Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Outline

Title
Abstract
Background
The Study
Results
Summary
Discussion
References
All Topics
Psychology
Cognitive Psychology

The role of visualization in learning from computer‐based images

Profile image of Stephen ReynoldsStephen Reynolds

2005, International Journal of Science Education

https://doi.org/10.1080/09500690412331314478
visibility

…

description

15 pages

link

1 file

Abstract

Among the sciences, the practice of geology is especially visual. To assess the role of spatial ability in learning geology, we designed an experiment using: (1) web-based versions of spatial visualization tests, (2) a geospatial test, and (3) multimedia instructional modules built around QuickTime Virtual Reality movies. Students in control and experimental sections were administered measures of spatial orientation and visualization, as well as a content-based geospatial examination. All subjects improved significantly in their scores on spatial visualization and the geospatial examination. There was no change in their scores on spatial orientation. A three-way analysis of variance, with the geospatial examination as the dependent variable, revealed significant main effects favoring the experimental group and a significant interaction between treatment and gender. These results demonstrate that spatial ability can be improved through instruction, that learning of geological content will improve as a result, and that differences in performance between the genders can be eliminated.

Related papers

The Hidden Earth-Interactive, computer-based modules for geoscience learning
Stephen Reynolds

SPECIAL PAPERS- …, 2006

Geology is among the most visual of the sciences, with spatial reasoning taking place at various scales and in various contexts. Among the spatial skills required in introductory college geology courses are spatial rotation (rotating objects in one's mind) and spatial visualization (transforming an object in one's mind). Geologic curricula commonly require students to visualize the earth in many ways, such as envisioning landscapes from topographic maps, the interaction of layers and topography, and the progressive development of geologic features over time. To facilitate learning in introductory college geology laboratories, we created two geologic modules-Visualizing Topography and Interactive 3D Geologic Blocks. The modules were developed as learning cycles, where students explore first, are then introduced to terminology and concepts they have observed, and finally apply their knowledge to different, but related problems. Both modules were built around interactive QuickTime Virtual Reality movies, which contain landforms and geologic objects that students can manipulate on the computer screen. The topography module pairs topographic maps with their 3D representations on the same screen, to encourage students to visualize two-dimensional maps as threedimensional landscapes and to match corresponding features on the map and 3D perspective.

View PDFchevron_right
Are Realistic Or Are Abstract Visual Representations More Effective Tools In Technology-Based Geosciences Education?
Jolin Qutub

Journal of Arts and Humanities

In this study, the researchers developed two visual representations for use in the geosciences context. One of the study’s goals was to demonstrate the educational value of distinguishing realistic from abstract visual representations in order to explore which type of representation most improves students’ cognitive understanding and learning of science. Four 4th-grade students were observed and videotaped while interacting with the developed representations. The researchers used the results to develop recommendations regarding useful pedagogical imagery.

View PDFchevron_right
Effect of instruction on spatial visualization ability in civil engineering students
Maizam Alias

International Education Journal, 2002

Spatial visualisation ability is a subset of spatial ability-one of the factors of human intelligence structure. Spatial visualisation ability has been defined as," the ability to mentally manipulate, rotate, twist, or invert pictorially presented stimulus objects."(McGee, 1979, p. 893). This multi-faceted ability helps engineers including civil engineers to conceptualise links between reality and the abstract model of that reality. For example, in the analysis of a loaded beam structure, the deflected shape of the beam is the reality and the ...

View PDFchevron_right
Evaluating Geoscience Students' Spatial Thinking Skills in a Multi-Institutional Classroom Study
Alexander P Boone, Carol Ormand, Thomas Shipley

