Global resilience analysis of water distribution systems
2016, Water Research
https://doi.org/10.1016/J.WATRES.2016.10.011Abstract
Evaluating and enhancing resilience in water infrastructure is a crucial step towards more sustainable urban water management. As a prerequisite to enhancing resilience, a detailed understanding is required of the inherent resilience of the underlying system. Differing from traditional risk analysis, here we propose a global resilience analysis (GRA) approach that shifts the objective from analysing multiple and unknown threats to analysing the more identifiable and measurable system responses to extreme conditions, i.e. potential failure modes. GRA aims to evaluate a system's resilience to a possible failure mode regardless of the causal threat(s) (known or unknown, external or internal). The method is applied to test the resilience of four water distribution systems (WDSs) with various features to three typical failure modes (pipe failure, excess demand, and substance intrusion). The study reveals GRA provides an overview of a water system's resilience to various failure modes. For each failure mode, it identifies the range of corresponding failure impacts and reveals extreme scenarios (e.g. the complete loss of water supply with only 5% pipe failure, or still meeting 80% of demand despite over 70% of pipes failing).GRA also reveals that increased resilience to one failure mode may decrease resilience to another and increasing system capacity may delay the system's recovery in some situations. It is also shown that selecting an appropriate level
References (22)
- Albert, R., Jeong, H. and Barabási A. L. (2000). "Error and attack tolerance of complex networks". Nature, 406, 378-382.
- Ahern, J. (2011). From fail-safe to safe-to-fail: sustainability and resilience in the new urban world. Landscape, 100, 341-343.
- ASCE Policy Statement 518. (2006) http://www.asce.org/issues-and-advocacy/public- policy/policy-statement-518---unified-definitions-for-critical-infrastructure-resilience/ Accessed on Feb 10, 2015.
- Berardi, L., R. Ugarelli, J. Røstum, and O. Giustolisi (2014). "Assessing mechanical vulnerability in water distribution networks under multiple failures". Water Resour. Res., 50, 2586-2599, doi:10.1002/2013WR014770. Resources Planning and Management, Special Issue on The Battle of Background Leakage Assessment for Water Networks, accepted.
- European Union (Drinking Water) Regulations 2014. S.I. No. 122 of 2014. The Stationery Office, Dublin. Available from: https://www.fsai.ie/uploadedFiles/Legislation/Food_Legisation_Links/Water/SI122_201
- pdf Francis, R. and Bekera, B. (2014). "A metric and frameworks for resilience analysis of engineered and infrastructure systems". Reliability Engineering and SystemSafety, 121, 90-103.
- Gheisi, A. and Naser, G. (2014). "Water distribution system reliability under simultaneous multicomponent failure scenario". Journal -American Water Works Association, 106(7), E319
- Giustolisi, O., Berardi, L., Laucelli, D., Savic, D., Kapelan, Z. (2015). "Operational and Tactical Management of Water and Energy Resources in Pressurized Systems: the competition at WDSA 2014". Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, Special Issue on The Battle of Background Leakage Assessment for Water Networks [doi: 10.1061/(ASCE)WR.1943-5452.
- He, S., Li, S and Ma, H. (2009). "Effect of edge removal on topological and functional robustness of complex networks". Physica A 388 (2009) 2243-2253.
- Hokstad, Per, Utne, Ingrid B., Vatn, Jørn.(2013). Risk and Interdependencies in Critical Infrastructures. Chapters 5 and 6, 49-94, Springer.
- Holme, P and Kim, B (2002). "Attack vulnerability of complex networks". PHYSICAL REVIEW E, 65, 056109-1-14.
- Hughes, J. F. and Healy, K (2014). "Measuring the resilience of transport infrastructure". NZ Transport Agency research report 546. AECOM New Zealand Ltd.
- Johansson, J. (2007). Risk and Vulnerability Analysis of Large-Scale Technical Infrastructures: Electrical Distribution Systems. Doctoral dissertation, Lund University, Sweden. Johansson, J., and Henrik, H. (2010). "An approach for modelling interdependent infrastructures in the context of vulnerability analysis". Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 95, 1335-1344.
- Johansson, J., Henrik, H., and Zio, E. (2013). "Reliability and vulnerability analyses of critical infrastructures: Comparing two approaches in the context of power systems". Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 120, 27-38.
- Kanta, L. and Brumbelow, K. (2013)."Vulnerability, Risk, and Mitigation Assessment of Water Distribution Systems for Insufficient Fire Flows." J. Water Resour. Plann.Manage., 139(6), 593-603.
- Kanta, L (2006). Vulnerability Assessment of Water Supply SystemsFor Insufficient Fire Flows. Master thesis, Texas A&M University.
- Marchi, A., Salomons, E., Ostfeld, A., Kapelan, Z., Simpson, A., Zecchin, A., Maier, H., Wu, Z., Elsayed, S., Song, Y., Walski, T., Stokes, C., Wu, W., Dandy, G., Alvisi, S., Creaco, E., Franchini, M., Saldarriaga, J., Páez, D., Hernández, D., Bohórquez, J., Bent, R., Coffrin, C., Judi, D., McPherson, T., van Hentenryck, P., Matos, J., Monteiro, A., Matias, N., Yoo, D., Lee, H., Kim, J., Iglesias-Rey, P., Martínez-Solano, F., Mora-Meliá, D., Ribelles-Aguilar, J., Guidolin, M., Fu, G., Reed, P., Wang, Q., Liu, H., McClymont, K., Johns, M., Keedwell, E., Kandiah, V., Jasper, M., Drake, K., Shafiee, E., Barandouzi, Vassiljev, A., Kim, J.H., Chung, G., Yoo, D.G., Diao K.G., Zhou, Y.W., Li, J., Liu, Z.L., Chang, K., Gao, J., Qu, S., Yuan, Y., Prasad, T.D., Laucelli, D., VamvakeridouLyroudia, L.S., Kapelan, Z., Savic, D., Berardi, L., Barbaro, G., Giustolisi, O., Asadzadeh, M., Tolson, B.A., and McKillop, R. (2012). "The Battle of the Water Calibration Networks (BWCN)". Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, ASCE. 138(5), 523- 532.
- Pickett, S.T.A., McGrath, B., Cadenasso, M.L. &Felson, A.J. (2014). "Ecological resilience and resilient cities." Building Research & Information, 42, 2, 143-15
- Rossman, L. A. (2000). EPANET 2 USERS MANUAL. U.S. Environmental protection agency, Cincinnati.
- Rossman, L. and Boulos, P. (1996). "Numerical Methods for Modeling Water Quality in Distribution Systems: A Comparison." J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage., 122(2), 137- 146.
- Sitzenfrei R, Mair M, Möderl M, and Rauch W. (2011). "Cascade vulnerability for risk analysis of water infrastructure." Water Sci Technol., 64(9), 1885-1891.
- Zechman, M. (2011). "Agent-Based Modeling to Simulate Contamination Events and Evaluate Threat Management Strategies in Water Distribution Systems". Risk Analysis, 31(5), 759-772.