Book Review: Climate Change as Social Drama: Global Warming in the Public Sphere
The Sociological Review, May 1, 2016
problem’, are concealed (p. 192). Ultimately, for Macnicol, discrimination is socially constructe... more problem’, are concealed (p. 192). Ultimately, for Macnicol, discrimination is socially constructed, it changes its meaning according to political narratives, and in our current meritocratic and competitive neoliberal world it is particularly precarious as ‘we are in effect discriminating against our future selves’ (p. 178). It is this notion of the social construction of meaning that serves as critique of Macnicol. The analysis presented is evidently Marxist in persuasion, and draws upon a top-down mode of power. There are substantial references to the ways in which governments impose ageing policies on the masses according to a neoliberal agenda, and the masking of inequalities between the rich and poor. Whilst this is insightful, it does not truly reflect the force of the neoliberal discourse upon the human populace, specifically those in old age. A historical and political analysis is useful for understanding the impact of neoliberalism upon the ageing population and wider society but it takes a very particular view, and fails to comprehend the extent to which this ideology has, since the late 1970s, shaped the thinking of people. A Foucauldian analysis, linked to the concept of ‘biopolitics’, and following a bottom-up approach to the understanding of the functions of power, would have enabled a more in-depth examination of this, providing a rationale as to why individuals in democratic countries such as the UK and USA largely accept restricting policies with little active resistance, why there are intergenerational conflicts between the young and the old, linked to Beck’s and Beck-Gernsheim’s (2001) modernity thesis, and why the meaning of discrimination has altered. However, I believe this current work on neoliberalism and ageing policy to be invaluable for academics and students alike, as it is comprehensive in scale and offers, in the conclusion, viable ways forward to combat inequalities. It raises important questions about the future, specifically in relation to the treatment of older people; something which we all have an invested interest in and cannot now ignore.
Uploads
Papers by Daniel J Welch