Journal of Geoscience Education, 2014

Spatial thinking skills are critical to success in many subdisciplines of the geosciences. We tested students' spatial skills in geoscience courses at three institutions (a public research university, a comprehensive university, and a liberal arts college, all in the midwest) over a two-year period. We administered standard psychometric tests of spatial skills to students in introductory geology, mineralogy, sedimentology and stratigraphy, hydrogeology, structural geology, and tectonics courses. In addition, in some courses we administered a related spatial skills test with geoscience content. In both introductory and upper level undergraduate geology courses, students' skills vary enormously as measured by several spatial thinking instruments. Additionally, students' spatial skills generally improve only slightly during one academic term, in both introductory and advanced geoscience classes. More unexpectedly, while there was a tendency for high-performing students to be adept at multiple spatial skills, many individual students showed strong performance on tests of one spatial skill (e.g., rotation) but not on others (e.g., penetrative thinking). This result supports the contention that spatial problem solving requires a suite of spatial skills, and no single test is a good predictor of ''spatial thinking.'' Ó

View PDFchevron_right
Developing the spatial visualization ability with a virtual reality tool for teaching descriptive geometry: a Brazilian experience
Eduardo Toledo Santos

Journal For Geometry and Graphics, 2013

ABSTRACT Due to the difficulty in understanding and learning descriptive geometry, combined with the lack of development of spatial abilities of most freshmen in engineering courses, an innovative tool based on virtual reality techniques was developed to support teaching the theme. The central hypothesis tested was whether the use of modern stereoscopic systems in the teaching-learning process facilitates visualization and understanding of complex spatial situations and therefore supports the development of spatial cognition of students, especially of those with less ability. In general, the three student groups analysed showed improvements in the development of their spatial skills (p<0·001). However, a statistically significant difference could not be detected by the analysis of average gains offered by the different treatments used in the experimental research.

View PDFchevron_right
1 Using Geovisualizations in the Curriculum: Do Multimedia Tools Enhance Geography Education?
Michelle Kinzel

2015

Abstract: The field of geography has been transformed in recent years through the use of spatial tools such as geographic information systems (GIS) satellite and acoustic remote sensing, the global positioning system (GPS), Internet mapping and more. Studying geography and earth science in the digital age now requires a sophisticated and complex integration of concepts that include spatial and temporal aspects (Harrower, et al., 2000). Using the same tools and data sets as earth scientists, students can explore spatial patterns, linkages, trends and processes on a local, regional or global scale. Despite our capabilities and advances, many questions remain about how to use these new geospatial tools and apply representational techniques to problem solving and knowledge construction. Particularly in educational settings, the potential of applying tools and techniques in problem-solving exercises remains largely under utilized. This paper examines the application of multimedia technol...

View PDFchevron_right
The Virtual Exploratorium: Foundational Research and Theory on the Integration of 5-D Modeling and Visualization in Undergraduate Geoscience Education
Kenneth Hay

International Conference of the Learning Sciences, 2013

The Virtual Exploratorium is a collaborative development project funded by the National Science Foundation to develop a theoretical and operational framework to promote highend visualization, modeling, and data in the support of education. This paper reports on the theoretical framework and three research studies that have been conducted to support the development of the Virtual Exploratorium.

View PDFchevron_right
Evaluation of the Spatial Visualization Ability of Entering Students in a Brazilian Engineering Course
Eduardo Toledo Santos

Journal for Geometry and …, 2008

Graphical Engineering and its applications require advanced abilities of visualization. The visualization ability and spatial reasoning are essential qualities for engineers due to their importance in the process of graphical communication and these professionals' need for solving spatial geometric problems. Yet, there is still no consensus on the exact components that constitute spatial visualization ability. Questions related to increasing students' spatial aptitude have motivated research on evaluation methods, as well as on the existing differences between males and females. Besides gender, differences in the spatial visualization ability and its acquisition have been attributed to a number of variables, including age, cognitive development, spatial experiences and genetic evolution. This work describes an experiment carried on through the execution of a computerized battery of two spatial visualization tests (Mental Rotation Test -MRT and Test de Visualización -TVZ), with the purpose of evaluating the entering students' spatial visualization ability in the Engineering courses of the Escola Politécnica of the University of São Paulo and to verify the existing differences between age groups and between genders, as well to analyze the behavior of the performance of the participants in the tests by testing some hypotheses.

