdahl, Fred. 1992. "Cognitive Constraints on Compositional Sys- tems." Contemporary Music Review 6/2: 97-121.
- Lindley, Mark, and Ronald Turner-Smith. 1993. Mathematical Models of Musical Scales. Bonn: Verlag für systematische Musikwissenschaft.
- Matthews, Max, and John Pierce. 1988. "Theoretical and Experimental Explorations of the Bohlen-Pierce Scale." Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 84: 1214-1222.
- Moreno, Enrique. 1992. Expanded Tunings in Contemporary Music. Studies in the History and Interpretation of Music 30. Lewiston (Eng- land): The Edwin Mellen Press.
- Pan, Wei, Micah K. Johnson, Larry Polansky, Daniel Rockmore, and Douglas Repetto. 2008. "OWT: A Real-Time Tuning Application." Proceedings of the International Computer Music Conference, Belfast, Ireland.
- Partch, Harry. 1949. Genesis of a Music. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press. Reprinted 1974. New York: Da Capo Press.
- Patel, Aniruddh. 2008. Music, Language and the Brain. New York: Oxford University Press.
- Perlman, Marc. 2004. Unplayed Melodies: Javanese Gamelan and the Genesis of Music Theory. Berkeley: University of California Press.
- Perlman, Marc, and Carol Krumhansl. 1996. "An Experimental Study of Internal Interval Standards in Javanese and Western Musicians." Music Perception 14: 95-116.
- Polansky, Larry. 1984. "Tuning Systems in American Gamelan, Part I: Interval sSzes in Javanese slendro." Balungan 1/2: 9-11.
- ---. 1987. "Paratactical Tuning: An Agenda for the Future Use of Computers in Experimental Intonation." Computer Music Journal 11/1: 61-68.
- ---. 1987b. "Item: Lou Harrison as a Speculative Theorist." In A Lou Harrison Reader. Soundings Press.
- ---. 2007. "Optimal Well-Temperament Examples." http://eamu- sic.dartmouth.edu/~larry/owt/Optimal_well_temperament_examples .html.
- Rasch, Rudolf, ed. 1983. Andreas Werckmeister, Musikalische Temper- atur (1691). Utrecht: Diapason Press.
- Rosser, John B. 1950. "Generalized Ternary Continued Fractions." The American Mathematical Monthly 57/8: 528-535.
- Rothenberg, David. 1978. "A Model for Pattern Perception with Musi- cal Applications, Part I: Pitch Structures as Order-Preserving Maps." Mathematical Systems Theory 11: 199-234.
- Sethares, William A. 1993. "Local Consonance and the Relationship Between Timbre and Scale." Journal of the Acoustical Society of Amer- ica 94/3: 1218-1228.
- ---. 1997. Tuning, Timbre, Spectrum, Scale. London: Springer- Verlag.
- Shepard, Roger. 1964. "Circularity in Judgments of Relative Pitch." Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 36: 2346-2353.
- ---. 1982. "Structural Representations of Musical Pitch." In Deutsch, Diana, ed., The Psychology of Music. New York: Academic Press.
- ---. 1987a. "General Properties of Musical Pitch Systems: Some Psychological Considerations." In Sundberg, ed., Harmony and Tonality. Stockholm: Royal Academy of Music.
- ---. 1987b. "Tonal and Harmonic Hierarchies." In Sundberg, ed. Harmony and Tonality. Stockholm: Royal Academy of Music.
- Sims, Ezra. 1987. "A 72-note just computer music system." 1/1, The Journal of the Just Intonation Network 5/1: 1, 9-14.
- Sumarsam. 1992. Gamelan. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
- Surjodiningrat, Wasisto., et al. 1972, English transation 1993. Penje- lidikan dalam pengukuran nada gamelan-gamelan djawa terkemuka di Jogjakarta dan Surakarta, translated by the authors as: Tone mea- surements of outstanding Javanese Gamelan. Yogyakarta: Gadjah Mada University Press.
- Tenney, James. 1987. "About 'Changes: Sixty-four Studies for Six Harps'." Perspectives of New Music. 25/1-2: 64-87.
- ---. 1988. A History of Consonance and Dissonance. New York: Excelsior Press.
- ---. 1992. "The Several Dimensions of Pitch." In Barlow, ed., The Ratio Book. Cologne: Feedback Papers 43, 102-115.
- Trehub, Sandra. 2001. "Human Processing Predispositions and Musical Universals." In Wallin, Merker, Brown eds., The Origins of Music. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press, 427-448.
- Yasser, Joseph. 1932. A Theory of Evolving Tonality. New York: Ameri- can Library of Musicology.