View PDFchevron_right
The Role of Visuospatial Ability in Developing Mental Models during Geologic Mapping
Heather Petcovic, Kathleen Baker

Geologic mapping draws heavily on 3D visualization, as the geologist must navigate through unfamiliar terrain, observing and interpreting scattered surface rock outcrops to create an accurate mental representation of the 3D subsurface geology. The geologist must then transfer a 3D mental representation onto a 2D geologic map. Geological knowledge is critical to success in this type of mapping; without, for example, correct identification of lithologies or correct interpretation of structural or stratigraphic features, the geologist cannot produce an accurate map. Presumably, visuospatial ability also plays a key role in geologic mapping. Not only does the geologist have to negotiate between the map and the physical field environment, but he or she must imagine how isolated surface rock outcrops relate to one another at depth.

View PDFchevron_right
Using Courseware Instruction to Improve Junior High School Students’ Spatial Visualization Skills
isaac owusu-darko

Journal on Mathematics Education, 2017

This study basically focused on the use of instruction to assist Junior High School (JHS 1) students at Dodowa Presbyterian Basic School (Ghana), to achieve high spatial visualization skills which will eventually translate into their mathematics achievement. The test instrument used for the data collection was an adapted form of the Middle Grades Mathematics Project (MGMP) spatial visualization test which comprised of 40 items with an internal consistency reliability of 0.81. The simple random sampling technique was used to assign 50 students to control and experimental groups. Pretest-posttest control group design was employed for the study. A paired-sample t-test and split plot ANOVA were used to analyze the data. The results showed that even though there was some improvement in spatial visualization skills across board (both control and experimental groups), there was a statistically significant improvement in spatial visualization skills among the experimental group. The study a...

View PDFchevron_right

References (35)

  1. BEN-CHAIM, D., LAPPAN, G. and HOUANG, R. (1988). The effect of instruction on spatial visualization skills of middle school boys and girls. American Educational Research Journal, 25, 51-71.
  2. CARTER, C., LARUSSA, M. and BODNER, G. (1987). A study of two measures of spatial ability as predictors of success in different levels of general chemistry. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 24(7), 645-657.
  3. COHEN, H. (1983). A comparison of the effect of two types of student behavior with manipulatives on the development of projective spatial structures. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 20(9), 875-883.
  4. COLEMAN, S. and GOTCH, A. (1998). Spatial perception skills of chemistry students. Journal of Chemical Education, 75, 206-209.
  5. DEVON, R., ENGEL, R. and TURNER, G. (1998). The effects of spatial visualization skill training on gender and retention in engineering. Journal of Women and Minorities in Science and Engineering, 4, 371-380.
  6. EKSTROM, R., FRENCH, J., HARMAN, H. and DERMEN, D. (1976). Manual for Kit of Factor Referenced Cognitive Tests (Princeton, NJ: Educational Testing Service).
  7. ELEY, M. (1993). The differential susceptibility of topographic map interpretation to influence from training. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 7, 23-42.
  8. HSI, S., LINN, M. and BELL, J. (1997). The role of spatial reasoning in engineering and the design of spatial instruction. Journal of Engineering Education, 86, 151-158.
  9. KALI, Y. and ORION, N. (1996). Spatial abilities of high-school students and the perception of geologic structures. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 33(4), 369-391.
  10. LORD, T. (1985). Enhancing the visuo-spatial aptitude of students. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 22(5), 395-405.
  11. LORD, T. (1987). A look at spatial abilities in undergraduate women science majors. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 24(8), 757-767.
  12. MACCOBY, E. and JACKLIN, C. (1974). The Psychology of Sex Differences (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press).
  13. MANN, D., SHAKESHAFT, C., BECKER, A.J. and KOTTKAMP, R. (1999). West Virginia Story: Achievement Gains from a Statewide Comprehensive Instructional Technology Program (Santa Monica, CA: Milken Exchange on Education Technology).
  14. MCCLURG, P. (1992). Investigating the development of spatial cognition in problem-solving microworlds. Journal of Computing in Childhood Education, 3(2), 111-126.
  15. MUEHLBERGER, W.L. and BOYER, R.E. (1961). Space relations test as a measure of visualization ability. Journal of Geological Education, 9, 62-69.
  16. O'SULLIVAN, C. and WEISS, A. (1999). Student Work and Teacher Practices in Science: A Report on What Students Know and Can Do (NCES 1999-445) (Jessup, MD: National Center for Educational Statistics).
  17. PAIVIO, A. (1990). Mental Representations: A Dual Coding Approach (New York: Oxford University Press).
  18. PALLRAND, G. and SEEBER, F. (1984). Spatial ability and achievement in introductory physics. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 21(5), 507-516.
  19. PIAGET, J. and INHELDER, B. (1967). The Child's Conception of Space (New York: Norton).
  20. PIBURN, M. (1980). Spatial reasoning as a correlate of formal thought and science achievement for New Zealand students. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 17(5), 443-448.
  21. PROVO, J., LAMAR, C. and NEWBY, T. (2002). Using a cross section to train veterinary students to visualize anatomical structures in three dimensions. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 39, 10-34.
  22. RAVITZ, J., MERGENDOLLER, J. and RUSS, W. (2002). What's school got to do with it? Cautionary tales about correlations between student computer use and academic achievement. Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, LA.
  23. REYNOLDS, S.J., JOHNSON, J.K. and STUMP, E. (2001). Observing and Interpreting Geology: A Laboratory Manual for Introductory Geology (Tucson, AZ: Terra Chroma).
  24. RIEBER, L.P. (1995). A historical review of visualization in human cognition. Educational Technology Research and Development, 43(1), 45-56.
  25. ROE, A. (1961). The psychology of the scientist. Science, 134, 456-459.
  26. SCHOFIELD, J. and KIRBY, J. (1994). Position location on topographical maps: Effects of task factors, training, and strategies. Cognition and Instruction, 12(1), 35-60.
  27. SHEPARD, R. (1978). The mental image. American Psychologist, 33, 125-137.
  28. SHEPARD, R. (1988). The Imagination of the scientist. In K. Egan and D. Nadaner (eds.) Imagination and Education (New York: Teachers' College Press), 153-185.
  29. SHEPARD, R. and CHIPMAN, S. (1970). Second order isomorphism of representations: Shapes of states. Cognitive Psychology, 1, 1-17.
  30. SHEPARDLER, R. and METZLER, J. (1971). Mental rotation of three-dimensional objects. Science, 171, 701-703.
  31. TUCKEY, H. and M. SELVARATNAM (1993). Studies involving three-dimensional visualization skills in chemistry: A review. Studies in Science Education, 21, 99-121.
  32. VASTA, R., KNOTT, J. and GAZE, C. (1996). Can spatial training erase the gender differences on the water-level task? Psychology of Women Quarterly, 20(4), 459-567.
  33. WEGLINSKY, H. (1998). Does it compute? The relationship between educational technology and student achievement in mathematics. Policy Information Report, Educational Testing Service, Princeton, NJ.
  34. WITKIN, H., MOORE, C., GOODENOUGH, D. and COX, P. (1977). Field dependent and field independent cognitive style and their educational implications. Review of Educational Research, 47, 1-64.
  35. ZAVOTKA, S. (1987). Three-dimensional computer animated graphics: A tool for spatial instruction. Educational Communications and Technology Journal, 35(3), 133-144.

Related papers

The comparative efficacy of 2D- versus 3D-based media design for influencing spatial visualization skills
Chun-Yen Chang

This study explored the effects of 2D-versus 3D-based media representations on the influence of the spatial visualization ability of undergraduate science majors. A pre-test/post-test comparisongroup experiment was conducted with 23 participants involved in the study. Participating students were randomly assigned either to the interactive 3D media representation group (n = 13) or the conventional 2D media representation group (n = 10); learning materials in both groups deliver the same information to students, but employ different media representations. All the activities were performed in a self-paced, web-based instructional system. The results of ANCOVA analysis showed statistically insignificant difference between groups in terms of students' post-test scores on the spatial visualization ability test with the students' pre-test scores as the covariate. However, a medium effect size was observed in favor of the 3D group in terms of practical significance. As a pilot study with a small sample size aiming to probe the research direction of this problem, the result of mediumsized effect magnitude is likely to implicate that the discrepancy of different representational design on students' performance of spatial ability assessment is noteworthy. Future study of this nature appears to merit further replications and investigations.

View PDFchevron_right
Visualization techniques in field geology education: A case study from western Ireland
Martin Feely, Declan G De Paor, Steve Whitmeyer, Shelley Whitmeyer, Jeremy Nicoletti

Geological Society of America Special Papers, 2009

Geoscience students often have diffi culty interpreting real-world spatial relationships from traditional two-dimensional geologic maps. This can be partly addressed with direct, tactile fi eld experiences, although three-dimensional (3-D) cognition can still be hampered by incomplete exposure of all spatial dimensions. Many of these barriers can be overcome by incorporating computer-based, virtual 3-D visualizations within undergraduate fi eld-oriented curricula. Digital fi eld equipment is fast becoming a standard tool in environmental, engineering, and geoscience industries, in part because of the increased accessibility of ruggedized computers equipped with global positioning system (GPS) receivers. Handheld computers with geo graphic information systems (GIS) software record and display data in real time, which on January 8, 2010 specialpapers.gsapubs.org Downloaded from

View PDFchevron_right
Spatial abilities of high-school students in the perception of geologic structures
Nir Orion

Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 1996

The specific spatial abilities required for the study of basic structural geology were characterized by quantitative and qualitative data analysis. A geologic spatial ability test (GeoSAT) was developed and administered to 115 comprehensive high-school students. Six of these students were interviewed. An analysis of students' incorrect answers revealed two types of answers: (a) nonpenetrative answers, which were based on external exposures of the structure; and (b) penetrative answers, which indicated attempts at representing internal properties of the structure. Students who tended to give penetrative incorrect answers performed significantly higher than students who tended to give nonpenetrative incorrect answers. The reasoning of students for these types of answers, as determined by interviews, supported the initial assumption that these answers were given by students with different levels of ability mentally to penetrate the image of a structure, which was named visual penetration ability (VPA). The interview findings indicated that the VPA is one of two complementary factors needed to solve the problems of GeoSAT; the other factor is the ability to perceive the spatial configuration of the structure. It is concluded that the teaching and learning process should provide students with assistance in both of these areas. 1. What are the typical answers students give in solving such problems? 2. What are students' reasoning behind different types of answers? 1. Cronbach's a reliability coefficient for the whole test was .90, with a range from .71 to .84 in the three subtests.

View PDFchevron_right
The Spatial Thinking Workbook: A Research-Validated Spatial Skills Curriculum for Geology Majors
LAUREL GOODWIN

Journal of Geoscience Education

Spatial visualization is an essential prerequisite for understanding geological features at all scales, such as the atomic structures of minerals, the geometry of a complex fault system, or the architecture of sedimentary deposits. Undergraduate geoscience majors bring a range of spatial skill levels to upper-level courses. Fortunately, spatial thinking improves with practice, and students benefit from intentional training. Several promising teaching strategies have emerged from recent cognitive science research into spatial thinking: gesturing, predictive sketching, and comparison, including analogy and alignment. Geoscience educators have traditionally incorporated many of these tools in their teaching, though not always consciously, intentionally, and in the most effective ways. Our research team, composed of geoscientists and cognitive psychologists, has collaborated to develop curricular materials for mineralogy, structural geology, and sedimentology and stratigraphy courses that incorporate these strategies intentionally and purposefully, supporting student understanding of the spatially challenging concepts and skills in these courses. Collectively, these two dozen learning activities comprise the Spatial Thinking Workbook (http://serc.carleton.edu/spatialworkbook/index.html). Pre-to posttest gains on a suite of assessment instruments, as well as embedded assessments, show that these curricular materials boost students' spatial thinking skills and strengthen their ability to solve geological problems with a spatial component.

View PDFchevron_right
The Hidden Earth: Visualization of Geologic Features and Their Subsurface Geometry
Julia Johnson, Carla McAuliffe, James Birk

annual meeting of the …, 2002

Geology is among the most visual of the sciences, with spatial reasoning taking place at various scales and in various contexts. Among the spatial skills required in introductory college geology courses are spatial rotation (rotating objects in one's mind), and visualization (transforming an object in one's mind). To assess the role of spatial ability in geology, we designed an experiment using (1) web-based versions of spatial visualization tests, (2) a geospatial test, and (3) multimedia instructional modules built around innovative QuickTime Virtual Reality (QTVR) movies.

View PDFchevron_right

Related topics

  • Geology
  • Computer Science
  • Visualization
  • Science Education
  • Spatial ability
  • Geospatial Analysis
  • Spatial Orientation
  • Curriculum and Pedagogy
  • Spatial Visualization

    • Cited by

    Internet-based Science Learning: A review of journal publications
    Hisham Rabie

    International Journal of Science Education, 2011

    View PDFchevron_right
    Developing the use of visual representations to explain basic astronomy phenomena
    Irene Marzoli

    Physical Review Physics Education Research

    View PDFchevron_right
    Finding That College Students Cluster in Majors Based on Differing Patterns of Spatial Visualization and Language Processing Speeds
    Richard Oldrieve

    SAGE Open

    For over 30 years, researchers such as Eisenberg and McGinty have investigated the relationship between 3-D visualization skills and choice of college major. Results of the present study support the fact that science and math majors tend to do well on a measure of 3-D visualization. Going beyond these earlier studies, the present study investigated whether a measure of Rapid Automatic Naming of Objects-which is normally used to screen for elementary school students who might struggle with speech, language, literacy, and numeracy-would further differentiate the choice of majors by college students. Far more research needs to be conducted, but results indicated that college students differentially clustered in scatterplot quadrants defined by the two screening assessments. Furthermore, several of these clusters, plus a statistical multiplier, may lead to a new understanding of students with phonological processing differences, learning disabilities, and speech and language impairments.

    View PDFchevron_right
    Improving spatial thinking skills among undergraduate geology students through short online training exercises
    Philip M . Pendergast

    International Journal of Science Education, 2018

    Spatial reasoning is a critical skill in the Geosciences. Using a randomized control study with 592 undergraduate students enrolled in introductory and advanced Geology courses, our data indicates that regular, short interventions throughout an academic semester improve students' spatial thinking skills significantly with a moderate to large effect size when compared to an instructionas-usual control group. We found evidence for additional gains in students who participated also in hands-on training interventions. We found even larger training effects on students who achieved correct scores of >50% on the practice modules, with gains of almost three-quarter of a standard deviation relative to their baseline scores. Male and female students display significant differences in spatial skills, with males outperforming females. Training resulted in similar magnitudes of improvement in both genders, so we see no evidence that the interventions closed the gender gap. Using the initial performance as a baseline, poor performers' spatial skills appear to improve through practice at the same rate as their peers. We argue that 15.4% of students improve their spatial skills through participation in the training towards a threshold that appears to be critical for participation in STEM careers. On a reflection survey, half of the students reported that they felt their spatial thinking skills improved through their participation, and over a third found the training beneficial for their overall learning in Geology or other classes. We hypothesise that formal training opportunities for spatial reasoning could increase the potential pool of students who successfully enter and succeed in Geoscience careers.

    View PDFchevron_right
    Conceptualizing Spatial Abilities and Their Relation to Science Learning from a Cognitive Perspective
    Fang-Ying Yang

    Journal of Baltic Science Education, 2020

    Science learning requires visuospatial thinking. Accordingly, spatial ability is regarded as the key to learning science well, but its effects are sometimes not as significant as expected. To this end, this research aims to conceptualize spatial abilities and to clarify their relation to science learning based on an analysis of empirical studies. Content analysis of 39 studies showed that (1) intrinsic-dynamic skills are the most frequently measured, (2) the explored science topics mostly involve well-established knowledge, (3) the effects of spatial ability on science achievement are inconsistent, and (4) educational interventions are not always effective in improving students’ spatial abilities or science achievement. It is argued that domain knowledge interferes with the study results and that domain-specific spatial ability exists, referring to apply spatial-type and domain-specific knowledge. Supported by cognitive theories and empirical evidence, a model is constructed to exhi...

    View PDFchevron_right
    580 California St., Suite 400
    San Francisco, CA, 94104
    © 2025 Academia. All rights reserved